Borrowing Constraints and Misallocations: Empirical Evidence from China

Hong Ma

2012-01-01

Abstract:This study investigates whether and how borrowing constraints can lead to resource misallocation.Previous studies found large within-industry marginal product disparities in poorer countries,which greatly lowered the aggregate total factor productivity(TFP).Many studies have focused on the role of financial distortions in generating TFP losses,but have found no conclusive evidence.However,these studies only relied on aggregate measures of financial development,such as external financing to gross domestic product ratios and interest rate spreads,which have failed to explain China's TFP losses.Firm-level data from China is used here to show that credit misallocation rather than an inadequate overall amount of cheap credit is the key factor.Since interest rates in the Chinese banking system have not been marketized and bank loans are less costly than informal financing,firms who have better access to loans from state-owned banks always benefit and tend to overinvest,which creates misallocation of capital and lowers the aggregate TFP.This study suggests that previous studies on borrowing constraints and misallocation might have underestimated the role of financial distortions in lowering productivity in developing countries.