Observation of Three Charmoniumlike States with JPC=1−− In

M. Ablikim,М. Н. Ачасов,P. Adlarson,R. Aliberti,A. Amoroso,M. R. An,Q. An,Y. Bai,O. Bakina,I. Balossino,Y. Ban,V. Batozskaya,K. Begzsuren,N. Berger,M. Bertani,D. Bettoni,F. Bianchi,E. Bianco,J. Bloms,A. Bortone,I. Boyko,R. A. Briere,A. Brueggemann,H. Cai,X. Cai,A. Calcaterra,G. F. Cao,N. Cao,S. A. Çetin,J. F. Chang,T. T. Chang,W. L. Chang,G. R.,G. Chelkov,C. Chen,Chao Chen,G. Chen,H. S. Chen,M. L. Chen,S. J. Chen,S. M. Chen,T. Chen,X. R. Chen,X. T. Chen,Y. B. Chen,Y. Q. Chen,Z. J. Chen,Wei Cheng,S. K. Choi,X. Chu,G. Cibinetto,S. C. Coen,F. Cossio,J. J. Cui,H. L. Dai,J. P. Dai,A. Dbeyssi,R. E. de Boer,D. Dedovich,Z. Y. Deng,A. Denig,I. Denysenko,M. Destefanis,F. De Mori,B. Ding,X. X. Ding,Yanchun Ding,J. Dong,L. Y. Dong,M. Y. Dong,X. Dong,S. X. Du,Z. H. Duan,P. Egorov,Y. L. Fan,J. Fang,S. S. Fang,Wenxing Fang,Y. Fang,R. Farinelli,L. Fava,F. Feldbauer,G. Felici,C. Q. Feng,J. H. Feng,K. Fischer,M. Fritsch,C. Fritzsch,C. D. Fu,Y. W. Fu,H. Gao,Yang Gao,S. Garbolino,I. Garzia,P. Ge,Z. W. Ge,Cong Geng,E. Gersabeck,A. Gilman,K. Goetzen,L. Gong,W. X. Gong,W. Gradl,S. Gramigna,M. Greco,M. H. Gu,Y. T. Gu,C. Y. Guan,Z. L. Guan,A. Q. Guo,L. B. Guo,R. P. Guo,Y. P. Guo,A. Guskov,X. T. H.,W. Y. Han,X. Q. Hao,F. A. Harris,K. K. He,K. L. He,F. H. Heinsius,Christian Heinz,Y. K. Heng,C. Herold,T. Holtmann,P. C. Hong,G. Y. Hou,Y. R. Hou,Z. L. Hou,H. M. Hu,J. F. Hu,T. Hu,Y. Hu,G. S. Huang,K. X. Huang,L. Q. Huang,X. T. Huang,Yanping Huang,T. Hussain,N. Hüsken,W. Imoehl,M. Irshad,J. Jackson,S. Jaeger,S. Janchiv,J. H. Jeong,Q. P. Ji,X. B. Ji,X. L. Ji,Y. Y. Ji,Z. K. Jia,P. C. Jiang,S. S. Jiang,T. J. Jiang,X. S. Jiang,Y. Jiang,J. B. Jiao,Z. Jiao,S. Jin,Y. Jin,M. Q. Jing,T. Johansson,X. K.,S. Kabana,N. Kalantar–Nayestanaki,X. L. Kang,X. S. Kang,R. Kappert,M. Kavatsyuk,B. C. Ke,A. Khoukaz,R. Kiuchi,R. Kliemt,L. Koch,O. B. Kolcu,B. Kopf,M. Kuessner,A. Kupść,W. Kühn,John Jake Lane,J. S. Lange,P. Larin,A. Lavania,L. Lavezzi,T. T. Lei,Lei Zhao,H. Leithoff,M. Lellmann,T. Lenz,C. Li,C. H. Li,Cheng Li,D. M. Li,F. Li,G. Li,H. Li,H. B. Li,H. J. Li,H. N. Li,Hui Li,J. R. Li,J. S. Li,J. W. Li,Ké Li,L. J Li,Lei Li,M. H. Li,P. R. Li,S. X. Li,T. Li,W. D. Li,W. G. Li,X. H. Li,X. L. Li,Xiaoyü Li,Y. G. Li,Z. J. Li,Z. X. Li,Z. Y. Li,C. Liang,H. Liang,Y. F. Liang,Y. T. Liang,G. R. Liao,L. Z. Liao,J. Libby,A. Limphirat,D. X. Lin,T. Lin,B. X. Liu,B. J. Liu,C. Liu,C. X. Liu,D. Liu,F. H. Liu,Fang Liu,Feng Liu,G. M. Liu,H. Liu,H. B. Liu,H. M. Liu,Huanhuan Liu,Huihui Liu,J. B. Liu,J. L. Liu,J. Y. Liu,K. Liu,K. Y. Liu,Ke Liu,L. Liu,L. C. Liu,Lu Liu,M. H. Liu,P. L. Liu,Q. Liu,S. B. Liu,T. Liu,W. K. Liu,W. M. Liu,X. Liu,Y. Liu,Y. B. Liu,Z. A. Liu,Z. Q. Liu,Xuanhong Lou,F. X. Lu,H. J. Lü,J. G. Lu,X. L. Lu,Y. Lu,Y. P. Lu,Z. H. Lu,C. L. Luo,M. X. Luo,T. Luo,X. L. Luo,Xiao-Rui Lyu,Y. F. Lyu,F. C.,H. L.,J. L.,L. L.,M. M.,Q. M.,R. Q.,R. T.,X. Y.,Y. Ma,F. E. Maas,M. Maggiora,S. Maldaner,S. Malde,A. Mangoni,Y. J. Mao,Z. P. Mao,S. Marcello,Z. X. Meng,J. G. Messchendorp,G. Mezzadri,H. Miao,T. J. Min,R. E. Mitchell,X. H. Mo,N. Yu. Muchnoi,Y. Nefedov,F. Nerling,I. B. Nikolaev,Z. Ning,S. Nisar,Y. Niu,S. L. Olsen,Q. Ouyang,S. Pacetti,X. Pan,Y. Pan,Atanu Pathak,Y. P. Pei,M. Pelizaeus,H. P. Peng,K. Peters,J. L. Ping,R. G. Ping,S. Plura,S. Pogodin,V. Prasad,F. Z. Qi,H. R. Qi,M. Qi,T. Y. Qi,S. J. Qian,W. Qian,C. F. Qiao,Jia-Jia Qin,Qin Liu,X. P. Qin,X. S. Qin,Z. H. Qin,J. F. Qiu,S. Q. Qu,C. F. Redmer,K. J. Ren,A. Rivetti,V. Rodin,M. Rolo,G. Rong,Ch. Rosner,S. N. Ruan,N. Salone,A. Sarantsev,Y. Schelhaas,K. Schoenning,M. Scodeggio,K. Y. Shan,W. Shan,X. Y. Shan,J. F. Shangguan,L. G. Shao,M. Shao,C. P. Shen,H. F. Shen,W. H. Shen,X. Y. Shen,B. A. Shi,H. C. Shi,John Shi,Q. Q. Shi,R. S. Shi,X. Shi,J. J. Song,T. Z. Song,W. M. Song,Y. X. Song,S. Sosio,S. Spataro,F. Stieler,Y. J. Su,G. B. Sun,G. X. Sun,H. K. Sun,J. F. Sun,K. Sun,L. Sun,S. S. Sun,T. Sun,W. Y. Sun,Y. K. Sun,Y. J. Sun,Y. Z. Sun,Z. T. Sun,Y. X. Tan,C. J. Tang,G. Y. Tang,J. Tang,Y. A. Tang,L. Y. Tao,Q. T. Tao,Martin Duy Tat,J. X. Teng,V. Thoren,W. H. Tian,Y. Tian,Zhen Tian,I. Uman,B. Wang,B. L. Wang,Bo Wang,C. W. Wang,D. Y. Wang,F. Wang,H. J. Wang,H. P. Wang,K. Wang,L. L. Wang,M. Wang,Meng Wang,S. Wang,T. Wang,Tao Wang,W. Wang,W. H. Wang,W. P. Wang,X. Wang,X. F. Wang,X. J. Wang,X. L. Wang,Y. Wang,Y. D. Wang,Y. F. Wang,Y. H. Wang,Y. N. Wang,Y. Q. Wang,Yaqian Wang,Yi Wang,Z. Wang,Z. L. Wang,Z. Y. Wang,Ziyi Wang,D. H. Wei,F. Weidner,S. P. Wen,Christoph Wenzel,U. Wiedner,G. Wilkinson,M. Wolke,L. Wollenberg,C. Wu,Jian Wu,L. H. Wu,L. J. Wu,X. Wu,Y. Wu,Zhenbin Wu,Ligang Xia,X. M. Xian,T. Xiang,D. Xiao,G. Y. Xiao,H. Xiao,S. Y. Xiao,Y. L. Xiao,Z. J. Xiao,Changsheng Xie,X. H. Xie,Y. H. Xie,Y. Xie,Z. P. Xie,T. Y. Xing,C. F. Xu,C. J. Xu,G. F. Xu,H. Y. Xu,Q. J. Xu,W. Xu,X. P. Xu,Y. C. Xu,Z. P. Xu,Zhe Xu,F. Yan,L. Yan,W. B. Yan,W. C. Yan,X. Q. Yan,Haijun Yang,H. L. Yang,H. X. Yang,Tao Yang,Yifan Yang,M. Ye,M. H. Ye,J. H. Yin,Z. Y. You,B. X. Yu,C. X. Yu,G. Yu,T. Yu,X. D. Yu,C. Z. Yuan,L. Yuan,Shiming Yuan,X. Q. Yuan,Y. Yuan,Z. Y. Yuan,C. X. Yue,A. A. Zafar,F. R. Zeng,X. Zeng,Y. Zeng,X. Y. Zhai,Y. H. Zhan,A. Q. Zhang,B. L. Zhang,B. X. Zhang,D. H. Zhang,G. Y. Zhang,H. Zhang,H. H. Zhang,H. Q. Zhang,H. Y. Zhang,J. J. Zhang,J. L. Zhang,J. Q. Zhang,J. W. Zhang,J. X. Zhang,J. Y. Zhang,J. Z. Zhang,Jiawei Zhang,L. M. Zhang,L. Q. Zhang,Lei Zhang,P. Zhang,Q. Y. Zhang,Shuihan Zhang,Shulei Zhang,X. D. Zhang,X. M. Zhang,X. Y. Zhang,Y. Zhang,Y. T. Zhang,Y. H. Zhang,Yan Zhang,Yao Zhang,Z. H. Zhang,Z. L. Zhang,Z. Y. Zhang,G. Zhao,J. Z. Zhao,J. Y. Zhao,Zhao Liu,Ling Zhao,M. G. Zhao,S. J. Zhao,Y. B. Zhao,Y. X. Zhao,Z. G. Zhao,A. Zhemchugov,B. Zheng,J. P. Zheng,W. J. Zheng,Y. Zheng,B. Zhong,X. Zhong,H. Zhou,Zhou Li,X. R. Zhou,X. K. Zhou,X. Y. Zhou,Y. Z. Zhou,Jiang Zhu,K. J. Zhu,L. X. Zhu,S. H. Zhu,S. Q. Zhu,T. J. Zhu,W. J. Zhu,Y. C. Zhu,Z. A. Zhu,J. H. Zou,J. Zu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevlett.130.121901
IF: 8.6
2023-01-01
Physical Review Letters
Abstract:The Born cross sections of the process ${e}^{+}{e}^{\ensuremath{-}}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}{D}^{*0}{D}^{*\ensuremath{-}}{\ensuremath{\pi}}^{+}$ at center-of-mass energies from 4.189 to 4.951 GeV are measured for the first time. The data samples used correspond to an integrated luminosity of $17.9\text{ }\text{ }{\mathrm{fb}}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$ and were collected by the BESIII detector operating at the BEPCII storage ring. Three enhancements around 4.20, 4.47, and 4.67 GeV are visible. The resonances have masses of $4209.6\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}4.7\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}5.9\text{ }\text{ }\mathrm{MeV}/{c}^{2}$, $4469.1\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}26.2\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}3.6\text{ }\text{ }\mathrm{MeV}/{c}^{2}$, and $4675.3\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}29.5\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}3.5\text{ }\text{ }\mathrm{MeV}/{c}^{2}$ and widths of $81.6\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}17.8\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}9.0\text{ }\text{ }\mathrm{MeV}$, $246.3\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}36.7\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}9.4\text{ }\text{ }\mathrm{MeV}$, and $218.3\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}72.9\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}9.3\text{ }\text{ }\mathrm{MeV}$, respectively, where the first uncertainties are statistical and the second systematic. The first and third resonances are consistent with the $\ensuremath{\psi}(4230)$ and $\ensuremath{\psi}(4660)$ states, respectively, while the second one is compatible with the $\ensuremath{\psi}(4500)$ observed in the ${e}^{+}{e}^{\ensuremath{-}}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}{K}^{+}{K}^{\ensuremath{-}}J/\ensuremath{\psi}$ process. These three charmoniumlike $\ensuremath{\psi}$ states are observed in the ${e}^{+}{e}^{\ensuremath{-}}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}{D}^{*0}{D}^{*\ensuremath{-}}{\ensuremath{\pi}}^{+}$ process for the first time.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?