Two Biomarker-Directed Randomized Trials in European and Chinese Patients with Nonsmall-Cell Lung Cancer: the BRCA1-RAP80 Expression Customization (BREC) Studies

Teresa Morán,Wei Jia,Manuel Cobo,Xiaoping Qian,Manuel Dómine,Zhengyun Zou,Isabel Bover,Lei Wang,Mariano Provencio,Lan Yu,Imane Chaib,Chaoqun You,Bartomeu Massutí,Yue Song,A. Vergnenègre,Huan Lu,G. López-Vivanco,Weixin Hu,G. Robinet,Jun Yan,Amelia Insa,Xiaoyue Xu,Margarita Majem,X. Chen,R. de las Peñas,Niki Karachaliou,María Sala,Qingpo Wu,Dolores Isla,Yanping Zhou,Nathalie Baize,F. Zhang,J. Garde,Paul Germonpré,Stefan Rauh,Hamed Alhusaini,Maria Sánchez-Ronco,Ana Drozdowskyj,José Javier Sánchez,Carlos Camps,B. Liu,Rafael Rosell,Benoît Colinet,J. De Grève,Huijun Chen,Juan Du,Yanan Gao,Jing Hu,Wencui Kong,L. Li,R. Li,X. Li,Jingyu Liu,Weihong Ren,Wen Li,Xianmin Xiao,Jason Yang,Mu‐Zi Yang,Yingjie Yang,Jian Yin,Xiu hui Yue,Jiliang Zhang,Liang Zhu,P. Bombaron,Christos Chouaïd,Éric Dansin,P. Fournel,G. Fraboulet,Radj Gervais,S. Hominal,S. Kahlout,H. Lecaer,H. Léna,J. Letreut,C. Locher,O. Molinier,Isabelle Monnet,G. Oliviéro,Reineke A. Schoot,Pascal Thomas,Guy Berchem,Hamed Al Husaini,Francisco Aparisi,E. Arriola,Iván Ballesteros,I. Barneto,R. Bernabé,Ana Blasco,Joaquim Bosch‐Barrera,V. Calvo de Juan,Enric Carcereny,Sílvia Catot,Eudald Felip,M.R. García-Campelo,Carlos García‐Girón,Ramón García-Gómez,Raquel García‐Sevila,Amaya Gascó,Jerzy Gil,J.L. González-Larriba,Susana Hernando-Polo,E. Jantús,Begoña Jiménez,P. Lianes,Rafael López‐López,Ana López Martín,José A. Macías,Juan Luis Martí-Ciriquián,R. Montoyo,Daniela Morales‐Espinosa,María Moreno,Cinta Pallarés,Marta Parera,R. Pérez-Carrión,Rut Porta,N. Reguart,Francisco Molina Rosillo,J. M. Sanchez,Ivana Sullivan,J. Terrasa,J.M. Trigo,Javier Valdivia,N. Viñolas,Santiago Viteri,M. Botia-Castillo,José-Luís Mate,M. Perez-Cano,José Luis Ramirez,B. Sanchez-Rodriguez,Miquel Tarón,M. Tierno-Garcia,Erika Mijangos,Juan Ocaña,Eva Pereira,Jingjing Shao,Xiaoting Sun,R. O'Brate
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/annonc/mdu389
IF: 51.769
2014-01-01
Annals of Oncology
Abstract:BackgroundIn a Spanish Lung Cancer Group (SLCG) phase II trial, the combination of BRCA1 and receptor-associated protein 80 (RAP80) expression was significantly associated with outcome in Caucasian patients with nonsmall-cell lung cancer (NSCLC). The SLCG therefore undertook an industry-independent collaborative randomized phase III trial comparing nonselected cisplatin-based chemotherapy with therapy customized according to BRCA1/RAP80 expression. An analogous randomized phase II trial was carried out in China under the auspices of the SLCG to evaluate the effect of BRCA1/RAP80 expression in Asian patients.Patients and methodsEligibility criteria included stage IIIB–IV NSCLC and sufficient tumor specimen for molecular analysis. Randomization to the control or experimental arm was 1 : 1 in the SLCG trial and 1 : 3 in the Chinese trial. In both trials, patients in the control arm received docetaxel/cisplatin; in the experimental arm, patients with low RAP80 expression received gemcitabine/cisplatin, those with intermediate/high RAP80 expression and low/intermediate BRCA1 expression received docetaxel/cisplatin, and those with intermediate/high RAP80 expression and high BRCA1 expression received docetaxel alone. The primary end point was progression-free survival (PFS).ResultsTwo hundred and seventy-nine patients in the SLCG trial and 124 in the Chinese trial were assessable for PFS. PFS in the control and experimental arms in the SLCG trial was 5.49 and 4.38 months, respectively [log rank P = 0.07; hazard ratio (HR) 1.28; P = 0.03]. In the Chinese trial, PFS was 4.74 and 3.78 months, respectively (log rank P = 0.82; HR 0.95; P = 0.82).ConclusionAccrual was prematurely closed on the SLCG trial due to the absence of clinical benefit in the experimental over the control arm. However, the BREC studies provide proof of concept that an international, nonindustry, biomarker-directed trial is feasible. Thanks to the groundwork laid by these studies, we expect that ongoing further research on alternative biomarkers to elucidate DNA repair mechanisms will help define novel therapeutic approaches.Trial registrationNCT00617656/GECP-BREC and ChiCTR-TRC-12001860/BREC-CHINA
What problem does this paper attempt to address?