Normative modeling for developmental population neuroscience: A "microscope" through which the laws and characteristics of individual differentiation can be quantified in human brain-mind development

Qing Zhang,Yinshan Wang,Lizhen Chen,Jiaxin Zhang,Zixuan Zhou,Xinian Zuo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1360/TB-2022-1170

2023-01-01

Abstract:Human neuroscience is at a crossroads where both replicability and generalizability of neurocognitive research remain highly challenging due to potentially unprecedented complexity of brain-behavior associations and thus hamper their translations into healthcare practices. An important aspect of such complexity is individual differences while population neuroscience provides a promising framework for addressing this complexity with an interdisciplinary paradigm by integrating neuroscience, genetics and epidemiology. A fairly attractive research direction in developmental population neuroscience is to uncover the patterns, origins and neural mechanisms of these individual differences in the human brain and mind. The complexity of understanding these individual differences in this new direction presents great challenges for current research methods. To fill this methodological gap, we argue that there is an urgent need to develop a methodological framework for modelling individual differences at both the population and individual levels with quantitative general laws and the characteristics of individual differentiation. Normative modelling provides an effective methodological choice for this purpose to bridge general laws and individual translations. This method can be used to generate statistical models at the population level by leveraging distributional regression approaches on representative samples and derives deviations at individual level from the population reference models as individual differentiation quantities. This methodological framework can provide a novel tool for developmental population neuroscience research through which common patterns and the biological underpinnings of individual differences in the brain and mind can be elucidated from a lifespan perspective. This framework offers reference resources that can be used to not only reveal possible etiological mechanisms of various brain-mind disorders but also implement their precise clinical practices such as the pediatric growth charts for references and standards. According to the vast potential of normative modelling methods, in this review, we encourage the immediate action of optimizing sampling strategies, standardizing data collection, and improving statistical modelling for deep investigations to accelerate their translational applications. In recent years, China has accumulated rich resources of in-vivo neuroimaging data, paralleling to the international brain imaging data sharing and open brain science research. Looking beyond, various large-scale brain-mind cohorts will be continuously initiated to cover different regions and different stages of lifespan through the program of scientific and technological innovation 2030-The major project of the Brain Science and Brain-Inspired Intelligence Technology. This will offer China the world's largest living brain-mind resources for promoting the research, application and transformation of normative modeling methods in the development of population neuroscience. Such advances will lead to construct normative brain-mind association models for the lifespan development of Chinese population, assist the early diagnosis and precise treatment as well as reform the clinical practice. It is expected to ultimately provide scientific support for parsing the etiology of the brain-mind diseases, and optimizing the national brain health and its related policy designation.