Peer Review #1 of "potentially Toxic Metal(loid) Distribution and Migration in the Bottom Weathering Profile of Indigenous Zinc Smelting Slag Pile in Clastic Rock Region (V0.1)"

Yishu Peng,Ruidong Yang,Tao Jin,Jun Chen,Jian Zhang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.7287/peerj.10825v0.1/reviews/1
2021-01-01
Abstract:Background.There are contaminated by potentially toxic metal(loid)s (PTMs) that the surface soil and the weathering profiles around the indigenous zinc smelting slag piles or smelters in the smelting area.However, few systematic studies are currently focusing on the PTM distribution and migration among the slag and its bottom weathering profile.Methods.This research determined the concentrations of PTMs and pH values.And we analyzed PTM distribution in the two weathering profiles (slag-covered and slag-absent) with a small horizontal distance in the clastic rock region in the smelting area.Results.The soil As and Pb contents respective within the 30-centimeter and 50 cm depth in the slagcovered section are higher than those in the slag-absent profile.And all soil Cd and Zn contents of the slag-covered core are significantly higher than those in the slag-absent weathering section. Conclusions.Compared with the slag-absent weathering section, some PTMs (i.e., As, Cd, Pb, and Zn) in the bottom weathering profile are polluted by these elements in the covered slag in the clastic rock region.And their depths are influenced by the slag to varying degrees.Additionally, with time, some PTMs (especially Cd and Zn) of the slag might finally contaminate the groundwater by leaching and infiltration through its bottom weathering profile in the clastic rock region.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?