Forum on “characterization Techniques for Li‐Ion Batteries and Beyond”
Jun Lu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/smtd.201800248
IF: 12.4
2018-01-01
Small Methods
Abstract:Transformational changes in battery technologies are critically needed to enable the effective use of renewable energy sources such as solar and wind, and to enable the expansion of the electrification of vehicles. For these applications, batteries must store more energy per unit volume and weight, and they must be capable of undergoing many thousands of charge–discharge cycles. Therefore, developing high-performance batteries is critical to meet these requirements, which certainly relies on material breakthroughs. In the meantime, to enhance the performance and lifetime of batteries (specifically lithium-ion batteries), it is very critical to understand the degradation mechanism of the electrodes. Under this circumstance, various state-of-the-art in situ and operando characterization tools developed during the past few years have clearly become indispensable in studying and eventually optimizing battery materials. Especially with the development of third-generation synchrotron sources, in situ study of the cell during discharging and charging, using X-ray techniques could provide insight into the structural changes at the atomic level. For instance, X-ray absorption fine structure spectroscopy (XAFS) is a powerful tool for studying the electronic and atomic structure of the active host metal. There are many more in situ tools that have been developed to study the battery failure under actual operating conditions, including in situ transmission electron microscopy (TEM), in situ nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR), and the combination of time-resolved X-ray diffraction and mass spectroscopy, for example. The wealth of these important results has grown exponentially in the last few years. This motivated the creation of this Special Issue in Small Methods featuring a section on “Characterization Techniques for Li-Ion Batteries and Beyond” to provide the readership with articles that highlight recent progress in advanced in situ and operando characterizations. Six contributions cover the most popular characterization techniques in the area of Li-ion batteries and beyond, including conventional vibrational spectroscopy methods, electrochemical AC impedance, advanced TEM, and synchrotron-based X-ray absorption fine structure, X-ray diffraction, and X-ray microscopy techniques. Xiulei Ji and co-workers (article number 1700332) review applications of two conventional vibrational spectroscopy characterization tools: Raman spectroscopy and Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy to understand structural changes of battery electrodes. These tools are widely available to most researchers and are often taken as routine methods; however, the values of these technologies should by no means be underestimated. In particular, they could afford deep knowledge that would be otherwise very difficult to obtain. Importantly, these tools are noninvasive, and can be operated at very low cost under ambient conditions, in contrast to high-energy tools. In this review, the authors highlight recent reports in the literature wherein Raman and FTIR are employed for the emerging secondary batteries, including sodium-ion batteries, potassium-ion batteries, Li–S batteries, and Li–O2 batteries. The review provides insights on using these conventional characterization tools to gain understanding of the structures of electrode materials and their structural change during the electrochemical process, the compositions of the solid electrolyte interface (SEI), and the reaction intermediates during the charge–discharge processes. For example, Raman provides highly valuable information to understand the local structures of carbon materials in various batteries, and it can identify the intermediate species in Li–O2 and Li–S batteries, particularly pertaining to the understanding of the mechanisms of these batteries. FTIR can determine the evolution of functional groups, particularly the carbonyl bonds on the electrodes, as well as in the electrolyte solvent. The authors highlighted the cell design, particularly the attenuated total reflection (ATR) FTIR. This review will serve as a highly valuable introduction to Raman and FTIR for battery researchers who have just begun their battery-related research. For more senior researchers, this article will raise their attention to these conventional but still powerful tools. AC impedance is a powerful electrochemical technique to investigate interfacial and diffusional phenomena. It has been used in the research of energy-storage systems for many decades, for example as a diagnostic tool for the health of a battery. The uniqueness of the impedance technique is that it bridges the steady-state and transient states, because of its capability of accessing relaxation phenomena with relaxation times many orders of magnitudes greater than non-steady-state techniques. Therefore, the kinetic parameters, e.g., diffusion coefficient constant, can be determined at various depths of discharge without irreversible modification of the battery system under study. With the rapid advancement of electronics and computation, the instruments used for impedance have become more accessible due to the reduction of the cost and more user-friendly computer interface, control, and fitting software. On the one hand, they now enable fast and accurate impedance measurements of various electrochemical systems; one the other hand, AC impedance represents one of most complex electrochemical techniques, and it should not be used lightly, but through a very careful data analysis to extract as much information as possible from the results. Deyang Qu et al. (article number 1700342) review the AC impedance technique to investigate batteries, covering the fundamental theory of impedance, the impedance of each of the electrochemical processes, and impedance spectrum analysis and modeling. In addition, examples of investigations using the impedance technique for various energy-storage systems are also reviewed. The improvement of the overall performance of lithium-ion batteries is inseparable from the in-depth understanding of their microscopic mechanisms. With a variety of advanced characterization techniques, there has been considerable progress in the study of the microscopic mechanisms of lithium-ion batteries during charge and discharge, but the further development of lithium-ion battery research could be hindered by the limitation of the spatial resolution, in that it is hard to detect atomic-level information of structures by general characterization methods, and there are still many vague places in the construction of the structure–property relationship at the atomic scale. Thanks to the extremely short wavelength of electron waves, TEM has unparalleled superiority in the analysis of material structure. Especially with the help of the aberration correctors, the resolving power of TEM can be substantially improved, and the atomic-scale structural information of electrode materials and solid electrolyte materials for lithium-ion batteries can be easily acquired to provide an experimental basis for an in-depth understanding of the reaction mechanism and failure mechanism of lithium-ion batteries at the atomic scale. Unlike optical microscopes and synchrotron radiation, which use electromagnetic waves as light sources, a highly coherent electron beam is used as the source in TEM. These electrons can not only motivate the second emission of the characteristic signals from the sample, but also carry a large amount of structural and chemical information about the sample on their own, which can be presented in real space and displayed in reciprocal space, and even spread out in energy space. According to the different information processing and presentation methods, the various techniques and methodologies of TEM can be correspondingly divided into three categories; namely, imaging, diffraction, and spectrometry. Meanwhile, the development of in situ technology has enabled TEM to fully realize its resolving power in the time dimension and achieve its significant development. Lin Gu and Xiaozhi Liu (article number 1800006) review a variety of advanced electron-microscopy characterization techniques applied in the research of electrode materials and solid electrolytes for lithium-ion batteries. The scientific topics of concern regarding the material preparation, structural phase transformations, defect configuration, chemical composition, and interface structure of lithium-ion batteries are covered in their review, and the basic principles and typical application examples of each characterization technique are discussed emphatically. For example, the atomic arrangement of interfaces and defective structures can be readily displayed by the imaging technique, which can even provide direct evidence for exotic structures, such as oxygen–oxygen (O–O) bonds; the orientation of crystallites, the type of crystal phases, and the long-range structural modulation can be directly and effectively determined by diffraction techniques; the spatial distribution of chemical composition and valence states can be determined by the spectrometry technique; the in situ TEM technique can expand the characterization in the time dimension and provide effective methods for the dynamic observation of phase transformation, interface movement, ion migration, and charge transfer. In addition, the effective combination of multiple characterization techniques can comprehensively deepen the understanding of the energy-storage mechanism of lithium-ion batteries. In spite of challenges to lithium-ion battery research, advanced TEM characterization techniques can enable us to further deepen the understanding of its atomic-scale structure–property relationship and provide useful guidance for subsequent improvement of the practical performance. Synchrotron-radiation (SR)-based techniques have been widely applied to study batteries to solve the remaining challenges, due to their high brilliance, flux, and stability. SR-based techniques provide a great chance to see what happens during the working process of a battery. An in-depth understanding of batteries has been realized through utilizing SR techniques and promotes the development of better and smarter batteries. Xueliang Sun and co-workers (article number 1700341) summarize the application of SR techniques for lithium secondary batteries with a focus on several techniques, including XAFS, synchrotron X-ray diffraction (SXRD) and synchrotron X-ray microscopy (SXM) techniques. The measurement principles of different techniques are introduced to explain how these characterization techniques are employed in various research projects. The utilization of SR techniques in different directions of batteries, including electrodes, electrolytes, and interfaces is intensively summarized and discussed. The practical application strategies of techniques in batteries are also clarified. The review gives a clear picture of how to use SR techniques to understand the working and degradation process of batteries. By summarizing and discussing the application of SR techniques in batteries, this review is aimed at highlighting the crucial role of SR characterization in the development of advanced energy materials. Jiajun Wang and co-workers (article number 1700293) further emphasize synchrotron X-ray imaging techniques with high spatial, temporal, and chemical resolution to elucidate the underlying mechanisms in battery electrochemical reactions. The nondestructive nature of X-ray imaging provides a powerful platform to explore the evolution and degradation of battery materials over a wide range of time and length scales. There are two general modes of X-ray microscopy: lens-based (e.g., full-field transmission X-ray microscopy (TXM), scanning transmission X-ray microscopy (STXM), and micro-X-ray fluorescence (XFM)), and lensless-based methods (e.g., coherent diffraction imaging (CDI)). A broad range of lens-based X-ray microscopy and mapping techniques is now available to probe these processes down to the nanoscale. The tunable nature of the synchrotron X-ray beam enables chemical analysis with high sensitivity through spectromicroscopy. Phase contrast imaging can retrieve the complex-valued refraction of the material, giving an even more nuanced chemical picture. With the increasingly widespread adoption of tomography techniques, the potential to track microstructural degradation of battery electrodes in 3D over an extended lifetime cycling provides a compelling opportunity to understand the fundamental driving forces for capacity fading and failure. Lensless coherent Bragg diffraction imaging enables structure determination of noncrystalline specimens and nanocrystals with a resolution limited only by the spatial frequency of the diffracted waves, providing a reconstructed three-dimensional volume of the specimen, as well as internal strain information. Some new insights into battery materials have been recently achieved through the applications of these X-ray imaging methods. Experiments performed while the battery is being actively cycled under in operando reveal behavior that differs significantly from that which is observed at equilibrium and metastable conditions. The continuous improvements on X-ray source brightness and coherence will extend these techniques by alleviating the current trade-off in time, chemical, and spatial resolution, enabling scientists and engineers to develop the next generation of safer high-performance batteries for a range of demanding applications. Finally, Yang Ren and Xiaobing Zuo (article number 1800064) discuss synchrotron X-ray and neutron diffraction, total scattering, and small-angle scattering for research of battery materials. Conventional X-ray- and neutron-diffraction methods reveal crystal structures of well-crystalline materials, which are the major components of electrodes in commercial batteries. Information obtained by traditional diffraction can be crystal structure symmetry, lattice size, atomic composition and position, site occupation, average thermal motion, particle size, and lattice microstrain, etc. However, batteries also contain materials that are not well crystallized, such as amorphous, disordered, and nanoscale materials. In this case, the so-called total scattering techniques coupled with the pair-distribution-function (PDF) and computational modeling and simulation will play an important role in revealing local atomic structure, which provides atom relationships in terms of bond length, coordination, structure coherence, nanoparticle size, etc. Beyond the atomistic relationship obtained using diffraction and PDF methods, battery materials have structure features with a large range of length scales from picometer to millimeter and even larger. Structure features above nanometer-scale up to millimeter-scale can be investigated using the small-angle-scattering (SAS) and ultrasmall-angle scattering (USAS) techniques. Different from the conventional diffraction and PDF methods, SAS provides structure information in terms of particle sizes, shapes, morphologies and their distributions and corrections in three-dimensional space. Battery charging and discharging processes are very complicated, involving electronic and ionic conductions, structure phase transformations, chemical reactions, and material conversion, etc. Monitoring these processes during in situ and in operando conditions will provide crucial knowledge for our fundamental understanding of the energy materials in action, thus guiding us to improve and modify existing materials and to develop new generations of advanced batteries. J.L. gratefully acknowledges support from the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE), Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy, Vehicle Technologies Office. Argonne National Laboratory is operated for DOE Office of Science by UChicago Argonne, LLC, under contract number DE-AC02-06CH11357. Jun Lu is a chemist at Argonne National Laboratory. His research interests focus on electrochemical energy storage and conversion technology, with a main focus on beyond-Li-ion battery technology. He earned his bachelor's degree in chemistry physics from University of Science and Technology of China (USTC) in 2000. He completed his Ph.D. at the Department of Metallurgical Engineering at University of Utah in 2009 with a major research on metal hydrides for reversible hydrogen-storage applications.