Cross-cultural Disparities of Subjective Sleep Parameters and Their Age-Related Trends over the First Three Years of Human Life: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Qingmin Lin,Karen Spruyt,Yue Leng,Yanrui Jiang,Guanghai Wang,Shumei Dong,Hao Mei,Jian‐Gao Fan
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.smrv.2019.07.006
IF: 11.401
2019-01-01
Sleep Medicine Reviews
Abstract:Changes in nighttime sleep consolidation and daytime discontinuation have been observed in early life. Yet information about societal or cultural factors remains scant for implementing sleep recommendations. We aimed to provide pooled estimates of subjective sleep duration, number of nightwakings and sleep timing; to describe their age-related trends; and to determine potential cross-cultural disparities between predominantly-Asian (PA) and predominantly-Caucasian (PC) regions during the first three years of life. We performed this review according to the PRISMA guidelines. Overall, 102 studies with 167,886 children aged 0-3 y from 26 different countries/regions were included. Compared to PC regions, PA toddlers had shorter sleep duration and more frequent nightwakings. When PC regions were further divided into Pacific Rim and Europe, differences were much more evident between PA and Pacific Rim for all nighttime sleep parameters. Trends of nighttime sleep duration and bedtime for PC regions showed rapid changes over the first 3-6 mo before stabilizing to a plateau, whereas a different change was found for PA regions. In conclusion, an apparent cross-cultural disparity of the subjective sleep parameters already exists in early childhood. Improved operationalization of sleep parameters and more objective evidence are needed to establish cultural-sensitive recommendations this early in life.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?