Abstract:Century‐long homogenized observations of surface incident solar radiation were used to evaluate five 20th century reanalyses over Japan. CERA20C performs best among the five 20th century reanalyses. The biases of surface incident solar radiation in 20th century reanalyses can mostly be explained by cloud cover. Surface incident solar radiation (Rs) is of great importance in determining the energy balance in the Earth system. In this study, we use century‐long homogenized observations over Japan to constrain five 20th century reanalyses to explore their performance in reproducing Rs variation on different time scales (high‐frequency components [HFCs], for signals with cycles less than 10 years; low‐frequency components [LFCs], for signals with cycles more than 10 years) by ensemble empirical mode decomposition (EEMD) method and to quantify the impact factors on the Rs estimations by the sum of tree (SOT) model. It is found that ERA20C, ERA20CM and CERA20C overestimated Rs by 0.48–1.49 W/m−2, while 20CRv2c and 20CRv3 underestimated Rs by −0.63 and −1.18 W/m−2, respectively for 1931–2010. Poor correlation coefficient (R) was found to be 0.10 for ERA20CM and 0.22 for 20CRv2c. 20CRv2c failed for 1931–1960 but improved considerably for 1961–2010. 20CRv3 uses an upgraded model and assimilates more observations compared with its predecessor 20CRv2c; however, only the original components and HFCs in Rs were improved, with nearly no improvement in the LFCs. In general, CERA20C Rs, with small biases and higher R of 0.73 for original signals, 0.83 for HFCs and LFCs, is superior to other reanalyses. No obvious trend in clear sky Rs demonstrated that reanalysed Rs are insensitive to the aerosol forcings. Therefore, cloud cover and water vapour maybe the main factors influenced reanalysed Rs. Most of time, Rs is more sensitive to cloud cover than vapour pressure for all reanalyses except original signals (with contribution ratio of 0.29 for cloud cover and 0.71 for vapour pressure) and LFCs (with contribution ratio of 0.41 for cloud cover and 0.59 for vapour pressure) in CERA20C, and original signals (with contribution ratio of 0.37 for cloud cover and 0.63 for vapour pressure) in ERA20C. This work pointed out that aerosol related processes such as aerosol forcings or aerosol radiative effect in reanalyses should be improved in the future, which will ultimately improve the interaction between aerosol and cloud in Rs simulations.

Comment on Essd-2021-231

Homogenized Century-Long Surface Incident Solar Radiation over Japan

Atmospheric Impacts on Climatic Variability of Surface Incident Solar Radiation

Decadal Variability of Surface Incident Solar Radiation over China: Observations, Satellite Retrievals, and Reanalyses

A Revisit of Global Dimming and Brightening Based on the Sunshine Duration

Measurement Biases Explain Discrepancies between the Observed and Simulated Decadal Variability of Surface Incident Solar Radiation

Merging ground-based sunshine duration observations with satellite cloud and aerosol retrievals to produce high-resolution long-term surface solar radiation over China

Merging High-Resolution Satellite Surface Radiation Data with Meteorological Sunshine Duration Observations over China from 1983 to 2017

Increase of Surface Solar Irradiance Across East China Related to Changes in Aerosol Properties During the Past Decade

Homogenized Daily Sunshine Duration over China from 1961 to 2022

Variability in Direct and Diffuse Solar Radiation Across China from 1958 to 2017

Solar Radiation Trend Across China in Recent Decades: A Revisit with Quality-Controlled Data

Urban Impacts on Mean and Trend of Surface Incident Solar Radiation

Surface Brightening In Eastern And Central China Since The Implementation Of The Clean Air Action In 2013: Causes And Implications

Century‐Long Variations in Surface Incident Solar Radiation Over Japan——Characterized by Observations and Reanalyses

Hourly Surface Observations Suggest Stronger Solar Dimming and Brightening at Sunrise and Sunset over China

Changes in the Relationship Between Solar Radiation and Sunshine Duration in Large Cities of China

Quantitation of the Surface Shortwave and Longwave Radiative Effect of Dust with an Integrated System: A Case Study at Xianghe

Determining Factors of Monthly to Decadal Variability in Surface Solar Radiation in China: Evidences from Current Reanalyses

The accuracy improvement of clear-sky surface shortwave radiation derived from CERES SSF dataset with a simulation analysis

Distinct Impact of Different Types of Aerosols on Surface Solar Radiation in China