Author Response: Optimization of Energy State Transition Trajectory Supports the Development of Executive Function During Youth
Zaixu Cui,Jennifer Stiso,Graham L. Baum,Jason Z. Kim,David R. Roalf,Richard F. Betzel,Shi Gu,Zhixin Lu,Cedric Huchuan Xia,Xiaosong He,Rastko Ćirić,Desmond J. Oathes,Tyler M. Moore,Russell T. Shinohara,Kosha Ruparel,Christos Davatzikos,Fabio Pasqualetti,Raquel E. Gur,Ruben C. Gur,Danielle S. Bassett,Theodore Satterthwaite
DOI: https://doi.org/10.7554/elife.53060.sa2
2020-01-01
Abstract:Article Figures and data Abstract eLife digest Introduction Results Discussion Materials and methods Data availability References Decision letter Author response Article and author information Metrics Abstract Executive function develops during adolescence, yet it remains unknown how structural brain networks mature to facilitate activation of the fronto-parietal system, which is critical for executive function. In a sample of 946 human youths (ages 8-23y) who completed diffusion imaging, we capitalized upon recent advances in linear dynamical network control theory to calculate the energetic cost necessary to activate the fronto-parietal system through the control of multiple brain regions given existing structural network topology. We found that the energy required to activate the fronto-parietal system declined with development, and the pattern of regional energetic cost predicts unseen individuals’ brain maturity. Finally, energetic requirements of the cingulate cortex were negatively correlated with executive performance, and partially mediated the development of executive performance with age. Our results reveal a mechanism by which structural networks develop during adolescence to reduce the theoretical energetic costs of transitions to activation states necessary for executive function. eLife digest Adolescents are known for taking risks, from driving too fast to experimenting with drugs and alcohol. Such behaviors tend to decrease as individuals move into adulthood. Most people in their mid-twenties have greater self-control than they did as teenagers. They are also often better at planning, sustaining attention, and inhibiting impulsive behaviors. These skills, which are known as executive functions, develop over the course of adolescence. Executive functions rely upon a series of brain regions distributed across the frontal lobe and the lobe that sits just behind it, the parietal lobe. Fiber tracts connect these regions to form a fronto-parietal network. These fiber tracts are also referred to as white matter due to the whitish fatty material that surrounds and insulates them. Cui et al. now show that changes in white matter networks have implications for teen behavior. Almost 950 healthy young people aged between 8 and 23 years underwent a type of brain scan called diffusion-weighted imaging that visualizes white matter. The scans revealed that white matter networks in the frontal and parietal lobes mature over adolescence. This makes it easier for individuals to activate their fronto-parietal networks by decreasing the amount of energy required. Cui et al. show that a computer model can predict the maturity of a person's brain based on the energy needed to activate their fronto-parietal networks. These changes help explain why executive functions improve during adolescence. This in turn explains why behaviors such as risk-taking tend to decrease with age. That said, adults with various psychiatric disorders, such as ADHD and psychosis, often show impaired executive functions. In the future, it may be possible to reduce these impairments by applying magnetic fields to the scalp to reduce the activity of specific brain regions. The techniques used in the current study could help reveal which brain regions to target with this approach. Introduction Executive function is essential for a wide range of cognitive tasks, and is strongly associated with both overall intelligence (Arffa, 2007) and academic performance (Best et al., 2011). Executive function undergoes protracted maturation during adolescence (Best and Miller, 2010; Gur et al., 2012), and its development is linked to the expansion of the cognitive and behavioral repertoire. Notably, executive deficits are linked to both increased morbidity associated with risk-taking behaviors (Romer et al., 2009) as well as a wide range of neuropsychiatric disorders (Shanmugan et al., 2016), such as attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and psychosis (Barkley, 1997; Wolf et al., 2015). Prior studies have consistently established that executive function relies on activity in a distributed network of fronto-parietal regions, including the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex, cingulate cortex, superior parietal cortex, and frontopolar cortex (Alvarez and Emory, 2006; Mansouri et al., 2017; Niendam et al., 2012; Rottschy et al., 2012; Satterthwaite et al., 2013). Notably, both functional (Fair et al., 2007; Grayson and Fair, 2017; Gu et al., 2015; Power et al., 2010) and structural (Baum et al., 2017; Hagmann et al., 2010; Huang et al., 2015) connectivity among these regions undergoes active remodeling during adolescence, with increased connectivity among executive regions, and diminished connectivity between executive regions and other systems such as the default mode network. As structural white matter networks are known to constrain both intrinsic connectivity and patterns of task-related activation (Hermundstad et al., 2013; Honey et al., 2009), it is possible that white matter networks develop during adolescence to facilitate dynamic transitions to fronto-parietal system activation states with lower theoretical energetic cost. However, research that seeks to relate developing white matter networks to the functional dynamics of the fronto-parietal executive system remains sparse. Network control theory provides a powerful framework to address this gap in our knowledge. Previous work has shown that the brain becomes more theoretically controllable to all possible brain states (on average) through the control of individual brain regions during adolescence (Tang et al., 2017). Network control theory has the potential to provide novel insights regarding mechanisms needed to transition to executive states, as executive function exerts top-down control on other brain systems in a manner akin to control points in a dynamic network (Gu et al., 2015; Tang et al., 2017). Capitalizing on recent developments in network control theory (Betzel et al., 2016; Gu et al., 2017; Stiso et al., 2019), here we examine how the developing brain structural network supports the transition to a specific state necessary for executive function through the distributed control of multiple brain regions. Specifically, this new framework allows one to integrate information regarding network topology and patterns of brain activation within one mathematical model, in order to specify how theoretical neural dynamics are constrained by the structural connectome (Tang and Bassett, 2018). Such models assume that the activation state of the brain at a given time is a linear function of the previous state, the underlying white matter network, and any additional control energy injected into the system (Betzel et al., 2016; Gu et al., 2017). From this paradigm, one can calculate the optimal energy cost to move the brain from one state to another given a structural network topology (Betzel et al., 2016; Gu et al., 2017; Kim et al., 2018). In the present work, we apply this new technique to a large sample of youth. Specifically, we investigated how the energetic cost of transitions to a fronto-parietal system activation state necessary for the executive function changes in response to the maturation of structural brain network. We hypothesized that maturation of structural brain networks would allow for the target activation state of the fronto-parietal executive system to be reached at a lower energetic cost. To test this hypothesis, we capitalized on a large sample of youth (8–23 years) who completed neuroimaging as part of the Philadelphia Neurodevelopmental Cohort (PNC) (Satterthwaite et al., 2014). We examined how white matter networks (estimated using diffusion imaging) support the transition to a fronto-parietal system activation state. As described below, we demonstrate that the energy required to reach this state declines with age, especially within the fronto-parietal control network. Furthermore, we find that the whole-brain control energy pattern contains sufficient information to predict individuals’ brain maturity across development. Finally, participants with better performance on executive tasks require less energetic cost in the bilateral cingulate cortex to reach this activation target, and the energetic cost of this region mediates the development of executive performance with age. Notably, these results could not be explained by individual differences in general network control properties, and were not present in alternative activation target states. Together, these results suggest that structural brain networks become optimized in development to minimize the energetic costs of transitions to activation states necessary for executive function through the distributed control of multiple brain regions. Results Network topology constrains the transition to a fronto-parietal activation state In this study, we included 946 youths aged 8–23 years who were imaged as part of the PNC (Figure 1—figure supplement 1). Structural white matter networks were reconstructed for each participant from diffusion imaging data using probabilistic tractography and a standard parcellation of 232 regions. Capitalizing on recent advances in network control theory, we modeled how structural networks facilitate state transitions from an initial baseline state to the target state. In the initial state, all regions had an activity magnitude of 0. In the target state, regions in the fronto-parietal system had activity magnitude of 1, with all other regions having an activity magnitude of 0. Specifically, we defined the trajectory of a neural system to be the temporal path that the system traverses through diverse states, where the item state was defined as the vector of neurophysiological activity across brain regions at a single time point. Based on each participant’s unique network topology, we estimated the regional energetic cost required for the brain to transition from the baseline to the fronto-parietal activation target state (Betzel et al., 2016; Gu et al., 2017; Stiso et al., 2019; Figure 1—figure supplement 2 and Figure 1a). Formally, this estimation was operationalized as a multi-point network control optimization problem, where we aimed to identify the optimal trajectory between baseline and the fronto-parietal activation target state that minimizes both the energetic cost and the distance between the final state and the target state. Figure 1 with 3 supplements see all Download asset Open asset Schematic of the network control approach and the estimation of control energy. (a) From a baseline state, we calculated the control energy required to reach a fronto-parietal activation target state. This transition was calculated for each subject based on their structural brain network, which was estimated using diffusion imaging and probabilistic tractography. (b) The average energetic costs to reach the fronto-parietal activation target state varied by cognitive system, with the largest energetic costs being present in the fronto-parietal control network and the ventral attention network. (c) The regional control energy required to reach the fronto-parietal activation target. (d) The control energy cost of a transition to the fronto-parietal activation target state was significantly lower in real brain networks than in null model networks where the strength and degree distribution were preserved. Results of this linear dynamical model indicate that the trajectory distance (i.e., the distance between current and target states) decreases with time until the desired target state is reached (Figure 1—figure supplement 3a and b). For each network node, we calculated the control energy cost, which provides an indication of where energy must be injected into the network to achieve the transition to the target state. Consistent with a recent methodological study (Karrer et al., 2019), and several recent empirical studies (Betzel et al., 2016; Gu et al., 2017; Stiso et al., 2019), the trajectory distance (Figure 1—figure supplement 3b) was inversely related to the time-dependent energy cost within subject (Figure 1—figure supplement 3c). We calculated the trajectory distance at each time point, which was defined as the Euclidean distance between the current brain state and the target brain state. A small distance suggests that the current vector of brain activity is similar to the target vector of brain activity. Across all subjects, we found the total trajectory distance of all time points was positively correlated with total control energy of all time points (r = 0.97, p<2 × 10−16, Figure 1—figure supplement 3d), suggesting that subjects whose state transition trajectory is long require more energy input to reach the target state. Prior literature has demonstrated that control energy cost is lower in human brain than in the brains of Drosophila and mouse to support diverse network dynamics (Kim et al., 2018), is related to network topology (Betzel et al., 2016; Kim et al., 2018) and reflects the magnitude of focal electrocorticography stimulation required to drive the brain to a target memory state in patients with medically refractory epilepsy (Stiso et al., 2019). Accordingly, here we used the control energy as a metric to summarize the optimal trajectory. We calculated the mean control energy of each system; the highest control energy was observed in systems involved in executive function (Figure 1b and c), including the fronto-parietal and ventral attention/cingulo-opercular systems (see Figure 1—figure supplement 2; Yeo et al., 2011). Based on recent evidence that network control properties depend appreciably on the topological structure of the network (Kim et al., 2018; Wu-Yan et al., 2017), we next sought to demonstrate that the topological structure of brain networks facilitates this transition. We therefore compared the energetic cost of this transition in empirical brain networks to the energetic cost observed in null model networks. Specifically, we randomly permuted (100 times per participant) the placement of edge weights, while preserving the network degree and strength distribution. The mean whole brain energetic cost of the null networks was significantly higher (p<2 × 10−16) than that of the empirical networks (Figure 1d), indicating that structural brain networks are topologically optimized to reduce the energetic costs of the transition to a fronto-parietal activation state. Energetic costs of the transition to a fronto-parietal activation state decline with development Having shown that the topology of structural brain networks facilitates transitions to a fronto-parietal activation state, we next investigated how the energetic costs of this transition evolve in youth. We hypothesized that the energy required to make this transition would decline as networks were remodeled in development. Prior studies have demonstrated that the developmental changes of both brain structure and function could be either linear (Hagmann et al., 2010; Wierenga et al., 2016) or non-linear (Grayson and Fair, 2017; Mills et al., 2016; Vandekar et al., 2015). Therefore, we used generalized additive models (GAM) with penalized splines, which allowed us to rigorously characterize both linear and nonlinear effects while avoiding over-fitting. Age associations with control energy were examined at multiple scales, including the level of the whole brain, cognitive systems, and individual nodes. For all analyses, we included sex, handedness, in-scanner head motion, total brain volume, and total network strength as covariates. These analyses revealed that the whole-brain average energetic cost of the transition to the fronto-parietal activation state declined with age (Z = −5.12, p=3.06 × 10−7, Partial r = −0.17, 95% confidence interval (CI) = [−0.23,–0.10]; Figure 2a). Notably, analyses of cognitive systems indicated that age effects were heterogeneously distributed (Figure 2b), with the largest declines in control energy occurring in fronto-parietal (Z = −5.30, PFDR = 4.54 × 10−7, Partial r = −0.17, CI = [−0.23,–0.11]; Figure 2c), visual (Z = −4.25, PFDR = 5.71 × 10−5, Partial r = −0.14, CI = [−0.20,–0.08]), and motor (Z = −3.20, PFDR = 2.70 × 10−3, Partial r = −0.09, CI = [−0.15,–0.03]) systems. In contrast, energetic costs within the limbic (Z = 8.69, PFDR <2 × 10−16, Partial r = 0.29, CI = [0.23, 0.35]) and default mode (Z = 2.86, PFDR = 5.66 × 10−3, Partial r = 0.10, CI = [0.04, 0.17]) systems increased with age (see Figure 2—figure supplement 1). These system-level results aligned with analyses of individual network nodes; we found that the control energy of 49 regions decreased significantly with age (PFDR <0.05), including regions in the fronto-parietal control, visual, and motor systems. Furthermore, the control energy significantly increased with development in 30 regions (PFDR <0.05), which were mainly situated in limbic and default mode systems (Figure 2d). Figure 2 with 4 supplements see all Download asset Open asset Control energy evolves with age in youth. (a) The mean whole-brain control energy required to reach the fronto-parietal activation target declines with age. (b) Control energy declines significantly with age in the fronto-parietal, visual, motor and subcortical systems. In contrast, control energy increased in the ventral attention, default mode and limbic systems. For each system with a significant association, the effect size is reported (in each bar) as the partial correlation between system-level control energy and age while controlling for the covariates. There is one outlier in the scatter plot of ventral attention system (Figure 2—figure supplement 1c) and the age-related changes of control energy was not significant (p=0.11) in this system after removing the outlier. (c) The control energy of the fronto-parietal system declines significantly with age. (d) The age effect of control energy for each brain region. The color of the contour of each brain region represents the cognitive system for each region (see Figure 1—figure supplement 2). In the scatterplots shown in panels (a and c), data points represent each subject (n = 946), the bold line indicates the best fit from a general additive model, and the shaded envelope denotes the 95% confidence interval. It should be noted that Z value was derived from the general additive model, which captures both linear and nonlinear relationships; the partial correlation reflects only linear relationships. VS: visual; MT: motor; DA: dorsal attention; VA: ventral attention; LM: limbic; FP: fronto-parietal; DM: default mode; SC: subcortical. Having found associations between age and control energy, we next conducted a series of eight additional analyses. First, we found that our results held true for a range of baseline initial states and a range of fronto-parietal activation target states. When 100 different initial baseline states were evaluated, we found that in all cases both the whole brain and the fronto-parietal system showed a significant decline in control energy with age (Figure 2—figure supplement 2a). Similarly, when 100 different target states of fronto-parietal activation were evaluated, we found that in all cases both the whole-brain and the fronto-parietal system showed a significant decline in control energy with age (Figure 2—figure supplement 2b). Second, we evaluated whether age effects could be due to non-topological network properties by evaluating the presence of age effects in null networks where degree and strength distributions were preserved. We found that the significance level of age effects in null networks were smaller than those observed in the real network (p<0.01, 100 permutations), suggesting that the empirically measured developmental effects were indeed driven by changes in the network topology (Figure 2—figure supplement 2c). Third, it should be noted that we only constrained the state of regions in the fronto-parietal system. Therefore, the distance travelled by these off-target regions outside the fronto-parietal system were not included in our cost function for calculating optimal control energy. This choice also serves to ensure that our calculation of control energy is largely robust to both the initial and target states of other regions. To demonstrate the robustness of our results to our definition of the matrix S, we calculated the control energy cost using the same initial and target states as in the main analyses but constraining the whole brain. Results showed that there is a high correlation (r = 0.94, p<2 × 10−16) between the whole-brain control energy cost when constraining the whole brain and that when constraining the fronto-parietal system only (Figure 2—figure supplement 2d). Fourth, we assessed whether the structural network optimized the transition to an a priori motor system activation target (Figure 1—figure supplement 2; Yeo et al., 2011). Results indicated that the mean whole brain energetic cost of the null networks was significantly higher (p<2 × 10−16) than that of the empirical networks (Figure 2—figure supplement 2e left), suggesting that the lower energetic cost of activtivating thefronto-parietal system was not unique, but was present when activating other systems as well. We further evaluated the age effects of control energy cost to activate the motor system. As the age range of 8–23 years is a critical period in the development of executive function rather than motor function, we expected weaker age effects in the motor system. We found that the whole-brain control energy required to transition to the motor system activation did not significantly change over the age range studied (Z = 1.48, p=0.14, Partial r = 0.05, CI = [−0.02, 0.11]; Figure 2—figure supplement 2e right). Fifth, we evaluated whether our developmental results could be explained by modal controllability. Modal controllability reflects the extent to which all dynamic modes of a system will change in response to small changes at a single node (Gu et al., 2015). If an individual has high modal controllability, it suggests that the underlying brain structural network was optimized to support efficient state transitions to diverse states. In line with this intuition, modal controllability increases with development in youth as flexible switching between patterns of brain activity becomes more common (Tang et al., 2017). Controlling for modal controllability did not alter our results (Figure 2—figure supplement 3a). Specifically, while controlling for modal controllability, average control energy of the whole-brain and fronto-parietal system both significantly declined with age (whole-brain: Z = −6.00, p=2.09 × 10−9, Partial r = −0.19, CI = [−0.25,–0.13]; fronto-parietal: Z = −9.95, PFDR <2 × 10−16, Partial r = −0.32, CI = [−0.37,–0.26]). Sixth, because the modularity of brain networks evolves with age, one could ask whether that evolution impacts the observed assocations with control energy (Baum et al., 2017; Hagmann et al., 2010; Huang et al., 2015). However, we found that results remained consistent after controlling for network modularity in all analyses (Figure 2—figure supplement 3b). For example, average control energy of the whole brain and of the fronto-parietal system both significantly declined with age after controlling for network modularity (whole-brain: Z = −3.95, p=7.73 × 10−5, Partial r = −0.13, CI = [−0.19,–0.07]; fronto-parietal: Z = −4.31, PFDR = 6.46 × 10−5, Partial r = −0.14, CI = [−0.20,–0.08]). We further assessed whether the increasing segregation of fronto-parietal system during youth (Baum et al., 2017) could explain the age effect of control energy. Results remained consistent after controlling for the average participation coefficient within the fronto-parietal system when examining age-related differences in the average control energy of the fronto-parietal system (Z = −4.64, p=3.51 × 10−6, Partial r = −0.15, CI = [−0.21,–0.09]). Seventh, we assessed whether connectivity within the fronto-parietal system or between the fronto-parietal and other systems could explain observed associations between age and control energy. Specifically, we calculated the sum of all the connections within fronto-parietal system and also the sum of all the connections between the fronto-parietal system and other systems. While controlling for within fronto-parietal connectivity strength, the control energy in the fronto-parietal system still significantly declined with development (Z = −3.53, p=0.0004, Partial r = −0.12, CI = [−0.18,–0.06]). Similarly, while controlling for the connectivity strength between the fronto-parietal system and other systems, the control energy in the fronto-parietal system still significantly declined with development (Z = −4.88, p=1.06 × 10−6, Partial r = −0.16, CI = [−0.22,–0.10]). Finally, in our main analyses, we specified the target state as regions within the fronto-parietal system, with each region having a magnitude of 1. As a final step, we also considered a biologically recorded target state defined as the average activation pattern elicited by an n-back working memory task that reliably recruits the fronto-parietal system (Figure 2—figure supplement 4a). Using this alternative target state, we found that the control energy cost of the real network was significantly lower than null networks (Figure 2—figure supplement 4b). As in the main analyses, the control energy cost was highest in the fronto-parietal system (Figure 2—figure supplement 4c). Similarly, the whole-brain average control energy cost (Z = −7.59, p=3.26 × 10−14, Partial r = −0.25, CI = [−0.30,–0.18]; Figure 2—figure supplement 4d) and average control energy in the fronto-parietal system (Z = −5.26, PFDR = 2.92 × 10−7, Partial r = −0.17, CI = [−0.23,–0.11]; Figure 2—figure supplement 4e) both significantly declined with age. Nodal analyses provided convergent results, revealing that the control energy in nodes within the fronto-parietal system significantly declined with age (Figure 2—figure supplement 4f). Patterns of control energy can predict brain maturity Having established that the control energy required to reach the fronto-parietal activation state changes with age on a regional and system-level basis using mass-univariate analysis, we next evaluated the developmental changes of control energy using multivariate pattern analysis. Multivariate pattern analysis complements mass-univariate analysis, as mass-univariate analysis investigates each feature (i.e., control energy of one brain region) in isolation. In contrast, multivariate pattern analyses are sensitive to the spatially distributed pattern of features (Davatzikos, 2004; Haynes, 2015; Haynes and Rees, 2006; Norman et al., 2006). To provide an integrated view of this high-dimensional data, we used multivariate pattern analysis to determine whether spatially distributed patterns of control energy could accurately predict participant age. Specifically, we applied ridge regression with nested two-fold cross validation (2F-CV, see Figure 3—figure supplement 1) to identify an individual participant’s age in an unbiased fashion using the multivariate pattern of regional control energy. Specifically, we divided all subjects into two subsets based on age, with the first subset used as a training set and the second subset used as a testing set. Within the training set, we used inner 2F-CV to select an optimal regularization parameter (λ). Then, we trained a model using the training data and predicted the brain maturity (i.e., ‘brain age’) of participants in the testing set (Dosenbach et al., 2010; Franke et al., 2010). The significance of the model was evaluated using permutation testing, where the correspondence between a subject’s control energy features and their age was permuted at random. This analysis revealed that the multivariate pattern of control energy could predict an unseen individual’s age (Figure 3a and Figure 3—figure supplement 2a and b): the correlation between the predicted ‘brain age’ and chronological age was 0.63 (p < 0.001) after controlling for the covariates, and the mean absolute error (MAE) was 2.16 years (p < 0.001). For completeness, we also repeated this procedure while reversing the training and test sets, which yielded very similar results (partial r = 0.58, p < 0.001; MAE = 2.27, p < 0.001; Figure 3a and Figure 3—figure supplement 2c and d). We further examined model weights at the level of individual network nodes. The regions that contributed the most to the prediction of brain maturity aligned with mass-univariate analyses, and included the dorsolateral and ventrolateral prefrontal cortex, the cingulate cortex, superior parietal cortex, and lateral temporal cortex (Figure 3b). In order to ensure that our initial split of the data was representative, we repeated this analysis with 100 random splits, which returned highly consistent results (mean partial r = 0.61, mean MAE = 2.21 years). Figure 3 with 2 supplements see all Download asset Open asset The whole-brain control energy pattern contains sufficient information to predict brain maturity in unseen individuals. (a) The predicted brain maturity index was significantly related to the chronological age in a multivariate ridge regression model that used 2-fold cross validation (2F-CV) with nested parameter tuning. The complete sample of of subjects was divided into two subsets according to age rank. The blue color represents the best-fit line between the actual score of the first subset of subjects and their scores predicted by the model trained using the second subset of subjects. The green color represents the best-fit line between the actual score of the second subset of subjects and their scores predicted by the model trained using the first subset of
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
-
Optimization of Energy State Transition Trajectory Supports the Development of Executive Function During Youth.
Zaixu Cui,Jennifer Stiso,Graham L. Baum,Jason Z. Kim,David R. Roalf,Richard F. Betzel,Shi Gu,Zhixin Lu,Cedric H. Xia,Xiaosong He,Rastko Ciric,Desmond J. Oathes,Tyler M. Moore,Russell T. Shinohara,Kosha Ruparel,Christos Davatzikos,Fabio Pasqualetti,Raquel E. Gur,Ruben C. Gur,Danielle S. Bassett,Theodore D. Satterthwaite
DOI: https://doi.org/10.7554/elife.53060
IF: 7.7
2020-01-01
eLife
Abstract:Executive function develops during adolescence, yet it remains unknown how structural brain networks mature to facilitate activation of the fronto-parietal system, which is critical for executive function. In a sample of 946 human youths (ages 8-23y) who completed diffusion imaging, we capitalized upon recent advances in linear dynamical network control theory to calculate the energetic cost necessary to activate the fronto-parietal system through the control of multiple brain regions given existing structural network topology. We found that the energy required to activate the fronto-parietal system declined with development, and the pattern of regional energetic cost predicts unseen individuals' brain maturity. Finally, energetic requirements of the cingulate cortex were negatively correlated with executive performance, and partially mediated the development of executive performance with age. Our results reveal a mechanism by which structural networks develop during adolescence to reduce the theoretical energetic costs of transitions to activation states necessary for executive function.
-
Changes in Behavior and Neural Dynamics across Adolescent Development
Lucrezia Liuzzi,Daniel S Pine,Nathan A Fox,Bruno B Averbeck
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1523/JNEUROSCI.0462-23.2023
2023-12-13
Abstract:Adolescence is an important developmental period, during which substantial changes occur in brain function and behavior. Several aspects of executive function, including response inhibition, improve during this period. Correspondingly, structural imaging studies have documented consistent decreases in cortical and subcortical gray matter volume, and postmortem histologic studies have found substantial (∼40%) decreases in excitatory synapses in prefrontal cortex. Recent computational modeling work suggests that the change in synaptic density underlie improvements in task performance. These models also predict changes in neural dynamics related to the depth of attractor basins, where deeper basins can underlie better task performance. In this study, we analyzed task-related neural dynamics in a large cohort of longitudinally followed subjects (male and female) spanning early to late adolescence. We found that age correlated positively with behavioral performance in the Eriksen Flanker task. Older subjects were also characterized by deeper attractor basins around task related evoked EEG potentials during specific cognitive operations. Thus, consistent with computational models examining the effects of excitatory synaptic pruning, older adolescents showed stronger attractor dynamics during task performance.SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT There are well-documented changes in brain and behavior during adolescent development. However, there are few mechanistic theories that link changes in the brain to changes in behavior. Here, we tested a hypothesis, put forward on the basis of computational modeling, that pruning of excitatory synapses in cortex during adolescence changes neural dynamics. We found, consistent with the hypothesis, that variability around event-related potentials shows faster decay dynamics in older adolescent subjects. The faster decay dynamics are consistent with the hypothesis that synaptic pruning during adolescent development leads to stronger attractor basins in task-related neural activity.
-
Flexible Traversal Through Diverse Brain States Underlies Executive Function in Normative Neurodevelopment
John D. Medaglia,Theodore D. Satterthwaite,Tyler M. Moore,Kosha Ruparel,Ruben C. Gur,Raquel E. Gur,Danielle S. Bassett
DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1510.08780
2015-10-29
Neurons and Cognition
Abstract:Adolescence is marked by rapid development of executive function. Mounting evidence suggests that executive function in adults may be driven by dynamic control of neurophysiological processes. Yet, how these dynamics evolve over adolescence and contribute to cognitive development is unknown. Using a novel dynamic graph approach in which each moment in time is a node and the similarity in brain states at two different times is an edge, we identify two primary brain states reminiscent of intrinsic and task-evoked systems. We demonstrate that time spent in these two states increases over development, as does the flexibility with which the brain switches between them. Increasing time spent in primary states and flexibility among states relates to increased executive performance over adolescence. Indeed, flexibility is increasingly advantageous for performance toward early adulthood. These findings demonstrate that brain state dynamics underlie the development of executive function during the critical period of adolescence.
-
Developmental Increases in White Matter Network Controllability Support a Growing Diversity of Brain Dynamics
Evelyn Tang,Chad Giusti,Graham L. Baum,Shi Gu,Eli Pollock,Ari E. Kahn,David R. Roalf,Tyler M. Moore,Kosha Ruparel,Ruben C. Gur,Raquel E. Gur,Theodore D. Satterthwaite,Danielle S. Bassett
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-017-01254-4
IF: 16.6
2017-01-01
Nature Communications
Abstract:As the human brain develops, it increasingly supports coordinated control of neural activity. The mechanism by which white matter evolves to support this coordination is not well understood. Here we use a network representation of diffusion imaging data from 882 youth ages 8-22 to show that white matter connectivity becomes increasingly optimized for a diverse range of predicted dynamics in development. Notably, stable controllers in subcortical areas are negatively related to cognitive performance. Investigating structural mechanisms supporting these changes, we simulate network evolution with a set of growth rules. We find that all brain networks are structured in a manner highly optimized for network control, with distinct control mechanisms predicted in child vs. older youth. We demonstrate that our results cannot be explained by changes in network modularity. This work reveals a possible mechanism of human brain development that preferentially optimizes dynamic network control over static network architecture.
-
Optimal Trajectories Of Brain State Transitions Indicate Motor Function Changes Associated With Aging
Hong Zhu,Jie Zhou,Pin Shu,Shanbao Tong,Junfeng Sun
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/EMBC.2019.8857778
2019-01-01
Abstract:Healthy aging is associated with structural and functional changes in sensorimotor systems, leading to a deterioration in motor function. However, most of the previous studies focused on the descriptive measures of alteration, little is known about how structural network facilitate functional dynamics during aging. Based on the structural brain network constructed by diffusion-weighted imaging, we employed recent network control theory to evaluate the control energy necessary to drive the state transition from baseline condition with default mode network (DMN) activation to motor network activation in a large cohort (n = 625; 18-88 years). We found at the whole, the control energy required to activate the motor network declined with aging, in which the motor network contributed most of the control energy. The control energy of nodes within motor network showed both positive and negative age effects, reflecting an aberrant functional integration associated with aging. Interestingly, the control energy of subcortical network most significantly increased with aging, suggesting an altered motor-subcortical circuit, thus requiring more energy for the optimal control. Moreover, the control energy of bilateral putamen showed the largest positive age effect, and this pattern was also supported by the energetic impact of nodes, implying a key role for motor modulation associated with aging. Taken together, our results offer insights of control energy cost necessary for the age-dependent decline in motor task, and provide new clues for brain optimal control of neuromodulation in older adults.
-
Developmental and aging resting functional magnetic resonance imaging brain state adaptations in adolescents and adults: A large N (>47K) study
Anees Abrol,Zening Fu,Yuhui Du,Tony W. Wilson,Yu‐Ping Wang,Julia M. Stephen,Vince D. Calhoun
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/hbm.26200
IF: 4.8
2023-01-13
Human Brain Mapping
Abstract:We highlight the replicable time‐resolved developmental and aging functional brain patterns in a systematic evaluation of over 47,000 youth and adult brains. Our study captured the most contrastive difference between the two life stages in a brain state that indicated coherent strengthening and modularization of functional coupling within the auditory, visual, and motor sub‐domains, supplemented by anticorrelation with other subdomains in adults, a pattern that was consistently less modular or absent in adolescents and presented a negative association with age in adults, thus indicating an overall inverted U‐shaped trajectory. This indicates greater synchrony, strengthening, modularization, and integration of the brain's functional connections beyond adolescence, and the gradual decline of this pattern during the healthy aging process. The brain's functional architecture and organization undergo continual development and modification throughout adolescence. While it is well known that multiple factors govern brain maturation, the constantly evolving patterns of time‐resolved functional connectivity are still unclear and understudied. We systematically evaluated over 47,000 youth and adult brains to bridge this gap, highlighting replicable time‐resolved developmental and aging functional brain patterns. The largest difference between the two life stages was captured in a brain state that indicated coherent strengthening and modularization of functional coupling within the auditory, visual, and motor subdomains, supplemented by anticorrelation with other subdomains in adults. This distinctive pattern, which we replicated in independent data, was consistently less modular or absent in children and presented a negative association with age in adults, thus indicating an overall inverted U‐shaped trajectory. This indicates greater synchrony, strengthening, modularization, and integration of the brain's functional connections beyond adolescence, and gradual decline of this pattern during the healthy aging process. We also found evidence that the developmental changes may also bring along a departure from the canonical static functional connectivity pattern in favor of more efficient and modularized utilization of the vast brain interconnections. State‐based statistical summary measures presented robust and significant group differences that also showed significant age‐related associations. The findings reported in this article support the idea of gradual developmental and aging brain state adaptation processes in different phases of life and warrant future research via lifespan studies to further authenticate the projected time‐resolved brain state trajectories.
radiology, nuclear medicine & medical imaging,neurosciences,neuroimaging
-
Modular Segregation of Structural Brain Networks Supports the Development of Executive Function in Youth
Graham L. Baum,Rastko Ciric,David R. Roalf,Richard F. Betzel,Tyler M. Moore,Russell T. Shinohara,Ari E. Kahn,Simon N. Vandekar,Petra E. Rupert,Megan Quarmley,Philip A. Cook,Mark A. Elliott,Kosha Ruparel,Raquel E. Gur,Ruben C. Gur,Danielle S. Bassett,Theodore D. Satterthwaite
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2017.04.051
IF: 9.2
2017-06-01
Current Biology
Abstract:The human brain is organized into large-scale functional modules that have been shown to evolve in childhood and adolescence. However, it remains unknown whether the underlying white matter architecture is similarly refined during development, potentially allowing for improvements in executive function. In a sample of 882 participants (ages 8-22) who underwent diffusion imaging as part of the Philadelphia Neurodevelopmental Cohort, we demonstrate that structural network modules become more segregated with age, with weaker connections between modules and stronger connections within modules. Evolving modular topology facilitates global network efficiency and is driven by age-related strengthening of hub edges present both within and between modules. Critically, both modular segregation and network efficiency are associated with enhanced executive performance and mediate the improvement of executive functioning with age. Together, results delineate a process of structural network maturation that supports executive function in youth.
cell biology,biochemistry & molecular biology,biology
-
Development of brain-state dynamics involved in working memory
Ying He,Xinyuan Liang,Menglu Chen,Ting Tian,Yimeng Zeng,Jin Liu,Lei Hao,Jiahua Xu,Rui Chen,Yanpei Wang,Jia-Hong Gao,Shuping Tan,Jalil Taghia,Yong He,Sha Tao,Qi Dong,Shaozheng Qin
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/cercor/bhad022
IF: 4.861
2023-02-28
Cerebral Cortex
Abstract:Human functional brain networks are dynamically organized to enable cognitive and behavioral flexibility to meet ever-changing environmental demands. Frontal-parietal network (FPN) and default mode network (DMN) are recognized to play an essential role in executive functions such as working memory. However, little is known about the developmental differences in the brain-state dynamics of these two networks involved in working memory from childhood to adulthood. Here, we implemented Bayesian switching dynamical systems approach to identify brain states of the FPN and DMN during working memory in 69 school-age children and 51 adults. We identified five brain states with rapid transitions, which are characterized by dynamic configurations among FPN and DMN nodes with active and inactive engagement in different task demands. Compared with adults, children exhibited less frequent brain states with the highest activity in FPN nodes dominant to high demand, and its occupancy rate increased with age. Children preferred to attain inactive brain states with low activity in both FPN and DMN nodes. Moreover, children exhibited lower transition probability from low-to-high demand states and such a transition was positively correlated with working memory performance. Notably, higher transition probability from low-to-high demand states was associated with a stronger structural connectivity across FPN and DMN, but with weaker structure–function coupling of these two networks. These findings extend our understanding of how FPN and DMN nodes are dynamically organized into a set of transient brain states to support moment-to-moment information updating during working memory and suggest immature organization of these functional brain networks in childhood, which is constrained by the structural connectivity.
neurosciences
-
Cognitive Control and Neural Activity during Human Development: Evidence for Synaptic Pruning
Leland L. Fleming,Timothy J. McDermott
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1523/jneurosci.0373-24.2024
2024-06-27
Journal of Neuroscience
Abstract:The modern world is full of distractions that steal our attention from important tasks. As a result, the world places ever-growing demands on cognitive control: the ability to coordinate mental resources to achieve our goals (Koechlin et al., 2003). A key mediator of cognitive control is the prefrontal cortex (PFC), which is heavily involved in processes like learning and memory, attention, and inhibition of improper responses (Koechlin et al., 2003). Yet the PFC, with its sophisticated circuitry that enables these roles, is one of the last brain regions to develop (Hill et al., 2010; Kolk and Rakic, 2022). Indeed, the maturation of the PFC is an important component of adolescent development (Larsen and Luna, 2018), as is the development of cognitive control. This delayed development of the PFC may lead to undesired outcomes, such as risky behaviors in teenagers (Larsen and Luna, 2018), which may be linked specifically to deficits in response inhibition or the suppression of competing responses during a given task or everyday situation (Luna and Sweeney, 2004). Therefore, understanding the developmental changes in the circuitry that underlies cognitive control, particularly response inhibition, is an important area of investigation. A major component of PFC maturation is the removal of excess connections via synaptic pruning (Kolk and Rakic, 2022). During early childhood, the PFC undergoes rapid expansion, with dorsolateral and medial PFC expanding to nearly double the surface area of other cortical regions such as occipital and insular cortices (Hill et al., 2010). Underlying this rapid expansion is a period of extensive synaptic growth (synaptogenesis), which begins prenatally but peaks postnatally (Teffer and Semendeferi, 2012), at ∼3.5 years of age in humans (Kolk and Rakic, 2022). PFC cortical thickness, which can serve as a measure of synaptic density, also shows rapid growth early in ... Correspondence should be addressed to Leland L. Fleming at llfleming{at}mclean.harvard.edu.
neurosciences
-
Prefrontal Excitation/Inhibition Balance Supports Adolescent Enhancements in Circuit Signal to Noise Ratio
Shane D McKeon,Maria I Perica,Finnegan J Calabro,Will Foran,Hoby Hetherington,Chan-Hong Moon,Beatriz Luna
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.08.15.608100
2024-08-19
bioRxiv
Abstract:The development and refinement of neuronal circuitry allow for stabilized and efficient neural recruitment, supporting adult-like behavioral performance. During adolescence, the maturation of PFC is proposed to be a critical period (CP) for executive function, driven by a break in balance between glutamatergic excitation and GABAergic inhibition (E/I) neurotransmission. During CPs, cortical circuitry fine-tunes to improve information processing and reliable responses to stimuli, shifting from spontaneous to evoked activity, enhancing the SNR, and promoting neural synchronization. Harnessing 7T MR spectroscopy and EEG in a longitudinal cohort (N = 164, ages 10-32 years, 283 neuroimaging sessions), we outline associations between age-related changes in glutamate and GABA neurotransmitters and EEG measures of cortical SNR. We find developmental decreases in spontaneous activity and increases in cortical SNR during our auditory steady state task using 40 Hz stimuli. Decreases in spontaneous activity were associated with glutamate levels in DLPFC, while increases in cortical SNR were associated with more balanced Glu and GABA levels. These changes were associated with improvements in working memory performance. This study provides evidence of CP plasticity in the human PFC during adolescence, leading to stabilized circuitry that allows for the optimal recruitment and integration of multisensory input, resulting in improved executive function.
-
Prefrontal Excitation/ Inhibition Balance Supports Adolescent Enhancements in Circuit Signal to Noise Ratio
Shane D McKeon,Maria I Perica,Finnegan J Calabro,Will Foran,Hoby Hetherington,Chan-Hong Moon,Beatriz Luna
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.08.15.608100
2024-08-19
Abstract:The development and refinement of neuronal circuitry allow for stabilized and efficient neural recruitment, supporting adult-like behavioral performance. During adolescence, the maturation of PFC is proposed to be a critical period (CP) for executive function, driven by a break in balance between glutamatergic excitation and GABAergic inhibition (E/I) neurotransmission. During CPs, cortical circuitry fine-tunes to improve information processing and reliable responses to stimuli, shifting from spontaneous to evoked activity, enhancing the SNR, and promoting neural synchronization. Harnessing 7T MR spectroscopy and EEG in a longitudinal cohort (N = 164, ages 10-32 years, 283 neuroimaging sessions), we outline associations between age-related changes in glutamate and GABA neurotransmitters and EEG measures of cortical SNR. We find developmental decreases in spontaneous activity and increases in cortical SNR during our auditory steady state task using 40 Hz stimuli. Decreases in spontaneous activity were associated with glutamate levels in DLPFC, while increases in cortical SNR were associated with more balanced Glu and GABA levels. These changes were associated with improvements in working memory performance. This study provides evidence of CP plasticity in the human PFC during adolescence, leading to stabilized circuitry that allows for the optimal recruitment and integration of multisensory input, resulting in improved executive function.
Neuroscience
-
Neural substrates of the executive function construct, age‐related changes, and task materials in adolescents and adults: ALE meta‐analyses of 408 fMRI studies
Zheng Zhang,Peng Peng,Simon B. Eickhoff,Xin Lin,Delong Zhang,Yingying Wang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/desc.13111
IF: 3.7
2021-04-04
Developmental Science
Abstract:<p>To explore the neural substrates of executive function (EF), we conducted an activation likelihood estimation meta‐analysis of 408 functional magnetic resonance imaging studies (9639 participants, 7587 activation foci, 518 experimental contrasts) covering three fundamental EF subcomponents: inhibition, switching, and working memory. Our results found that activation common to all three EF subcomponents converged in the multiple‐demand network across adolescence and adulthood. The function of EF with the multiple‐demand network involved, especially for the prefrontal cortex and the parietal regions, could not be mature until adulthood. In adolescents, only working memory could be separable from common EF, whereas in adults, the three EF subcomponents could be separable from common EF. However, findings of switching in adolescents should be treated with substantial caution and may be exploratory due to limited data available on switching tasks. For task materials, inhibition and working memory showed both domain generality and domain specificity, undergirded by the multiple‐demand network, as well as different brain regions in response to verbal and nonverbal task materials, respectively. In contrast, switching showed only domain generality with no activation specialized for either verbal or nonverbal task materials. These findings, taken together, support and contribute to the unitary–diverse nature of EF such that EF should be interpreted in an integrative model that relies on the integration of the EF construct, development, and task materials.</p>
psychology, experimental, developmental
-
Brain topology underlying executive functions across the lifespan: focus on the default mode network
A Menardi,M Spoa,A Vallesi
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2024.1441584
2024-09-04
Abstract:Introduction: While traditional neuroimaging approaches to the study of executive functions (EFs) have typically employed task-evoked paradigms, resting state studies are gaining popularity as a tool for investigating inter-individual variability in the functional connectome and its relationship to cognitive performance outside of the scanner. Method: Using resting state functional magnetic resonance imaging data from the Human Connectome Project Lifespan database, the present study capitalized on graph theory to chart cross-sectional variations in the intrinsic functional organization of the frontoparietal (FPN) and the default mode (DMN) networks in 500 healthy individuals (from 10 to 100 years of age), to investigate the neural underpinnings of EFs across the lifespan. Results: Topological properties of both the FPN and DMN were associated with EF performance but not with a control task of picture naming, providing specificity in support for a tight link between neuro-functional and cognitive-behavioral efficiency within the EF domain. The topological organization of the DMN, however, appeared more sensitive to age-related changes relative to that of the FPN. Discussion: The DMN matures earlier in life than the FPN and it ıs more susceptible to neurodegenerative changes. Because its activity is stronger in conditions of resting state, the DMN might be easier to measure in noncompliant populations and in those at the extremes of the life-span curve, namely very young or elder participants. Here, we argue that the study of its functional architecture in relation to higher order cognition across the lifespan might, thus, be of greater interest compared with what has been traditionally thought.
-
Maturation of widely distributed brain function subserves cognitive development.
B Luna,K R Thulborn,D P Munoz,E P Merriam,K E Garver,N J Minshew,M S Keshavan,C R Genovese,W F Eddy,J A Sweeney
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1006/nimg.2000.0743
IF: 5.7
2001-01-01
NeuroImage
Abstract:Cognitive and brain maturational changes continue throughout late childhood and adolescence. During this time, increasing cognitive control over behavior enhances the voluntary suppression of reflexive/impulsive response tendencies. Recently, with the advent of functional MRI, it has become possible to characterize changes in brain activity during cognitive development. In order to investigate the cognitive and brain maturation subserving the ability to voluntarily suppress context-inappropriate behavior, we tested 8-30 year olds in an oculomotor response-suppression task. Behavioral results indicated that adult-like ability to inhibit prepotent responses matured gradually through childhood and adolescence. Functional MRI results indicated that brain activation in frontal, parietal, striatal, and thalamic regions increased progressively from childhood to adulthood. Prefrontal cortex was more active in adolescents than in children or adults; adults demonstrated greater activation in the lateral cerebellum than younger subjects. These results suggest that efficient top-down modulation of reflexive acts may not be fully developed until adulthood and provide evidence that maturation of function across widely distributed brain regions lays the groundwork for enhanced voluntary control of behavior during cognitive development.
-
The Lifespan Trajectories of Brain Activities Related to Cognitive Control
Guochun Yang,Zhenghan Li,Isaac T. Petersen,Lingxiao Wang,Joaquim Radua,Xun Liu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2023.08.20.554018
2024-09-17
Abstract:Cognitive control plays a pivotal role in guiding human goal-directed behavior, and revealing its lifespan trajectory is crucial for optimizing cognitive functioning at different ages, especially for stages of rapid development and decline. While existing studies have shed light on the inverted U-shaped trajectory of cognitive control function both behaviorally and anatomically, little is known about the corresponding changes in functional brain activation with age. To bridge this gap, we conducted a comprehensive meta-analysis of 129 neuroimaging studies using conflict tasks, encompassing 3,388 participants whose age spanned from 5 to 85 years old. We applied the seed-based d mapping (SDM), generalized additive model (GAM) and model comparison approaches to investigate age-related changes of brain activity, chart the lifespan trajectories and pinpoint peaks of cognitive control brain activity. The present study have three major findings: 1) The inverted U-shaped lifespan trajectory is the predominant pattern; 2) Cognitive control related brain regions exhibit heterogeneous lifespan trajectories: the frontoparietal control network (such as the inferior frontal gyrus and inferior parietal lobule) follows inverted U-shaped trajectories, peaking between 24 and 40 years, while the dorsal attention network (such as the frontal eye field and superior parietal lobule) demonstrates flatter trajectories with age; 3) Both the youth and the elderly show weaker brain activities and greater left laterality than young adults. These results collectively reveal the lifespan trajectories of cognitive control, highlighting heterogeneous fluctuations in brain networks with age.
Neuroscience
-
Structural and functional brain parameters related to cognitive performance across development: Replication and extension of the parieto-frontal integration theory in a single sample
Ruben C. Gur,Ellyn R. Butler,Tyler M. Moore,Adon F.G. Rosen,Kosha Ruparel,Theodore D. Satterthwaite,David R. Roalf,Efstathios D. Gennatas,Warren B. Bilker,Russell T. Shinohara,Allison Port,Mark A. Elliott,Ragini Verma,Christos Davatzikos,Daniel H. Wolf,John A. Detre,Raquel E. Gur
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/659193
2019-06-04
Abstract:Abstract The Parieto-Frontal Integration Theory (PFIT) identified a fronto-parietal network of regions where individual differences in brain parameters most strongly relate to cognitive performance. PFIT was supported and extended in adult samples, but not in youths or within single-scanner well-powered multimodal studies. We performed multimodal neuroimaging in 1601 youths age 8-22 on the same 3-Tesla scanner with contemporaneous neurocognitive assessment, measuring volume, gray matter density (GMD), mean diffusivity (MD), cerebral blood flow (CBF), resting-state functional MRI measures of amplitude of low frequency fluctuations (ALFF) and regional homogeneity (ReHo), and activation to a working memory and a social cognition task. Across age and sex groups, better performance was associated with higher volumes, greater GMD, lower MD, lower CBF, higher ALFF and ReHo and greater activation for the working memory task in PFIT regions. However, additional cortical, striatal, limbic and cerebellar regions showed comparable effects, hence PFIT needs expansion into an Extended PFIT (ExtPFIT) network incorporating nodes that support motivation and affect. Associations of brain parameters became stronger with advancing age group from childhood to adolescence to young adulthood, effects occurring earlier in females. This ExtPFIT network is developmentally fine-tuned, optimizing abundance and integrity of neural tissue while maintaining low resting energy state.
-
Brain structure and activity predicting cognitive maturation in adolescence
Junda Zhu,Clément M Garin,Xue-Lian Qi,Anna Machado,Zhengyang Wang,Suliann Ben Hamed,Terrence R Stanford,Emilio Salinas,Christopher T Whitlow,Adam W Anderson,Xin Maizie Zhou,Finnegan J Calabro,Beatriz Luna,Christos Constantinidis
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.08.23.608315
2024-09-02
bioRxiv
Abstract:Cognitive abilities of primates, including humans, continue to improve through adolescence. While a range of changes in brain structure and connectivity have been documented, how they affect neuronal activity that ultimately determines performance of cognitive functions remains unknown. Here, we conducted a multilevel longitudinal study of monkey adolescent neurocognitive development. The developmental trajectory of neural activity in the prefrontal cortex accounted remarkably well for working memory improvements. While complex aspects of activity changed progressively during adolescence, such as the rotation of stimulus representation in multidimensional neuronal space, which has been implicated in cognitive flexibility, even simpler attributes, such as the baseline firing rate in the period preceding a stimulus appearance had predictive power over behavior. Unexpectedly, decreases in brain volume and thickness, which are widely thought to underlie cognitive changes in humans 5 did not predict well the trajectory of neural activity or cognitive performance changes. Whole brain cortical volume in particular, exhibited an increase and reached a local maximum in late adolescence, at a time of rapid behavioral improvement. Maturation of long-distance white matter tracts linking the frontal lobe with areas of the association cortex and subcortical regions best predicted changes in neuronal activity and behavior. Our results provide evidence that optimization of neural activity depending on widely distributed circuitry effects cognitive development in adolescence.
-
Longitudinal association of executive function and structural network controllability in the aging brain
Rongxiang Tang,Jeremy A. Elman,Carol E. Franz,Anders M. Dale,Lisa T. Eyler,Christine Fennema-Notestine,Donald J. Hagler,Michael J. Lyons,Matthew S. Panizzon,Olivia K. Puckett,William S. Kremen
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11357-022-00676-3
2022-10-23
GeroScience
Abstract:Executive function encompasses effortful cognitive processes that are particularly susceptible to aging. Functional brain networks supporting executive function—such as the frontoparietal control network and the multiple demand system—have been extensively investigated. However, it remains unclear how structural networks facilitate and constrain the dynamics of functional networks to contribute to aging-related executive function declines. We examined whether changes in structural network modal controllability—a network's ability to facilitate effortful brain state transitions that support cognitive functions—are associated with changes in executive function cross-sectionally and longitudinally. Diffusion-weighted imaging and neuropsychological testing were conducted at two time points (Time 1: ages 56 to 66, N = 172; Time 2: ages 61 to 70, N = 267) in community-dwelling men from the Vietnam Era Twin Study of Aging. An executive function factor score was computed from six neuropsychological tasks. Structural networks constructed from white matter connectivity were used to estimate modal controllability in control network and multiple demand system. We showed that higher modal controllability in control network and multiple demand system was associated with better executive function at Time 2, after controlling for age, young adult general cognitive ability, and physical health status. Moreover, changes in executive function over a period of 5 to 6 years (Time 1-Time 2, N = 105) were associated with changes in modal controllability of the multiple demand system and weakly in the control network over the same time period. These findings suggest that changes in the ability of structural brain networks in facilitating effortful brain state transitions may be a key neural mechanism underlying aging-related executive function declines and cognitive aging.
geriatrics & gerontology,gerontology
-
A developmental arc of white matter supporting a growing diversity of brain dynamics
Evelyn Tang,Chad Giusti,Graham L. Baum,Shi Gu,Eli Pollock,Ari E. Kahn,David R. Roalf,Tyler M. Moore,Kosha Ruparel,Ruben C. Gur,Raquel E. Gur,Theodore D. Satterthwaite,Danielle S. Bassett
2016-01-01
Abstract:As the human brain develops, it increasingly supports the coordinated synchronization and control of neural activity. The mechanism by which white matter evolves to support this coordination is not well understood. We use a network representation of diffusion imaging data to show that white matter connectivity becomes increasingly optimized for a diverse range of predicted dynamics in development. Such optimized topologies emerge across 882 youth from ages 8 to 22 evidencing increasing local specialization. Notably, stable controllers in subcortical areas are negatively related to cognitive performance. Seeking to investigate structural mechanisms that support these changes, we simulate network evolution with a set of growth rules, to find that all brain networks -- from child to adult -- are structured in a manner highly optimized for network control. We further observe differences in the predicted control mechanisms of the child and adult brains, suggesting that the white matter architecture in children has a greater potential to increasingly support brain state transitions, potentially underlying cognitive switching. This work suggests mechanisms for the propagation and stabilization of brain activity at various spatial scales, revealing a possible mechanism of human brain development that preferentially optimizes dynamic network control over static features of network architecture.
-
Mapping Functional Connectome Changes of the Human Brain across the Life Span
M. Cao,Zhengjia Dai,Fengmei Fan,Lili Jiang,X. Cao,Mingrui Xia,N. Shu,XiNian Zuo,Yong He
2011-01-01
Abstract:Introduction: Uncovering the lifespan changes of the human brain is definitely thrilling and a fundamental goal in discovery neuroscience. The lifespan trajectory coding both normal developing and aging stages of the brain has reflected dramatic changes both its structure [1-3] and function [4-6]. It has been commonly accepted that human brain is structurally and functionally organized into a complex network allowing the segregation and integration of information processing [7,8]. In particular, the brain network, describing the interaction between different brain regions, has demonstrated consistent non-trivial properties and reliable changes throughout normal development, aging and in various pathological conditions. Beyond these advances, how the brain network is reorganized through the whole lifespan or its lifespan trajectory has been rarely studied. Here, armed with the graph theory, we aim to chart the lifespan trajectory of human whole-brain functional networks based on resting-state functional MRI (R-fMRI) datasets from 150 subjects collected from the same scanner. Materials and Methods: Participants and Data acquisition: A public R-fMRI dataset including total 150 right-handed healthy people (males, 87; females, 63; age range, 7-85 years) from the NKI/Rockland sample (http://fcon_1000.projects.nitrc.org/indi/pro/nki.html) was employed. All subjects have no history of neurological and psychiatric disorders. The resting state fMRI scans were performed on the Siemens Trio 3.0 Tesla MRI scanner using an echo-planar imaging (EPI) sequence (TR/TE=2500/30 ms, FA=80°, FOV=216 mm, matrix=256×256, slices=38, thickness=3.0 mm, 260 volumes). High-resolutionT1-weighted images were also collected by magnetization-prepared rapid gradient echo (MPRAGE) sequence (TR/TE=2500/3.5 ms, FA=8°, thickness=1.0 mm, slices=192, matrix=256×256, FOV=256mm). Functional data preprocessing: Data preprocessing was similar to as implemented in [6], producing individual residual timeseries in the MNI152 standard space. Network Construction: A group mask in standard space was made which includes all voxels with non-zeros standard deviation of bold time series and gray matter tissue probability greater than 20%. A high-resolution parcellation template was generated by randomly partitioning the group mask into 1024 contiguous and uniform regions using an algorithm described in [9]. Resting state functional connectivity (RSFC) for each pair of 1024 regions of interest was obtained by computing Pearson correlation coefficients of their representative (i.e., mean across all voxels) time series. Each subject’s weighted functional connectivity network was then constructed based on a Bonforroni correction procedure. Network properties analysis: We studied the age-related variation trends of the following regional characteristic and connection property: 1) the regional correlation strength which measures the average correlation extent by which a given region, i, is connected to the rest of the network. Regions with correlation strength greater than the mean and two standard deviations of the global network correlation strength were defined as hubs in every person. 2) The anatomical distance of the connection between region i and region j is defined as the Euclidean distance between centroids of the two regions. The percentages of long-distance (>75mm) and short-distance (≤75mm) connection of the functional connectome were computed for each subject. Results: The probability map of hubs in population was gotten and several specific regions including default-mode network regions, attention network regions, motor-related regions and visual cortex were detected to be functional hubs consistently (Figure 1.A). Besides, we observed significantly linear decreases of RSFC strength with age primarily located in several default-mode (e.g., medial frontal and parietal cortex, lateral temporal and parietal cortex) and attention network regions (e.g., insula, dorsal anterior cingulate cortex, lateral frontal cortex and temporal-parietal conjunction) while few regions including SMA and temporal pole showed significantly linear increases (p<0.05, FDR corrected) (Figure 1.B). Meanwhile, significant quadratic trajectories of RSFC strength on age were also detected within the left hippocampus and bilateral superior temporal gyrus (p<0.01, uncorrected) (Figure 1.C). The network sparsity (i.e., number of graph edges or network connections showing significant RSFC) between brain regions demonstrated a linear trend of decrease with age (not significant) through the lifespan (p=0.10). The percentage of long-distance connections was found increase up to age 42 and then decrease while the short-distance connections showed an inverse trajectory (p=0.01) (Figure 2).