Peer Review #2 of "design of New Acid-Activated Cell-Penetrating Peptides for Tumor Drug Delivery (V0.1)"

Jia Yao,Yinyun Ma,Wei Zhang,Li,Yun Zhang,Li Zhang,Hui Liu,Jingman Ni,Rui Wang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.7287/peerj.3429v0.1/reviews/2
2017-01-01
Abstract:TH(AGYLLGHINLHHLAHL(Aib)HHIL-NH 2 ), a histidine-rich, cell-penetrating peptide with acidactivated pH response, designed and synthesized by our group, can effectively target tumor tissues with an acidic extracellular environment.Since the protonating effect of histidine plays a critical role in the acid-activated, cell-penetrating ability of TH, we designed a series of new histidine substituents by introducing electron donating groups (Ethyl, Isopropyl, Butyl) to the C-2 position of histidine.This resulted in an enhanced pHresponse and improved the application of TH in tumor-targeted delivery systems.The substituents were further utilized to form the corresponding TH analogs (Ethyl-TH, Isopropyl-TH and Butyl-TH), making them easier to protonate for positive charge in acidic tumor microenvironments.The pH-dependent cellular uptake efficiencies of new TH analogs were further evaluated using flow cytometry and confocal laser scanning microscopy, demonstrating that ethyl-TH and butyl-TH had an optimal pH-response in an acidic environment.Importantly, the new TH analogs exhibited relatively lower toxicity than TH.In addition, these new TH analogs were linked to the antitumor drug camptothecin (CPT), while butyl-TH modified conjugate presented a remarkably stronger pH-dependent cytotoxicity to cancer cells than TH and the other conjugates.In short, our work opens a new avenue for the development of improved acid-activated, cellpenetrating peptides as efficient anticancer drug delivery vectors.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?