The Pricing of European Heat Rate-Linked Derivatives

Shuguang Zhang

2008-01-01

Abstract:In this paper,we treat the market including electricity as an incomplete market,in which electricity can't be traded.Then we get the price of European heat rate-linked derivatives using the pricing theory of Davis. And the analytic solution for the derivative pricing is obtained,under a particular electricity model.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Pricing electricity derivatives within a Markov regime-switching model

Joanna Janczura

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1203.5442

2012-03-25

Abstract:In this paper analytic formulas for electricity derivatives are calculated. To this end, we assume that electricity spot prices follow a 3-regime Markov regime-switching model with independent spikes and drops and periodic transition matrix. Since the classical derivatives pricing methodology cannot be used in case of non-storable commodities, we employ the concept of the risk premium. The obtained theoretical results are then used for the European Energy Exchange (EEX) market data. The 3-regime model is calibrated to the spot electricity prices. Next, the risk premium is derived and used to calculate prices of European options written on spot, as well as, forward prices.

Pricing of Securities
An Electricity Price Model with Consideration to Load and Gas Price Effects.

Huang Min-xiang,Tao Xiao-hu,Han Zhen-xiang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/bf02851607

2003-01-01

Journal of Zhejiang University SCIENCE A

Abstract:Some characteristics of the electricity load and prices are studied, and the relationship between electricity prices and gas (fuel) prices is analyzed in this paper. Because electricity prices are strongly dependent on load and gas prices, the authors constructed a model for electricity prices based on the effects of these two factors; and used the Geometric Mean Reversion Brownian Motion (GMRBM) model to describe the electricity load process, and a Geometric Brownian Motion(GBM) model to describe the gas prices; deduced the price stochastic process model based on the above load model and gas price model. This paper also presents methods for parameters estimation, and proposes some methods to solve the model.
Energy-Grade Double Pricing Rule in the Heating Market

Xinyi Yi,Ye Guo,Hongbin Sun

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/cdc51059.2022.9993047

2022-01-01

Abstract:The problem of heat system pricing is considered. A direct extension of locational marginal prices (LMP) in electricity markets to heat systems may lead to revenue inadequate issues. The underlying reason for such a problem is that, unlike electric power, heat has different grades and cannot be considered as homogenized commodity. Accordingly, an energy-grade double pricing rule is proposed in this paper. Heat energy and grade prices are explained as the shadow prices related to the nodal heat balance constraints and temperature requirements constraints at the optimal solution. The resulting merchandise surplus at each dispatch interval can be decomposed into several explainable parts, namely, congestion rent, impact from the last period, and impact from the upcoming period. And the total merchandise surplus over all dispatch intervals can be decomposed into several non-negative interpretable parts, including congestion rent and impact from the initial state, thus guaranteeing the revenue adequacy for the heat system operator. Simulations verify the effectiveness of the proposed mechanism.
Research on economic withholding in wholesale markets based on incremental heat rate

Fuqiang Zhang,Hao Zhou

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/TDC.2005.1546928

2005-01-01

Abstract:Experience with deregulated electricity markets has shown that the exercise of market power is the significant reason that results in market failure. More attention should be paid on economic withholding since it is the main expressive form of exercise of market power. Economic withholding is bidding a relatively high price above marginal cost of their generation units with the expectation of receiving higher revenue. Heat Rate is introduced to establish the linkage between individual suppliers' bid curves and their own heat rates because heat rate times the fuel price equals the fuel costs. In this paper we assume fuel costs are equal to variable costs since fuel costs occupy the most shares of variable costs. We originally propose that economic withholding is quantified as the area between the bid curve and corresponding fuel costs curve take accounting of its fixed costs. Numerical examples are presented to verify the effectiveness of the proposed method. The approach developed in this paper provides a clearly defined and measurable standard for quantifying the existence and severity of economic withholding in electricity markets. © 2005 IEEE.
Risk valuation of quanto derivatives on temperature and electricity

Aurélien Alfonsi,Nerea Vadillo

2024-04-19

Abstract:This paper develops a coupled model for day-ahead electricity prices and average daily temperature which allows to model quanto weather and energy derivatives. These products have gained on popularity as they enable to hedge against both volumetric and price risks. Electricity day-ahead prices and average daily temperatures are modelled through non homogeneous Ornstein-Uhlenbeck processes driven by a Brownian motion and a Normal Inverse Gaussian Lévy process, which allows to include dependence between them. A Conditional Least Square method is developed to estimate the different parameters of the model and used on real data. Then, explicit and semi-explicit formulas are obtained for derivatives including quanto options and compared with Monte Carlo simulations. Last, we develop explicit formulas to hedge statically single and double sided quanto options by a portfolio of electricity options and temperature options (CDD or HDD).

Pricing of Securities,Portfolio Management,Risk Management
Generalized Locational Marginal Pricing in a Heat-and-Electricity-Integrated Market

Lirong Deng,Zhengshuo Li,Hongbin Sun,Qinglai Guo,Yinliang Xu,Runze Chen,Jianhui Wang,Ye Guo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/tsg.2019.2904522

IF: 10.275

2019-01-01

IEEE Transactions on Smart Grid

Abstract:In this paper, a new pricing method derived from the heat-and-electricity-integrated market clearing problem, referred to as generalized locational marginal pricing (GLMP), is presented. The market clearing problem is formulated by the independent system operator (ISO) to coordinate the electric power system with the district heating system by considering time-delay effects in the heating transfer process. GLMP is explained as the shadow price related to the nodal electricity balance and nodal heat balance at the optimal solution. Without considering network constraints, a simplified market clearing problem is proposed to illustrate the price linkage between heating and electricity markets through combined heat and power joint costs and feasible regions. Rational generation units will behave exactly as the ISO predicts by maximizing their individual producer surplus. Then, a compact form of the complete market clearing problem is employed to derive the detailed components of GLMP, namely, the extended marginal generation component, marginal loss component, and marginal congestion component. Furthermore, time-delay effects are reflected in the pricing. Numerical results verify the validity of component classification in GLMP and demonstrate that the proposed method can promote efficiency improvements and reduce cross-subsidies.
Application of VAR in Financial Risk Analysis of Electricity Markets

Zhou Hao,Zhang Fuqiang,Wu Hao,Ho, S.L.

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1049/cp:20030612

2003-01-01

Abstract:In this paper, the necessity to study financial risks in electricity markets, the application of the value at risk (VaR) method and the feasibility of historical simulations are firstly introduced and discussed. Then the gross profit, daily VaR and weekly VaR models of an electricity company (the unique buyer) based on practical conditions of the Zhejiang electricity markets are presented, and the corresponding computational results are reported. Furthermore, the application of historical simulations in financial risk investigations of electricity markets is analyzed, and the influence of the two factors (contracted price Pc and contract rate k) of CFD (contract for difference) on the company's gross profit and daily VaR are discussed. The numerical results revealed that the historical simulation is suitable to analyze and to predict the short-term financial risk (next day or next week) of electricity market. It is intuitive, simple and easy to implement.
Analysis of price spiking in electricity markets

Hao Zhou,Quan Zhang,Fuqiang Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/TDC.2005.1546930

2005-01-01

Abstract:With the developing of the worldwide reform of electricity market, the participants of the market have been encountering unprecedented market risk, especially huge financial risk evoked by the price fluctuations. Although nearly everybody pays attention to the phenomenon of price spiking in electricity markets, there is little clear analysis. Based on the actual historical bid data of Zhejiang Electricity Market, this paper defined SPCP (System Price Capacity Percent) and analyzed the relation of system price capacity percent and electricity price. The results indicate the mechanism of price spiking in electricity markets, which will be good for participants and administrators to understand the origin and mechanism of the price spiking in electricity markets, and also will make for the development of electricity markets. © 2005 IEEE.
Hedging Expected Losses on Derivatives in Electricity Futures Markets

Adrien Nguyen Huu,Nadia Oudjane

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1401.8271

2014-02-01

Abstract:We investigate the problem of pricing and hedging derivatives of Electricity Futures contract when the underlying asset is not available. We propose to use a cross hedging strategy based on the Futures contract covering the larger delivery period. A quick overview of market data shows a basis risk for this market incompleteness. For that purpose we formulate the pricing problem in a stochastic target form along the lines of Bouchard and al. (2008), with a moment loss function. Following the same techniques as in the latter, we avoid to demonstrate the uniqueness of the value function by comparison arguments and explore convex duality methods to provide a semi-explicit solution to the problem. We then propose numerical results to support the new hedging strategy and compare our method to the Black-Scholes naive approach.

Pricing of Securities,Optimization and Control
A Game Theoretic Model for Equilibrium Pricing of Futures Electricity Contracts

Jiang Wu,Xiaohong Guan,Feng Gao,Guoji Sun

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/pes.2008.4596634

2008-01-01

Abstract:Due to the unique characteristics of electricity markets, the traditional methods to futures contracts pricing, which have been widely used to common commodity, can not be applied directly. This paper presents a Cournot game model for equilibrium pricing of futures electricity contracts. In the game, each Genco optimizes a generation asset allocation problem between monthly futures contracts and the daily spot market, with consideration of market power in futures market, price risk in spot market and operating costs and constraints of generating units. An iterative method is applied to obtain the Cournot-Nash equilibrium of the futures contract prices. Finally, the possible factors influencing the futures price equilibriums are discussed with case studies.
Electricity Market Theory Based on Continuous Time Commodity Model

Haoyong Chen,Lijia Han

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1710.07918

2017-10-22

Econometrics

Abstract:The recent research report of U.S. Department of Energy prompts us to re-examine the pricing theories applied in electricity market design. The theory of spot pricing is the basis of electricity market design in many countries, but it has two major drawbacks: one is that it is still based on the traditional hourly scheduling/dispatch model, ignores the crucial time continuity in electric power production and consumption and does not treat the inter-temporal constraints seriously; the second is that it assumes that the electricity products are homogeneous in the same dispatch period and cannot distinguish the base, intermediate and peak power with obviously different technical and economic characteristics. To overcome the shortcomings, this paper presents a continuous time commodity model of electricity, including spot pricing model and load duration model. The market optimization models under the two pricing mechanisms are established with the Riemann and Lebesgue integrals respectively and the functional optimization problem are solved by the Euler-Lagrange equation to obtain the market equilibria. The feasibility of pricing according to load duration is proved by strict mathematical derivation. Simulation results show that load duration pricing can correctly identify and value different attributes of generators, reduce the total electricity purchasing cost, and distribute profits among the power plants more equitably. The theory and methods proposed in this paper will provide new ideas and theoretical foundation for the development of electric power markets.
A fundamental Game Theoretic model and approximate global Nash Equilibria computation for European Spot Power Markets

Ioan Alexandru Puiu,Raphael Andreas Hauser

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2208.14164

2022-08-30

Abstract:Spot electricity markets are considered under a Game-Theoretic framework, where risk averse players submit orders to the market clearing mechanism to maximise their own utility. Consistent with the current practice in Europe, the market clearing mechanism is modelled as a Social Welfare Maximisation problem, with zonal pricing, and we consider inflexible demand, physical constraints of the electricity grid, and capacity-constrained producers. A novel type of non-parametric risk aversion based on a defined worst case scenario is introduced, and this reduces the dimensionality of the strategy variables and ensures boundedness of prices. By leveraging these properties we devise Jacobi and Gauss-Seidel iterative schemes for computation of approximate global Nash Equilibria, which are in contrast to derivative based local equilibria. Our methodology is applied to the real world data of Central Western European (CWE) Spot Market during the 2019-2020 period, and offers a good representation of the historical time series of prices. By also solving for the assumption of truthful bidding, we devise a simple method based on hypothesis testing to infer if and when producers are bidding strategically (instead of truthfully), and we find evidence suggesting that strategic bidding may be fairly pronounced in the CWE region.

Computer Science and Game Theory,Theoretical Economics,Mathematical Finance
CES Utility Function Based Consumer Optimal Decision Making in Heat-Power Market

CHEN Yue,WEI Wei,LIU Feng,MEI Shengwei,YUAN Tiejiang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.7500/AEPS20171225004

2018-01-01

Abstract:With the wide deployment of electrical heating devices,such as electric boilers and heat pumps,the coupling between electric power and heating system is increasingly prominent.Under the circumstance that multiple energies taking part in the trading market,sophisticated games exist between various market participants.Analyzing consumers" behaviors and their impacts on the energy prices becomes an important issue.A heat-power trading scheme is proposed and the optimal decision making problem of consumer with constant elasticity of substitution (CES) utility function is formulated.The proposed method also provides important reference for the research on other energy market problems.The market clearing condition is transformed into mixed integer linear constraints by jointly using the Karush-Kuhn-Tucker(KKT)optimality condition as well as the duality theorem of linear programming.Embedded with the market clearing condition,the consumer decision making problem is solved by the pattern search algorithm.Numeric studies on a testing system consisting of an IEEE 33 bus distribution system and a 32 node heating system show the effectiveness of the proposed method.The influences of several factors on the market equilibrium are also analyzed.
Transaction Path-based Market Clearing and Pricing Mechanism Design in Interregional Power Markets

Zhihuan Zhuo,Mingkai Yu,Jianxiao Wang,Gengyin Li,Chenxing Yang,Haihua Cheng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/icpsasia55496.2022.9949713

2022-01-01

Abstract:Interregional transactions have effectively promoted the consumption of renewable energy and optimized the allocation of resources. The transaction path-based model is proposed, used for interregional transaction market clearing. Although this model can figure out the occupation of transmission line capacity corresponding to the transaction between nodes, it cannot address the pricing problem effectively. This paper improves the transaction path-based model and proposes a pricing method for interregional transaction, considering the principle of locational marginal price adopted in the European market and PJM market. The physical meaning of locational marginal price is analyzed, and the transaction path-based model is adjusted, figuring out the corresponding constraints to solve the Lagrange multipliers, which can be used for market pricing. Case studies based on an IEEE 9-node system prove the effectiveness of the proposed improved transaction path-based model. This model can create incentive compatible pricing scheme.
Pricing in non-convex markets with quadratic deliverability costs

Xiaolong Kuang,Alberto J. Lamadrid,Luis F. Zuluaga

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eneco.2018.12.022

IF: 12.8

2019-05-01

Energy Economics

Abstract:This article studies the problem of obtaining equilibrium clearing prices for markets with non-convexities when it is relevant to account for convex quadratic deliverability costs and constraints. In a general market, such a situation arises when quadratic commodity or transactions costs are relevant. In the particular case of electricity markets, there is a mix of resources including dispatchable and renewable energy sources, leading to the presence of integer variables and quadratic costs reflecting ramping needs. To illustrate our results, we compute and analyze the equilibrium clearing prices of the Scarf's classical market problem with the addition of ramping costs.

economics
Electricity Tariff Insurance Design under Real-Time Pricing

Siyuan Li,Nan Gu,Chenye Wu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/ei259745.2023.10512364

2023-01-01

Abstract:In electricity markets, real-time pricing introduces financial uncertainties to users, particularly in the presence of price spikes. Risk hedging mechanisms contain end-customers' financial uncertainties by sharing the risks with contractual counterparts and paying a fee as the risk premium. This paper introduces a pricing model for insurance primarily designed for residential electricity bills. This model employs heavy-tailed distributions and stochastic differential equations to forecast electricity prices, accounting for price spikes, and then uses a clustering-based probability distribution model to classify and predict customers' consumption patterns. The integration of predictive data and insurance principles enables the calculation of net premium rates. The change in the coefficient of variation, employed as a measure, assesses the effectiveness of risk reduction through insurance. The proposed methodology provides guidance for both insurance companies and customers.
Energy Trading and Market Equilibrium in Integrated Heat-Power Distribution Systems

Yue Chen,Wei,Feng Liu,Enzo E. Sauma,Shengwei Mei

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/tsg.2018.2849227

IF: 10.275

2018-01-01

IEEE Transactions on Smart Grid

Abstract:The increasing utilization of cogeneration plants and energy conversion facilities accelerates the integration of energy systems, which introduces both opportunities and challenges into system operation and management. Thorough mathematical model and analytical method which take into account the energy flow interdependence and strategic behaviors in multi-carrier energy systems are highly desired. This paper studies an integrated heat- power distribution system from the market perspective. The nonlinear AC optimal power flow (OPF) model is used to clear the distribution power market, which exactly accounts for network losses. To facilitate computation, convex relaxation is applied and polyhedral outer approximation of second-order cone is performed, leading to a linear market clearing model. An optimal thermal flow (OTF) model is employed to clear the heat market. Energy consumptions of heating devices are charged according to locational marginal prices. The market equilibrium is interpreted by a fixed point between OPF and OTF and reformulated as a mixed-integer linear program. Dedicated optimization models are set forth to investigate the market impact of strategic providers and elastic demands, in which the market equilibrium condition serves as constraint. Case studies validate the effectiveness of the proposed model and method.
Valuation and pricing of electricity delivery contracts: the producer’s view

Raimund M. Kovacevic

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10479-018-3010-0

IF: 4.82

2018-08-24

Annals of Operations Research

Abstract:This paper analyzes the valuation and pricing of physical electricity delivery contracts from the viewpoint of a producer with given capacities for production and fuel-storage. Using stochastic optimization problems in discrete time with general state space, the dual problems of production problems are used to derive no-arbitrage conditions for fuel and electricity prices as well as superhedging values and prices of bilaterally traded electricity delivery contracts. In particular we take the perspective of an electricity producer, who serves contractual deliveries but avoids unacceptable losses. The resulting no-arbitrage conditions, stochastic discount factors and superhedging prices account for typical frictions like limitation of storage and production capacity and for the fact that it is possible to produce electricity from fuel, but not to produce fuel from electricity. Similarities, but also substantial differences to purely financial results can be demonstrated in this way. Furthermore, using acceptability measures, we analyze capital requirements and acceptability prices for delivery contracts, when the producer accepts some risk.

operations research & management science
The Valuation of Clean Spread Options: Linking Electricity, Emissions and Fuels

Rene Carmona,Michael Coulon,Daniel Schwarz

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/14697688.2012.750733

2012-05-11

Abstract:The purpose of the paper is to present a new pricing method for clean spread options, and to illustrate its main features on a set of numerical examples produced by a dedicated computer code. The novelty of the approach is embedded in the use of structural models as opposed to reduced-form models which fail to capture properly the fundamental dependencies between the economic factors entering the production process.

Pricing of Securities
Weather derivatives pricing using regime switching model

Emmanuel Evarest,Fredrik Berntsson,Martin Singull,Xiangfeng Yang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/mcma-2018-0002

2018-01-26

Monte Carlo Methods and Applications

Abstract:Abstract In this study we discuss the pricing of weather derivatives whose underlying weather variable is temperature. The dynamics of temperature in this study follows a two state regime switching model with a heteroskedastic mean reverting process as the base regime and a shifted regime defined by Brownian motion with nonzero drift. We develop mathematical formulas for pricing futures and option contracts on heating degree days (HDDs), cooling degree days (CDDs) and cumulative average temperature (CAT) indices. The local volatility nature of the model in the base regime captures very well the dynamics of the underlying process, thus leading to a better pricing processes for temperature derivatives contracts written on various index variables. We use the Monte Carlo simulation method for pricing weather derivatives call option contracts.

The Pricing of European Heat Rate-Linked Derivatives

Pricing electricity derivatives within a Markov regime-switching model

An Electricity Price Model with Consideration to Load and Gas Price Effects.

Energy-Grade Double Pricing Rule in the Heating Market

Research on economic withholding in wholesale markets based on incremental heat rate

Risk valuation of quanto derivatives on temperature and electricity

Generalized Locational Marginal Pricing in a Heat-and-Electricity-Integrated Market

Application of VAR in Financial Risk Analysis of Electricity Markets

Analysis of price spiking in electricity markets

Hedging Expected Losses on Derivatives in Electricity Futures Markets

A Game Theoretic Model for Equilibrium Pricing of Futures Electricity Contracts

Electricity Market Theory Based on Continuous Time Commodity Model

A fundamental Game Theoretic model and approximate global Nash Equilibria computation for European Spot Power Markets

CES Utility Function Based Consumer Optimal Decision Making in Heat-Power Market

Transaction Path-based Market Clearing and Pricing Mechanism Design in Interregional Power Markets

Pricing in non-convex markets with quadratic deliverability costs

Electricity Tariff Insurance Design under Real-Time Pricing

Energy Trading and Market Equilibrium in Integrated Heat-Power Distribution Systems

Valuation and pricing of electricity delivery contracts: the producer’s view

The Valuation of Clean Spread Options: Linking Electricity, Emissions and Fuels

Weather derivatives pricing using regime switching model