Robust Modeling Analysis of Relationships Between Mode Choice and Trip Chaining Pattern Using Two-Stage Semi-Nonparametric Method

Xin Ye
2010-01-01
Abstract:In this paper, a robust modeling analysis is conducted to investigate inter-relationships between travel mode choice and trip chaining pattern choice using semi-nonparametric modeling method. Mode choice is modeled as a binary choice between auto and non-auto modes, while trip chaining pattern is modeled as a binary choice between complex tour (multi-stop tour) and simple tour (single-stop tour). The endogenous dummy variables indicating auto mode choice and complex pattern of trip chain are specified into mutual utility functions to quantify the impact of one choice on the other choice. The recursive bivariate probit model may not provide consistent estimators if the assumption of bivariate normal distribution is violated. Semi-nonparametric method can overcome this potential problem given its advantage of having a distribution-free random utility for binary choice model. With slight modifications on the original semi-nonparametric binary choice method, we developed a two-stage semi-nonparametric method to estimate binary choice models with endogenous dummy variables. The data used for empirical model estimation is a non-work tour (tour visiting one or more non-work places) sample drawn from the 2000 Swiss Microcensus Travel Survey. Robust model estimation results show that recursive bivariate probit models underestimate coefficients of endogenous dummy variables by 30-50% in the models, where normality assumptions are not satisfied. Thus, it is necessary to use distribution-free modeling method for consistently estimating travel choice models with endogenous dummy variables in case the given distributional assumption is violated for the random component of utility function.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?