Blockchain Technology Adoption in Digital Advertising: A Game-Theoretic Model

Yi Gao,Subodha Kumar,Dengpan Liu
2021-01-01
SSRN Electronic Journal
Abstract:Recently, the disruptive impact of blockchain technology on the digital advertising industry has caught widespread attention. However, this issue has not been formally analyzed in the literature. In order to fill this important gap, we use a game-theoretic model to study whether and when digital advertisers should adopt blockchain technology in a competitive environment. We also analyze how the publisher should adapt his advertising slot assignment strategies accordingly. With blockchain technology, advertisers can avoid click fraud and work directly with publishers, while incurring certain blockchain-related costs; publishers can benefit from instant payment and no middleman, but in the meantime, lose potential revenue generated from click manipulation. We identify the existence conditions for all possible equilibria and find that the advertisers can benefit from adopting the blockchain channel under certain circumstances. Our result also shows that the adoption of blockchain may sometimes lead advertisers to fall into the prisoner’s dilemma. Furthermore, when one advertiser’s value per click increases, she may sometimes be better off deviating to the blockchain channel to get the higher slot (with more click traffic). Yet, the other advertiser can still be better off with her ad moving down to the lower slot (with less click traffic), potentially yielding a Pareto improvement outcome for both advertisers. Our result also shows that as the inter-slot differentiation increases, taking the higher slot may not always be the advertiser’s optimal decision. In addition, interestingly, we find that the publisher should assign the higher slot to the blockchain-based advertiser only when the delay in receiving the advertiser’s payment in the traditional channel is sufficiently higher than that in the blockchain channel. Our paper provides meaningful implications for publishers and advertisers regarding blockchain adoption in digital advertising. Moreover, our results send an important message to policymakers that the objectives of advertisers and publishers may sometimes be in conflict with each other, especially when the blockchain fee is relatively high.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?