Reply to Luo Et Al.: Robustness of Causal Effects of Galactic Cosmic Rays on Interannual Variation in Global Temperature

Hao Ye,George Sugihara,Ethan R. Deyle,Robert M. May,Kyle L. Swanson,Anastasios A. Tsonis

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1511080112

2015-01-01

Abstract:Tsonis et al. (1) recently used convergent cross mapping (CCM) (2) to identify a causal relationship between cosmic rays (CRs) and interannual variation in global temperature (ΔGT). Subsequently, Luo et al. (3) questioned this finding using the Clark implementation of CCM (version 1.0 of the multispatial CCM package).* This version of the CCM code, which has since been debugged by Clark, unfortunately contains errors that are not in the original rEDM software package that Tsonis et al. used.† Thus, though well-intentioned, the Luo et al. (3) analysis is incorrect.