The Potential Negative Effect of High‐Dose Glucosamine on the Chondrocyte: Comment on the Article by Caramés Et Al

Libo Jiang,Jian Zhang,Jian Dong

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/art.38230

2013-01-01

Arthritis & Rheumatology

Abstract:We read with great interest the recent article by Caramés et al, who demonstrated that glucosamine can activate autophagy in human chondrocytes and in mouse knee joints by inhibiting the Akt/FoxO/mammalian target of rapamycin pathway (1). Importantly, the authors proved that intraperitoneal and oral administration of glucosamine induced similar levels of autophagy in the cartilage, thus providing a convenient method for inducing autophagy in vivo in the future. Similarly, another study also demonstrated the inductive effect of glucosamine on autophagy in HeLa and COS-7 cells (2). Glucosamine has been shown to play antiinflammatory, anticatabolic, and antiapoptotic roles in the chondrocyte (3, 4), and in the future autophagy might be identified as a mechanism mediating these effects. However, as mentioned in reports suggesting double roles of autophagy in disease (5), the negative effect of “autophagic cell death” on chondrocytes may need to be elucidated. After treating normal chondrocytes from SD rats with 100 mM glucosamine for 24 hours, we observed that the cytoplasm of cells in monolayer culture was filled with numerous vacuoles (Figure 1). When the incubation time was extended, an increasing number of chondrocytes died, which indicated that glucosamine at high concentrations may lead to autophagic cell death. Although we could not determine whether the cells died due to autophagy, the results suggested that high-dose glucosamine may have a negative effect on cell viability. Photomicrographs obtained by phase-contrast microscopy, showing the morphology of chondrocytes treated with 100 mM glucosamine for 24 hours, at A, lower magnification (100×) and B, higher magnification (400×). In accordance with our observations, De Mattei et al showed that glucosamine at doses of 6.5 mg/ml (∼30 mM) and 25 mg/ml (∼116 mM) decreased cell viability in bovine cartilage explants by 28% and >90%, respectively (6). Moreover, ultrastructural analysis showed that the cells in which death was induced by glucosamine exhibited obvious vacuoles in the cytoplasm (6). In addition, Walsh and colleagues reported that after 4 days and 7 days of exposure to glucosamine at a dose of 4.5 mg/ml (∼20 mM), the DNA content of annulus fibrosus cells was reduced by 75% and 89%, respectively (7). Therefore, it may be imperative to place the emphasis on the concentration when treating chondrocytes with glucosamine. In summary, although an increasing number of studies have suggested that there may be a role for autophagy in the treatment of arthritis, further studies, especially in the human system, are still needed to rule out any negative effects. Supported by the Natural Science Foundation of China (grant 81372002) and the “Technology Innovation Action Plan” Key Project of the Shanghai Science and Technology Commission (grant 12411951300).