MORE ALCOHOL DEPENDENCE THAN ABUSE IN RURAL CHINA

Wanjun Guo,Xiufeng Xu,Paul Lee

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1360-0443.2009.02798.x

2009-01-01

Addiction

Abstract:Recent research has suggested a significant increase of alcohol consumption and use disorders in China, and attributed this to a culturally lax attitude to binge-drinking, business-related drinking and the adoption of western life-styles following globalization [1,2]. Accordingly, the pattern of DSM-IV alcohol use disorders in urban regions is now quite similar to those of western populations [3,4]; that is, these disorders are mainly prevalent among young to middle-aged males [2] and abuse is significantly more common than dependence [2,5]. However, about 70% of the Chinese population consists of rural and ethnic minority people, among whom recent DSM-IV-based community surveys repeatedly found the prevalence of dependence to be significantly higher than that of abuse [6,7]. Moreover, both disorders are more prevalent among older males [6,7]. In some surveys, including both urban and rural regions, the prevalence of dependence was also estimated to be higher than that of abuse [8]. These findings suggest that special aetiological pathways may shape the pattern of alcohol use and its disorders in non-urban people in China. Using both anthropological and epidemiological research methods [9], we found that drinking is a well-accepted means of relieving physical and psychological symptoms among older Chinese men in rural and minority areas. Many of them believe that alcohol can reduce fatigue, relieve pain, enhance sleep and ‘expel wetness and restore bodily imbalance’. Drinking after heavy labour, including solitary drinking among older people, is especially popular [9]. Because of the perceived health benefits, regular drinking without binge drinking and drunkenness is a locally endorsed kind of self-medication for a variety of symptoms. None the less, consumption levels are often much larger than the professionally recommended limit of ‘proper drinking’, and can result in alcohol dependence without apparently causing psychosocial problems associated with the diagnosis of alcohol abuse [9]. If they do occur, these problems are not dealt with legally because there are few police officers available to handle them. Drink-driving rarely occurs, as very few people own a vehicle [7]. The physical complications of alcohol dependence are rarely detected, because nearly all rural or minority people no longer have access to free health care following privatization and the breakdown of the previously collectivistic health care system [10]. Consequently, there is ample time for dependence to develop among older male people in rural regions. As alcohol is much cheaper than health visits, future research should examine in more detail how ‘self-medication with alcohol’ may explain the special pattern of alcohol use disorders and its policy implications in China. This atypical pattern has been discussed rarely in the literature, indicating that the diagnosis of alcohol abuse is more likely to be shaped by socio-cultural factors than that of dependence, which is more physiological in origin. Nosologically, a dimensional and more quantitative approach to alcohol use disorders that integrates the features of both abuse and dependence is worth considering in the DSM-V [11]. None.