Developing a Nitrogen Application Estimation Model for Diverse Wheat Fields: A User-Friendly Approach for Smallholder Nitrogen Fertilizer Recommendations

Ziyang Liu,Yuefan Wang,Syed Tahir Ata-UI-Karim,Xiaojun Liu,Yongchao Tian,Yan Zhu,Weixing Cao,Qiang Cao
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eja.2023.126984
IF: 5.2
2023-01-01
European Journal of Agronomy
Abstract:China's winter wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) production heavily relies on nitrogen (N) fertilizer application, which poses challenges due to the inability of most smallholders to accurately apply N according to site-specific conditions. Difficulty in accurately estimating the nitrogen demands of wheat is a barrier to precise nitrogen fertilizer management. We hypothesized that assessing plant N uptake at different sites can potentially improve site -specific N management based on the theoretical N rate method. To address this issue, this study proposes a cost-effective and user-friendly method to accurately predict plant nitrogen uptake for improving N management decisions. The study used a meta-analysis method, and modeling by integrating datasets from published papers. Then, the model's performance was evaluated using nine different nitrogen input and yield level scenarios built from published paper datasets. A nitrogen fertilizer recommendation model under a specific target yield using both the linear mixed effects model and random forest model was established, with the latter demonstrating superior performance. The model predicts plants' N demand index (NDI) considering geographic, varietal, and climatic characteristics as model input variables. In the scenario suitable for the model, the model reduces the N fertilizer rate by 17.91-110.48 kg ha(- 1 )N, resulting in improved economic benefits by 14.15-137.59 $ ha(- 1), reduced N2O emissions by 15.23-53.7%, and enhanced NEEB benefits by 0.18-1.78%. Notably, the medium -level N input with low-level yield output scenario closely resembles the smallholder production scenario. Improving wheat plants' grain protein content and plant height through breeding can improve their nitrogen requirements by analyzing the factors affecting NDI. The model's efficacy in terms of N recommendation, economic benefits, N2O emissions, and the net ecosystem economic benefit (NEEB) across the nine evaluated scenarios was assessed. Based on the model performance, the factors influencing NDI and providing insights for wheat breeding improvements were identified. Additionally, model suitability assessment demonstrates that, under a typical smallholder production scenario, the model offers economic benefits while reducing pollution. By implementing this approach, smallholders can achieve optimized N management, improving their economic outcomes and contributing to environmental sustainability. This study partially filled the gap between blanket fertilization recommendations and fertilization based on site-specific soil testing.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?