Peer Review #1 of "impact of Dialysis Modality Conversion on the Health-Related Quality of Life of Peritoneal Dialysis Patients: a Retrospective Cohort Study in China (V0.1)"

Ye Zhuang,Lanying Gao,Nengxiong Xu,Yan Xiong,Min Yuan,Jun Lü,Jianming Ye,Heqi Sun

DOI: https://doi.org/10.7287/peerj.12793v0.1/reviews/1

2022-01-01

Abstract:Background.To analyze the health-related quality of life associated with the conversion of dialysis modality among end-stage renal disease patients in China.Methods.Patients were recruited from hospitals and a dialysis center in Kunshan, China.Patients converting from continuous ambulatory peritoneal dialysis to automated peritoneal dialysis were recruited as the observation group (n=64), and patients continuing with continuous ambulatory peritoneal dialysis treatment were included in the control group (n=64) after matching in this historical cohort study.Their health-related quality of life was measured using the kidney disease quality of life instrument in 2019 and 2020, respectively.Baseline socio-demographic characteristics and clinical data were collected in 2019.The before-and-after cross-group comparisons of subscale scores of two groups were conducted using a student t-test.Multiple linear regression models were fitted to identify the factors associated with the change of each scale.Results.The health-related quality of life scores of the two groups was comparable in baseline, while the observation group had higher scores in Physical Component Summary (51.92±7.50),Kidney Disease Component Summary (81.21±8.41),Symptoms(90.76±6.30),Effects(82.86±11.42),and Burden(69.04±15.69)subscales after one year.In multivariate regression analysis, the change of Physical Component Summary was significantly associated with conversion to APD (β=11.54,95%CI:7.26,15.82); the change of Mental Component Summary with higher education (β=-5.96,95%CI: -10.18,-1.74)and CCI (>2) (β=5.39,95%CI: 1.05,9.73);the change of Kidney Disease Component Summary with conversion to APD (β=15.95,95%CI: 10.19,21.7)and age (>60 years) (β=-7.36,95%CI: -14.11,-0.61); the change of Symptoms with CCI (>2) (β=7.96,95%CI: 1.49,14.44);the change of Effects with conversion to APD (β=19.23,95%CI: 11.57,26.88);and the change of Burden with conversion to APD (β=22.40,95%CI: 13.46,31.34),age (>60 years) (β=-12.12,95%CI: -22.59,-1.65),and higher education (β=-10.38,95%CI: -19.79,-0.98).Conclusions.The conversion of dialysis modality had a significant impact on the scores of most subscales.Patients converting from continuous ambulatory peritoneal dialysis to automated peritoneal dialysis generally had improved health-related quality of life scores.