Abstract:This paper presents an impartial and extensive benchmark for text classification involving five different text classification tasks, 20 datasets, 11 different model architectures, and 42,800 algorithm runs. The five text classification tasks are fake news classification, topic detection, emotion detection, polarity detection, and sarcasm detection. While in practice, especially in Natural Language Processing (NLP), research tends to focus on the most sophisticated models, we hypothesize that this is not always necessary. Therefore, our main objective is to investigate whether the largest state-of-the-art (SOTA) models are always preferred, or in what cases simple methods can compete with complex models, i.e. for which dataset specifications and classification tasks. We assess the performance of different methods with varying complexity, ranging from simple statistical and machine learning methods to pretrained transformers like robustly optimized BERT (Bidirectional Encoder Representations from Transformers) pretraining approach (RoBERTa). This comprehensive benchmark is lacking in existing literature, with research mainly comparing similar types of methods. Furthermore, with increasing awareness of the ecological impacts of extensive computational resource usage, this comparison is both critical and timely.We find that overall, bidirectional long short-term memory (LSTM) networks are ranked as the best-performing method albeit not statistically significantly better than logistic regression and RoBERTa. Overall, we cannot conclude that simple methods perform worse although this depends mainly on the classification task. Concretely, we find that for fake news classification and topic detection, simple techniques are the best-ranked models and consequently, it is not necessary to train complicated neural network architectures for these classification tasks. Moreover, we also find a negative correlation between F1 performance and complexity for the smallest datasets (with dataset size less than 10,000). Finally, the different models' results are analyzed in depth to explain the model decisions, which is an increasing requirement in the field of text classification.

Evaluation of Text Classification Using Support Vector Machine Compare with Naive Bayes, Random Forest Decision Tree and K-NN

A Comparative Analysis of Logistic Regression, Random Forest and KNN Models for the Text Classification

Chinese News Text Classification Based on Machine Learning Algorithm

Comparison of Naive Bayes, Random Forest, Decision Tree, Support Vector Machines, and Logistic Regression Classifiers for Text Reviews Classification

Bagging Text Classification Algorithm Based on Classifier Performance Evaluation

Performance Analysis and Comparison of Neural Networks and Support Vector Machines Classifier

Text Classification Using Hybrid Machine Learning Algorithms on Big Data

Evaluating text classification: A benchmark study

Basic Tenets of Classification Algorithms K-Nearest-Neighbor, Support Vector Machine, Random Forest and Neural Network: A Review

Comparison of Random Forest, Support Vector Machine and Back Propagation Neural Network for Electronic Tongue Data Classification: Application to the Recognition of Orange Beverage and Chinese Vinegar

An Empirical Study on the Classification of Chinese News Articles by Machine Learning and Deep Learning Techniques

A comparative study of forecasting corporate credit ratings using neural networks, support vector machines, and decision trees

A discriminative model selection approach and its application to text classification

A Comparison among Three Neural Networks for Text Classification

A comparative analysis of text data classification accuracy and speed using neural networks, Bloom filter and naive Bayes

Academic Performance Prediction Using Machine Learning Algorithms

Implementation of Machine Learning for Text Classification Using the Naive Bayes Algorithm in Academic Information Systems at Sebelas Maret University Indonesia

K-Nearest Neighbour and Support Vector Machine Hybrid Classification

Finding decision jumps in text classification

Stock Market Forecasting Based on Text Mining Technology: A Support Vector Machine Method

Text sentiment analysis from students' comments using various machine learning and deep learning techniques: a comparative analysis