The Liquidity Trap: an Alternative Explanation for Today's Low Inflation

Maria A. Arias,Yi Wen

2014-01-01

Abstract:In contrast with many people’s expectations, the Fed’s injection of $3.5 trillion into the economy caused no significant inflation or increases in the price level. There are many possible explanations in the mainstream; an alternative is a liquidity trap.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Low Inflation in a World of Securitization

Brett W. Fawley,Yi Wen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.20955/es.2013.15

2013-01-01

Economic Synopses

Abstract:Weak lending may still be the culprit behind low inflation, but monetary aggregates may no longer closely track credit conditions.
Testing the Liquidity Effect with Equilibrium Interest Rate

Liu Zhentao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00036840600820689

IF: 1.916

2008-01-01

Applied Economics

Abstract:We examine the existence of liquidity effects by using the equilibrium interest rates estimated from the disequilibrium analysis instead of the observed interest rate. The use of equilibrium interest rates allows us to take the growth rate in the money supply as being exogenous and circumvent the identification problem away. Following the traditional AR model and the method proposed by Hamilton (1997), we obtain evidences showing the negative relationship between the equilibrium interest rate and the growth rate in money supply.
Money, Liquidity and Bank Competition

Ping He,Zehao Liu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2755060

2017-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:Real liquidity refers to the real purchasing power of the monetary base. In an economy where banks only take money as deposits, insufficient real liquidity constrains the price level when there is a liquidity shock before banks settle their long-term loan contracts. This leads to strictly positive nominal investment return and over-investment. In the presence of systemic liquidity shocks, the price-adjustment mechanism cannot take full effect with a real liquidity shortage, which can lead to non-zero profits for banks. Quantitative easing, featuring a combination of nominal liquidity injection and lump-sum tax, can help the economy achieve a socially optimal allocation. Exchanging real goods for reserve assets to increase the real value of monetary base can improve social welfare.
Fiscal Stimulus of Last Resort

Alessandro Piergallini

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2104.02753

2021-04-07

Abstract:I examine global dynamics in a monetary model with overlapping generations of finite-horizon agents and a binding lower bound on nominal interest rates. Debt targeting rules exacerbate the possibility of self-fulfilling liquidity traps, for agents expect austerity following deflationary slumps. Conversely, activist but sustainable fiscal policy regimes - implementing intertemporally balanced tax cuts and/or transfer increases in response to disinflationary trajectories - are capable of escaping liquidity traps and embarking inflation into a globally stable path that converges to the target. Should fiscal stimulus of last resort be overly aggressive, however, spiral dynamics around the liquidity-trap steady state exist, causing global indeterminacy.

Theoretical Economics
Excess Liquidity and Credit Misallocation: Evidence from China

Shiyuan Pan,Kang Shi,Lisheng Wang,Juanyi Xu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/17538963.2017.1370141

2017-01-01

China Economic Journal

Abstract:China's M2/GDP ratio continues to rise despite having reached the highest tier in the world, but there is no consensus on its driving forces. In this paper, we investigate this puzzle empirically, using different levels of data. We first estimate the degree of the excess liquidity in China based on cross-country regressions. Our results show that China's excess liquidity is 50 percent of that implied by the cross-country benchmark. Province-level evidence shows that credit misallocation between state-owned enterprises (SOEs) and private enterprises (PEs) may lead to credit inefficiency and hence generate excess liquidity. We further validate this finding using manufacturing firm-level data, and show that credit misallocation has deteriorated since the Four Trillion Yuan Stimulus Plan since 2008. These facts unveil more challenges for the ongoing deleveraging campaign and SOE reform.
The Inefficacy of Loose Monetary Policy

Kenneth S. Choie

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5539/ijef.v15n8p73

2023-07-10

International Journal of Economics and Finance

Abstract:Based on U.S. macroeconomic data from the past 30 years, it appears that the loose monetary policy of maintaining low interest rates did not effectively encourage businesses and consumers to increase their purchases. Despite the intent of the policy to stimulate demand for goods and services, it instead had an unexpected effect on the financial sector by driving up demand for assets, which led to inflation in equity and real estate prices. As a result, a loose monetary policy is unlikely to be an effective strategy for countering a recession, which contradicts the working assumption of the central banks around the world.
Understanding Persistent ZLB: Theory and Assessment

Pablo Cuba-Borda,Sanjay R. Singh

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1257/mac.20210453

2024-07-01

Abstract:We develop a theoretical framework that rationalizes two hypotheses of long-lasting low-interest rate episodes: deflationary-expectations-traps and secular stagnation in a unified setting. These hypotheses differ in the sign of the theoretical correlation between inflation and output growth that they imply. Using the data from Japan over 1998:I–2019:IV, we find that the data favor the expectations-trap hypothesis. The superior model fit of the expectations trap relies on its ability to generate the observed negative correlation between inflation and output growth. (JEL E12, E31, E32, E43, E52)

economics
Liquidity Demand and Welfare in a Heterogeneous-Agent Economy

Yi Wen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1387091

2009-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:This paper reconsiders the welfare costs of inflation and the welfare gains from financial intermediation in a heterogeneous-agent economy where money is held as a store of value (as in Bewley, 1980). The dynamic stochastic general equilibrium model recaptures some essential features of the liquidity-preference theory of Keynes (1930, 1936). Because of heterogeneous liquidity demand, transitory lump-sum money injections can have persistent expansionary effects despite flexible prices, and such effects can be greatly amplified by the banking system through the credit channel. However, permanent money growth can be extremely costly: With log utility functions, consumers are willing to reduce consumption by 15% (or more) to avoid a 10% annual inflation. For the same reason, financial intermediation can significantly improve welfare: The welfare costs of a collapse of the banking system is estimated as about 10-68% of aggregate output. These welfare implications differ dramatically from those of the existing literature.
Are Prices Sticky and Does It Matter

Liang Wang,Randall Wright

2016-01-01

Abstract:Many economists believe that prices are ?sticky??they adjust slowly. This stickiness, they suggest, means that changes in the money supply have an impact on the real economy, inducing changes in investment, employment, output and consumption, an effect that can be exploited by policymakers. {{p}} In this essay, we argue that price stickiness doesn?t necessarily generate an exploitable policy option. We describe a model in which money is neutral (that is, growth or reduction in money supply doesn?t impact real economic activity) even in a context of sluggish price adjustment.
The Missing Money and the Sudden Inflation

Ping PEI,Gui-xin HAN

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1009-8860.2005.01.006

2005-01-01

Abstract:The price index had begun to rise since the second half of 2003. In order to control the possible inflation, the central bank had employed tight monetary policy. However, the monetary policy had not realized the objectives of controlling price. The domestic price increased at the great pace after undergoing long-term deflation. This paper tried to explain the profound reason of the sudden inflation using the “hypothesis of missing money” so as to enrich the study of monetary policy theory and to raise some countermeasures for improving the efficiency of China's monetary policy.
Testing and mechanism identification of liquidity trap in China

Kaifeng Duan Chuanzhen Zheng Yuan Shan a School of Economics and Management,Fuzhou University,Fuzhou,Chinab School of Economics and Management,Tongji University,Shanghai,Chinac Faculty of Economics and Business Administration,Ghent University,Ghent,Belgium

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/13504851.2024.2364016

2024-06-13

Applied Economics Letters

Abstract:This paper examines the existence and mechanism of China's liquidity trap. First, a broad money supply model is reconstructed to evaluate the effectiveness of monetary policy. Based on the observed data from 1997 to 2022 and first-order difference regression results, we find that: The relationship between the monetary base and broad money exhibits two distinct stages, with 2008 as a delineating point. Pre-2008, the money creation multiplier is significant; post-2008, it becomes insignificant. Second, by examining the asset-side and liability-side gaps of the financial system, we have identified two liquidity traps. The first occurs between 2015 and 2019, caused by funds idling within the financial system. The second occurs in 2020- and is caused by recessionary expectations. Monetary policy flexibility is waning, compelling strategic decisions for Chinese government and central bank.

economics
Changing Central Bank Pressures and Inflation

Hassan Afrouzi,Marina Halac,Kenneth Rogoff,Pierre Yared,Kenneth S. Rogoff

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4787399

2024-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:We present a simple long-run aggregate demand and supply framework for evaluating long-run inflation. The framework illustrates how exogenous economic and political economy factors generate central bank pressures that can impact long-run inflation as well as transitions between steady states. We use the analysis to provide a fresh perspective on the forces that drove global inflation downward over the past four decades. We argue that for inflation to remain low and stable in the future, political economy factors, such as strengthened central bank independence or more credible public debt policy, would need to offset the global economic pressures now pushing average long-run inflation upwards.Institutional subscribers to the NBER working paper series, and residents of developing countries may download this paper without additional charge at www.nber.org.
Inflation -- who cares? Monetary Policy in Times of Low Attention

Oliver Pfäuti

2023-10-23

Abstract:I propose an approach to quantify attention to inflation in the data and show that the decrease in the volatility and persistence of U.S. inflation after the Great Inflation period was accompanied by a decline in the public's attention to inflation. This decline in attention has important implications (positive and normative) for monetary policy as it renders managing inflation expectations more difficult and can lead to inflation-attention traps: prolonged periods of a binding lower bound and low inflation due to slowly-adjusting inflation expectations. As attention declines the optimal policy response is to increase the inflation target. Accounting for the lower bound fundamentally changes the normative implications of declining attention. While lower attention raises welfare absent the lower-bound constraint, it decreases welfare when accounting for the lower bound.

General Economics
Secular Stagnation, Too Much Saving, Ben Bernanke vs Larry Summers and the Theory of Limited Good

Niccolo Leo Caldararo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2638198

2015-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:Current discussions among major economists finds significant disagreement in defining the status of the global economy. This article examines the main themes in the context of the theories presented on savings, consumption and investment. The primitive society concept of “limited good” appears to have more relevance than any of these theories of modernity. Central banks have been injecting liquidity into markets from the UK, EU, the USA and China and yet the effect has not produced “normality” in the world economy or domestic ones. A “magic” element is lacking and yet is this concept consonant with modernity as it has been described?
The Deflationary Bias of the ZLB and the FED's Strategic Response

ADRIAN PENALVER,DANIELE SIENA

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/jmcb.13140

IF: 1.963

2024-03-02

Journal of money credit and banking

Abstract:The paper shows, in a simple analytical framework, the existence of a deflationary bias in an economy with a low natural rate of interest, a zero lower bound (ZLB) constraint on nominal interest rates and a discretionary Central Bank (CB) with an inflation mandate. The presence of the ZLB prevents the CB from offsetting negative shocks to inflation whereas it can offset positive shocks. This asymmetry pushes average inflation below the target which in turn drags down inflation expectations and reinforces the likelihood of hitting the ZLB. We show that this deflationary bias is particularly relevant for a CB with a symmetric dual mandate (i.e., minimizing deviations from inflation and employment), especially when facing demand shocks. But a strict inflation targeter cannot escape the suboptimal deflationary equilibrium either. The deflationary bias can be mitigated by targeting "shortfalls" instead of "deviations" from maximum employment and/or using flexible average inflation targeting. However, changing monetary policy strategy risks inflation expectations becoming entrenched above the target if the natural interest rate increases.

economics,business, finance
Inflation and Money: A Puzzle

pengfei wang,yi wen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.874057

2005-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:We document that persistent and lagged inflation (with respect to output) is a worldwide phenomenon in that these short-run inflation dynamics are highly synchronized across countries. We investigate whether standard monetary models are consistent with the empirical facts. We find that neither the new Keynesian sticky-price model nor the Mankiw-Reis (QJE 2002) sticky-information model can explain the international synchronization of the short-run inflation dynamics. Although the sticky-information model of Mankiw and Reis is very successful in explaining the persistent and lagged inflation dynamics for each individual country, its open-economy analogue fails to explain the synchronization of the inflation dynamics among the countries using calibrated international covariance of monetary shocks. The reason is that the dynamic effects of monetary shocks on inflation in one country cannot be effectively propagated across and preserved in other countries. We conclude that the short-run inflation dynamics and their global synchronization cannot be a monetary phenomenon, but may be instead the consequence of non-monetary shocks. An independent contribution of the paper is to provide a simple solution technique for solving general equilibrium models with lagged expectations (e.g., due to sticky information).
Inflation—Who Cares? Monetary Policy in Times of Low Attention

OLIVER PFÄUTI

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/jmcb.13145

IF: 1.963

2024-03-25

Journal of money credit and banking

Abstract:I propose an approach to quantify attention to inflation and show that attention declined after the Great Inflation period. This decline in attention has important implications for monetary policy as it renders managing inflation expectations more difficult and can lead to inflation‐attention traps: prolonged periods of a binding lower bound and low inflation due to slowly adjusting inflation expectations. As attention declines, the optimal policy response is to increase the inflation target. The lower bound fundamentally changes the normative implications of declining attention: lower attention raises welfare absent the lower‐bound constraint, whereas it decreases welfare when accounting for the lower bound.

economics,business, finance
Evaluating Unconventional Monetary Policies Why Aren’t They More Effective?

Yi Wen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2337163

2013-01-01

Abstract:We use a general equilibrium nance model that features explicit government purchases of private debts to shed light on some of the principal working mechanisms of the Federal Reserves large-scale asset purchases (LSAP) and their macroeconomic e¤ects. Our model predicts that unless private asset purchases are highly persistent and extremely large (on the order of more than 50% of annual GDP), money injections through LSAP cannot e¤ectively boost aggregate output and employment even if ination is fully anchored and the real interest rate signicantly reduced. Our framework also sheds light on some longstanding nancial puzzles and monetary policy questions facing central banks around the world, such as (i) the ight to liquidity under a credit crunch and debt crisis, (ii) the liquidity trap, and (iii) the low ination puzzle under quantitative easing.
Ultra-Low Interest Rates: Risk Measurement/Assessment and Macroprudential Political Economy

Rainer Masera

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3537508

2020-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:After recalling the quantitative relevance as of end-2019 of “new normal” ultra-low interest rates at world level, a brief discussion is offered of key areas of economic analysis and policy critically impacted by negative nominal interest rates. Specific reference is made to the following points. Risk modelling/measurement and the Basel risk-weighted capital framework. The operational viability of banks and insurance companies and the growth of leveraged loans. The liquidity trap revisited and the risk of illiquidity. Secular stagnation and the savings glut: the role of monetary policy. Political economy in the EA: a macro-prudential network perspective to prevent systemic risk. The case for infrastructure investment. On the basis of the arguments presented, it is argued, in the concluding remarks, that the costs of prolonged primary reliance on monetary expansion and sub-zero interest rates outweigh the benefits. A more balanced policy approach is outlined, with a view to improving the functioning of the Eurozone, enlarging the policy space, and reducing financial vulnerabilities.
The quasi-inflation of 2021–2022: a case of bad analysis and worse response

James K. Galbraith

DOI: https://doi.org/10.4337/roke.2023.02.04

2023-04-21

Review of Keynesian Economics

Abstract:The theoretical construct of pure inflation is of no use in understanding the price events of 2021 and 2022 in the United States. By extension, the conventional tools of the Phillips Curve, NAIRU, potential output and money–supply growth are equally useless. By further extension, the ‘anti-inflation’ policies of the Federal Reserve have acted on asset markets (which are not part of theoretical inflation) while taking credit for the end to a price process in produced goods that was transitory in any event. The Federal Reserve is now stuck in a posture guaranteed to destabilize economic activity sooner or later, while the economy remains vulnerable to additional potential price shocks emanating from the same sources already seen, including real resources, supply chains, wars, pandemics and the policies of the Federal Reserve itself. These can be dealt with, if at all, only by policies in each specific area.

economics

The Liquidity Trap: an Alternative Explanation for Today's Low Inflation

Low Inflation in a World of Securitization

Testing the Liquidity Effect with Equilibrium Interest Rate

Money, Liquidity and Bank Competition

Fiscal Stimulus of Last Resort

Excess Liquidity and Credit Misallocation: Evidence from China

The Inefficacy of Loose Monetary Policy

Understanding Persistent ZLB: Theory and Assessment

Liquidity Demand and Welfare in a Heterogeneous-Agent Economy

Are Prices Sticky and Does It Matter

The Missing Money and the Sudden Inflation

Testing and mechanism identification of liquidity trap in China

Changing Central Bank Pressures and Inflation

Inflation -- who cares? Monetary Policy in Times of Low Attention

Secular Stagnation, Too Much Saving, Ben Bernanke vs Larry Summers and the Theory of Limited Good

The Deflationary Bias of the ZLB and the FED's Strategic Response

Inflation and Money: A Puzzle

Inflation—Who Cares? Monetary Policy in Times of Low Attention

Evaluating Unconventional Monetary Policies Why Aren’t They More Effective?

Ultra-Low Interest Rates: Risk Measurement/Assessment and Macroprudential Political Economy

The quasi-inflation of 2021–2022: a case of bad analysis and worse response