Open Community Challenge Reveals Molecular Network Modules with Key Roles in Diseases

Sarvenaz Choobdar,Ahsen Me,Jake Crawford,Mattia Tomasoni,Tao Fang,David Lamparter,Lin J,Benjamin Hescott,Xin Hu,Johnathan Mercer,Ted Natoli,Rajiv Narayan,Ayshwarya Subramanian,Zhang Jd,Gustavo Stolovitzky,Zoltán Kutalik,Kasper Lage,Donna K. Slonim,Julio Sáez-Rodríguez,Cowen Lj,Sven Bergmann,Daniel Marbach,Fabian Aicheler,Nicola Amoroso,Àlex Arenas,Karthik Azhagesan,Allison H. Baker,Michael Banf,Serafim Batzoglou,Anaı̈s Baudot,R. Bellotti,Boroevich Ka,Catherine Brun,Sanjun Cai,Michael Caldera,Alberto Calderone,Gianni Cesareni,W Chen,Christine Chichester,Lenore Cowen,Heng Cui,Dao P,Domênico,Andi Dhroso,Gilles Didier,Mathew R. Divine,Sol Ad,Xian Zhang Feng,Flores-Canales Jc,Santo Fortunato,Anthony Gitter,Anna Górska,Yuanfang Guan,Alain Guénoche,Selma Gomez,Haya Hamza,András Hartmann,Shenggen He,A Heijs,Joachim Heinrich,Yibo Hu,Xuelin Huang,Hughitt Vk,Minji Jeon,Lucas G. S. Jeub,Nia Johnson,K. Joo,InSuk Joung,Sungwon Jung,Kalko Sg,Kamola Pj,Jie Kang,B Kaveelerdpotjana,Mi‐Hyun Kim,Yonggyun Kim,Oliver Kohlbacher,Dmitry Korkin,Krzysztof Krzemieniecki,Khalid Kunji,S Lang-Brown,Le Td,Lee J,Lee S,Li D,Jian Li,Lei Liu,A Loizou,Luo Z,Artem Lysenko,Ma T,Raghvendra Mall,Thomas Di Mattia,Mario Medvedovic,Jörg Menche,Elisa Micarelli,A. Monaco,Felix Müller,Oleksandr Narykov,Thea Norman,S Park,Livia Perfetto,Dimitri Perrin,S Pirrò,Przytycka Tm,Xiao Qian,Karthik Raman,Daniele Ramazzotti,Emilie Ramsahai,B. Ravindran,Phil Rennert,Curt Scharfe,Roded Sharan,Ning Shi,William Shin,Shu Hu,Himanshu Sinha,Lionel Spinelli,Suhas Srinivasan,Christine Suver,Damian Szklarczyk,Sabina Tangaro,Suresh Thiagarajan,Laurent Tichit,Tyler Tiede,Beethika Tripathi,Aviad Tsherniak,Tatsuhiko Tsunoda,Dénes Türei,Ehsan Ullah,Golnaz Vahedi,Alberto Valdeolivas,J Vivek,Mering Cv,Andra Waagmeester,Bingkai Wang,Y Wang,Weir Ba,Simon White,Stefan Winkler,Ke Xu,Tao Xu,Yan C,Lei Yang,Yu Kang,Yu X,Gaia Zaffaroni,Mikhail Zaslavskiy,Tian Zeng,L Zhang,W Zhang,X Zhang,J Zhang,Xia Zhou,Jiaqi Zhou,Hai‐Liang Zhu,Jun Zhu,Guido Zuccon

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3188379

2018-01-01

Abstract:Identification of modules in molecular networks is at the core of many current analysis methods in biomedical research. However, how well different approaches identify disease-relevant modules in different types of networks remains poorly understood. We launched the "Disease Module Identification DREAM Challenge", an open competition to comprehensively assess module identification methods across diverse gene, protein and signaling networks. Predicted network modules were tested for association with complex traits and diseases using a unique collection of 180 genome-wide association studies (GWAS). While a number of approaches were successful in terms of discovering complementary trait-associated modules, consensus predictions derived from the challenge submissions performed best. We find that most of these modules correspond to core disease-relevant pathways, which often comprise therapeutic targets and correctly prioritize candidate disease genes. This community challenge establishes benchmarks, tools and guidelines for molecular network analysis to study human disease biology (https://synapse.org/modulechallenge).