Imperialism and Its Critics

Demin Duan,Howard Williams
2023-01-01
Abstract:In this chapter, we engage with the concept of imperialism through the eyes of major political thinkers—Immanuel Kant, Karl Marx, Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel, John Stuart Mill and Alexis de Tocqueville—to extract lessons for the present. These thinkers not only offer influential visions of modern domestic politics, but also of international politics. Mill and Tocqueville are typical liberal thinkers, while Marx has given rise to the ideology of Marxism, still influential particularly on the left. Kant and Hegel are more difficult to categorise. Hegel has left his mark both on state-centric and realist thought, whereas Kant influences today’s liberalism as well as cosmopolitanism. None of them puts imperialism at the center of their otherwise complicated political thinking, but all of them treat imperialistic undertakings as an important problem in their theorisation. However, if we take all these thinkers together, despite areas of consensus and of critical differences, they can help us develop insights and visions about a good world order today.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?