The Missing Carbon Pass-through in China’s Electricity Market

Libo Wu,Ningyue Zhang,Yang Zhou

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4604443

2023-01-01

Abstract:This paper studies the carbon pass-through under China’s rate-based carbon market. We developed a theoretical framework to explore how carbon costs are passed to electricity prices, considering both cap-and-trade (C&T) and Tradable Performance Standard (TPS, rate-based) schemes. Unlike the direct carbon cost pass-through under C&T, the rate-based scheme introduces uncertainty on whether firms will be subsidized or taxed, the demand for allowances, and the equilibrium price, which are mostly dependent on the benchmark level. We further empirically assessed the policy effect of carbon trading in the power sector of Shandong and Shanxi. The empirical results reveal an insignificant impact of carbon on electricity prices — a “missing carbon pass-through.” This outcome was primarily attributable to the fact the units receive marginal subsidies (approximately 0.5% of total generation costs) through carbon trading, coupled with the uncertainties within the market. This paper provides valuable insights into the design of China’s carbon market and the setting of emission benchmarks. The interaction of the carbon and electricity markets should be well considered by policymakers when making climate policies.