The Politics of the Concept of Totality
K. Goonewardena
2017-10-25
Abstract:Although Georg Lukacs famously wrote that the ‘standpoint of totality’ is the essence of Marxism as a revolutionary method, no concept of Marxism has been more virulently discredited by poststructuralist as much as Cold War liberal perspectives than totality. As Fredric Jameson has often noted, moreover, totality has been effectively equated with totalitarianism in popular political discourse, presenting Marxist theory with considerable challenges in the battleground of ideology. Against this backdrop, I first explore some of the most influential concepts of totality within the Western Marxist tradition, noting the salient differences and possible rapprochements between the approaches of such philosophers as Lukacs, Sartre, Lefebvre, Adorno and Althusser. Next, I examine some radical critiques of the concept of totality directed against Marxism especially by feminism and postcolonialism, while also noting how some strands of socialist-feminism and anti-colonial traditions have productively and even collaboratively appropriated the concept of totality in emancipatory fashion. Finally, I turn to the relevance of the concept of totality to make sense of some contemporary political challenges of planetary scope, notably the problems posed by global urbanization and climate change. In sum, the paper shows how old objections concerning totality persist into current political debates, while arguing for a radical re-engagement with the problem of totality with old and new methods.
Sociology,Political Science