Can Social Media Combat Gender Inequalities in Academia? Measuring the Prevalence of the Matilda Effect in Communication
Yunya Song,Xiaohui Wang,Guanrong Li
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/jcmc/zmad050
IF: 7.432
2023-01-01
Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication
Abstract:This study sought to investigate whether scholarly impact and academic influence differ between men and women in the field of communication and the extent to which the gender gap has persisted on social media platforms, an arena increasingly used for research dissemination. Data were collected from 10,736 articles, published in prominent communication journals between 2012 and 2022, using a combination of three sources: OpenAlex, Altmetric, and Twitter. The gender of 6,827 first authors was identified using ChatGPT, with an accuracy of 0.94. The findings confirmed the presence of the Matilda effect, indicating a bias toward male scholars in terms of research performance, academic mobility, and online popularity. Furthermore, the study revealed uneven gains between male and female scholars in their use of social media for research dissemination. These results have implications for how science communities can effectively promote research on social media. Social media is often seen as a potential tool to overcome the barriers faced by women in science; however, its effect on academic equality remains uncertain. This study seeks to investigate whether promoting research on Twitter narrowed or perpetuated the gender gap among communication scholars. The analysis involved examining the publication records of 6,827 scholars who published articles as first authors in prominent communication journals. This study offers a significant contribution by surpassing previous research and considering the entire academic careers across both offline and online domains. Factors such as the number of publications, total citations received, mobility, collaboration networks, and online popularity were considered. The findings of the study reveal that despite there being more female scholars in the field, male scholars experienced high-level of productivity, mobility, and online popularity. Furthermore, the gender gap in communication is amplified by social media, with male scholars gaining more citations through using social media for research dissemination. Recognizing these unequal benefits gained from social media use can help shape strategies aimed at enhancing gender equity, diversity, and inclusivity in communication research. By understanding and addressing these disparities, steps can be taken toward establishing a more equitable academic environment.