Reversible 1,2-Methyl Migration to an N-Heterocyclic Carbene in a PCNHCP Cobalt(I) Complex Enables Stereoselective (E and Z) Allyl Ether Isomerization

Graham de Ruiter,Subhash Garhwal,Sakthi Raje,Katarzyna Młodzikowska-Pieńko,Tofayel Sheikh Mohammed,Ron Raphaeli,Natalia Fridman,Linda Shimon,Renana Poranne
DOI: https://doi.org/10.26434/chemrxiv-2023-ltgjf
2023-11-16
Abstract:With growing efforts pushing towards sustainable catalysis, using earth-abundant metals has become increasingly important. Here we present the first examples of cobalt PCNHCP pincer complexes that demonstrate dual stereoselectivity for allyl ether isomerization. While the cationic cobalt complex [((PCNHCP)Co)2-μ-N2][BAr4F]2 (3) affords the Z-isomer of the enol ether predominantly, the corresponding methyl complex [(PCNHCP)CoMe)] (4) mostly gives the E-isomer. The dichotomy in selectivity is investigated computationally, revealing important contributions from the steric profile of the substituents on the metal (Me or N2), including an unprecedented migration of the methyl substituent from cobalt to the N-heterocyclic carbene carbon, which is further explored in this report.
Chemistry
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to achieve stereoselective control of allyl ether isomerization when using the earth - abundant metal cobalt as a catalyst. Specifically, the researchers developed two cobalt(I) PCNHCP sandwich complexes with almost identical structures, which can efficiently catalyze the formation of E - and Z - allyl ether isomers respectively. These two complexes exhibit different stereoselectivities during the catalysis process. One mainly produces the Z - isomer, while the other mainly produces the E - isomer. The study explored the origin of this selectivity through experimental and computational methods, especially how the dissociation of the N2 ligand and the migration of the methyl group from cobalt to the N - heterocyclic carbene carbon affect the reaction pathway and stereoselectivity. ### Main problems 1. **Achieving high stereoselectivity in allyl ether isomerization**: - By designing specific cobalt(I) PCNHCP sandwich complexes, the researchers aim to develop a method that can efficiently and selectively catalyze allyl ether isomerization, especially a method that can generate Z - and E - isomers. 2. **Understanding the mechanism of stereoselectivity**: - The researchers hope to reveal the mechanism by which different catalysts selectively generate different isomers through experimental and computational methods, especially to explore the influence of N2 ligand dissociation and methyl group migration on the reaction pathway. ### Specific objectives - **Synthesizing cobalt(I) PCNHCP sandwich complexes**: - Two cobalt(I) PCNHCP sandwich complexes with similar structures but different substituents were synthesized and characterized, namely complex 3 containing a nitrogen gas ligand and complex 4 containing a methyl ligand. - **Evaluating the activity and selectivity of catalysts**: - The activity and stereoselectivity of these two complexes in the allyl ether isomerization reaction were evaluated experimentally. It was found that complex 3 mainly generates the Z - isomer, while complex 4 mainly generates the E - isomer. - **Exploring the mechanism of stereoselectivity**: - Through density functional theory (DFT) calculations, the researchers analyzed the reaction pathway and transition - state structures in detail, revealing the influence of N2 ligand dissociation and methyl group migration on stereoselectivity. ### Conclusions - **Dissociation of the N2 ligand**: - For complex 3, the dissociation of the N2 ligand is a crucial step. It enables the cobalt center to form an η3 - allyl intermediate, which is favorable for the generation of the Z - isomer. - **Methyl group migration**: - For complex 4, the methyl group migrates from the cobalt center to the N - heterocyclic carbene carbon, also forming an empty coordination site, enabling the cobalt center to form an η3 - allyl intermediate, which is favorable for the generation of the E - isomer. Through these studies, the paper not only shows how to achieve high stereoselectivity in allyl ether isomerization by designing specific catalysts, but also deeply explores the reaction mechanism, providing a theoretical basis for the development of more efficient catalysts in the future.