Abstract: We establish a new bridge between propositional logic and elementary number theory. The main objects are "minimally unsatisfiable clause-sets", short "MUs", unsatisfiable conjunctive normal forms rendered satisfiable by elimination of any clause. In other words, irredundant coverings of the boolean hypercube by subcubes. The main parameter for MUs is the "deficiency" k, the difference between the number of clauses and the number of variables (the difference between the number of elements in the covering and the dimension of the hypercube), and the fundamental fact is that k >= 1 holds. A "full clause" in an MU contains all variables (corresponding to a singleton in the covering). We show the lower bound S_2(k) <= FCM(k), where FCM(k) is the maximal number of full clauses in MUs of deficiency k, while S_2(k) is the smallest n such that 2^k divides n!. The proof rests on two methods: On the logic-combinatorial side, applying subsumption resolution and its inverse, a fundamental method since Boole in 1854 introduced the "expansion method". On the arithmetical side, analysing certain recursions, combining an application-specific recursion with a recursion from the field of meta-Fibonacci sequences (indeed S_2 equals twice the Conolly sequence). A further tool is the consideration of unsatisfiable "hitting clause-sets" (UHITs), special cases of MUs, which correspond to the partitions of the boolean hypercube by subcubes; they are also known as orthogonal or disjoint DNF tautologies. We actually show the sharper lower bound S_2(k) <= FCH(k), where FCH(k) is the maximal number of full clauses in UHITs of deficiency k. We conjecture that for all k holds S_2(k) = FCH(k), which would establish a surprising connection between the extremal combinatorics of (un)satisfiability and elementary number theory. We apply the lower bound to analyse the structure of MUs and UHITs.

Computing Minimal Unsatisfiable Core for LTL over Finite Traces

Enumerating Minimal Unsatisfiable Cores of LTLf formulas

Satisfiability Of Linear Time Mu-Calculus On Finite Traces

Extracting Minimal Unsatisfiable Subformulas in Satisfiability Modulo Theories.

LTLf satisfiability checking

Finding First-Order Minimal Unsatisfiable Cores with a Heuristic Depth-First-Search Algorithm.

SAT-Based Explicit LTLf Satisfiability Checking

Computing Small Unsatisfiable Cores in Satisfiability Modulo Theories

Parameters for Minimal Unsatisfiability: Smarandache Primitive Numbers and Full Clauses

Fmus2: An Efficient Algorithm To Compute Minimal Unsatisfiable Subsets

Applying Variable Minimal Unsatisfiability in Model Checking

Classes of propositional UMU formulas and their extensions to minimal unsatisfiable formulas

LTL Satisfiability Checking Revisited

Model-Guided Synthesis for LTL over Finite Traces.

Tackling Universal Properties of Minimal Trap Spaces of Boolean Networks

A Graph-Based Approach for Calculating Minimal Unsatisfiability-Preserving Subsets of Ontology in D L-Lite

An Explicit Transition System Construction Approach to LTL Satisfiability Checking

An Algorithm for Calculating Minimal Unsatisfiability-Preserving Subsets of Ontology in DL-Lite

Application and Analysis of Unsatisfiable Cores on Circuits Synthesis

COMPLEXITY RESULTS ON MINIMAL UNSATISFIABLE FORMULAS

Computing Minimal Sets on Propositional Formulae I: Problems & Reductions