Risk Assessment of Passenger Behaviors That Influence Accident Type and Severity in Metro Operation
Ying Lu,Yi Zhang,Xuepeng Jiang,Yong Wang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/prbm.s419194
IF: 3.974
2023-09-08
Psychology Research and Behavior Management
Abstract:Ying Lu, 1– 3 Yi Zhang, 1 Xuepeng Jiang, 1– 3 Yong Wang 1– 3 1 School of Resources and Environmental Engineering, Wuhan University of Science and Technology, Wuhan, 430081, People's Republic of China; 2 Hubei Industrial Safety Engineering Technology Research Center, Wuhan University of Science and Technology, Wuhan, 430081, People's Republic of China; 3 Safety and Emergency Research Institute, Wuhan University of Science and Technology, Wuhan, 430081, People's Republic of China Correspondence: Yong Wang, Email Background: The unsafe behavior of passengers frequently causes metro operation accidents. This research aims to establish a model for evaluating the risk of unsafe behavior among subway passengers and for assessing the severity of different types of accidents caused by passenger unsafe behavior. Methods: A risk assessment model that combines the Interaction Matrix (IM) model with a Monte Carlo algorithm was established to quantitatively test the risk of unsafe behavior among passengers. Based on the initial data of 234 cases, the behavioral risks in accidents were simulated, and the resulting risks follow a normal distribution. After analyzing the differences in behavioral risk distribution characteristics, the targeted risk mitigation countermeasures were obtained. Results: Results showed that there are 12 kinds of unsafe behaviors related to 4 metro operation accident types. Among them, crowded stampede caused by four kinds of passengers' unsafe behavior has the highest risk mean (μ) of 5.14, followed by escalator injury (4.72), pinched by a shielding barrier (4.42) and fall injury (4.14). Conclusion: The severity of different types of accidents caused by different unsafe behaviors of passengers was obtained, which can provide a basis for targeted risk mitigation strategies and measures. Keywords: passenger unsafe behaviors, metro operation safety, interaction matrix model, IM model, Monte Carlo algorithm, risk mitigation As a modern mode of advantageous transportation with large capacity, high speed, low pollution and energy saving, metro is being constructed in many cities of China. 1,2 The increased metro lines also bring new challenges and demands for reliable and safe metro operation. 3,4 Report showed that there were 1023 metro operation incidents with delays exceeding 5 min in China in 2020, which resulted in casualties and serious property losses. 5 Among risk factors such as human factors, equipment factors, management factors and environmental factors of metro operation, accidents caused by passengers' unsafe behavior account for the highest proportion, due to the lack of safety awareness, less traffic safety training, as well as the metro riding rules are not as strict and explicit as traffic regulations in China. 6–8 Moreover, metro passengers' unsafe behaviors are diverse such as going on boarding even after the door-close alarm sounded, 2 irregular behavior on escalators 1,9 and pushing each other. 10 And the accidents caused by them are uncertain, for instance, some behaviors induce escalator injuries, some lead to fall injury, some have relations to pinched by the shielding barrier, and some even to crowded stampede. 11 It can be seen that there are diverse unsafe behaviors that cause various metro operation accidents, which increases the difficulty of risk management. Considering the growing proportion of passengers' unsafe behaviors and their grave consequences in metro operation, there is an urgent need to examine the passengers' unsafe behaviors risk that affect accident type and severity of metro operation for improving the pertinence and effectiveness of risk mitigation countermeasures. Risk assessment of unsafe behavior is a significant approach to identify risk source and reduce injuries. 12 The risk of unsafe behavior consists of the possibility of behavior and the severity of consequence that caused by the behavior. In order to quantitatively explore the risk of passengers' unsafe behaviors, it is necessary to understand the uncertainty of behavioral risk, find out the effect of each passenger's unsafe behavior on the accident type and severity of metro operation. 13 The selection of comprehensive passengers' unsafe behaviors and the choice of appropriate analytical methods are two important considerations for establishing an accurate risk assessment model to study each passenger's unsafe behavior related to different metro accident types and risk levels. In regard to the selection of passenger's unsafe behaviors, previous studies mainly focus on one or some types, lacking of comprehensive analysis. Unsafe behaviors in -Abstract Truncated-
psychology, clinical, multidisciplinary