Replacing PCR with COLD-PCR Enriches Variant DNA Sequences and Redefines the Sensitivity of Genetic Testing in Cancer

Jin Li,Lilin Wang,Harvey J. Mamon,Matthew H. Kulke,R. Berbeco,Mike Makrigiorgos
IF: 11.2
2008-01-01
Cancer Research
Abstract:1796 Introduction: The Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR) has become the cornerstone of molecular diagnosis, with almost every genetic test aiming to identify DNA sequence variation incorporating PCR. A commonly encountered problem is that variant DNA sequences exist in the presence of a large majority of wild type alleles such as when DNA is obtained from heterogeneous cancer biopsies or when fetal alleles are sought in maternal blood. As a result, downstream assays are severely limited in their ability to identify subtle genetic changes that can have profound impact in clinical decision-making and outcome. We describe Co-amplification at Lower Denaturation temperature (COLD-PCR), a novel form of PCR that amplifies minority alleles selectively from mixtures of wild-type and mutation-containing sequences irrespective of the mutation type or position on the sequence (Nature Medicine, In Press). Methods: In COLD-PCR, an intermediate annealing temperature is used during PCR-cycling to allow cross-hybridization of mutant and wild type alleles; hetero-duplexes, which melt at lower temperatures than homo-duplexes, are then selectively denatured and amplified at Critical Denaturation Temperature (Tc), while homo-duplexes remain double-stranded and do not amplify efficiently. By fixing the denaturation temperature to Tc, mutations at any position along the sequence are enriched during COLD-PCR amplification. To validate COLD-PCR, we used serial dilutions of DNA from tumor-derived cell lines containing point mutations or micro-deletions at different positions along p53 exon 8 and Kras exon 1 (codons 12-13), or samples with micro-deletions in EGFR exon 19. In addition, genomic DNA from a series of colon and lung cancer surgical specimens, and plasma-circulating DNA collected under IRB approval were utilized for validation on clinical specimens. Results: By replacing regular PCR with COLD-PCR prior to application of a range of assays (Sanger sequencing; Pyrosequencing; MALDI-TOF; dHPLC; RFLP; and Taqman) we improved mutation detection sensitivity up to 100-fold and identified several additional p53/Kras/EGFR mutations in heterogeneous cancer samples. 4 of 43 surgical samples and 3 of 10 plasma samples tested contained clinically important mutations that were not detected by any of the methods tested when preceded by regular-PCR, but they were detectable following COLD-PCR. Conclusion: Replacement of regular PCR with COLD-PCR provides a universal boost to most mutation detection technologies and enables them to be used with the required confidence in routine screening of cancer specimens for somatic mutations, including low-level mutation screening of surgical/FFPE tumor samples or bodily fluids. COLD-PCR is also anticipated to find application in pre-natal diagnosis, in infectious diseases and in epigenetics.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?