Comparative Evaluation of Experimental Methods for Detecting Helicobacter Pylori Infection

WANG Chun-jiang,GE Fu-lin
2003-01-01
Abstract:AIM: To evaluate some detecting methods with diagnostic value in the diagnosis of Helicobacter pylori (Hp) infection. METHODS: Antral biopsy specimens obtained by gastroscopy from 386 patients were detected with modified Giemsa stain and rapid urease test (RUT). The patients were also examined with 14 C urease breath test ( 14 C UBT) and serum Hp IgG antibody. Comparison was made with bacteria culture and these detecting methods were evaluated by χ 2 test. RESULTS: RUT, 14 C UBT and modified Giemsa stain detections had relatively higher sensitivity and specificity and produced similar result to that of bacteria culture. The result of modified Giemsa stain detection combined with 14 C UBT was more similar to that of bacteria culture (99.7%). Although the sensitivity of serum Hp IgG antibody examination was the same as those of other methods, its specificity was relatively lower, especially the specificity of the return visit group ( P 0.01), which was also different from that of the first visit group ( χ 2=35.18, P 0.01 ). CONCLUSION: The Hp IgG antibody examination can be used in screening Hp infection, but not in evaluating the curative effect. The combined detection of 14 C UBT with modified Giemsa stain is comparatively more reliable in detecting Hp infection.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?