Abstract:Background: Phenomena of instability are widely observed in many dissimilar systems, with punctuated equilibrium in biological evolution and economic crises being noticeable examples. Recent studies suggested that such instabilities, quantified by the abrupt changes of the composition of individuals, could result within the framework of a collection of individuals interacting through the prisoner's dilemma and incorporating three mechanisms: (i) imitation and mutation, (ii) preferred selection on successful individuals, and (iii) networking effects.Methodology/Principal Findings: We study the importance of each mechanism using simplified models. The models are studied numerically and analytically via rate equations and mean-field approximation. It is shown that imitation and mutation alone can lead to the instability on the number of cooperators, and preferred selection modifies the instability in an asymmetric way. The co-evolution of network topology and game dynamics is not necessary to the occurrence of instability and the network topology is found to have almost no impact on instability if new links are added in a global manner. The results are valid in both the contexts of the snowdrift game and prisoner's dilemma.Conclusions/Significance: The imitation and mutation mechanism, which gives a heterogeneous rate of change in the system's composition, is the dominating reason of the instability on the number of cooperators. The effects of payoffs and network topology are relatively insignificant. Our work refines the understanding on the driving forces of system instability.

A Random Evolution Model of Incomplete Competitive System

Evolution and distribution of competitiveness to deterministic stochastic competitive system

Topological Structure and Evolution Nature of Competitive System Based on Reverse Preferential Competition

An evolution model of complex systems with simultaneous cooperation and competition

Mathematical Model Allowing the Coexistence of Closely Related Competitors at the Initial Stage of Evolution

Dynamic Analysis of Network Organization's Evolution Based on the Relationship Between Competition and Cooperation

Evolution Kinetics and Phase Transitions of Complex Adaptive Systems

Dynamical behavior of a competitive system under the influence of random disturbance and toxic substances

A Model for E-commerce Market Network with Improved Evolution Mechanism

The Almost Sure Evolution of Hierarchy Among Similar Competitors

Strategy Evolution Driven by Switching Probabilities in Structured Multi-Agent Systems

SELF-ORGANIZATION AND EVOLUTION:A SIMULATED STUDY

Evolutionary Dynamics of Strategies Without Complete Information on Complex Networks

Must the System Evolution Meet the Power-Law Rates?

Random Stock Model Based on Evolutionary Strategies

An Evolutionary Game with the Game Transitions Based on the Markov Process

Network growth approach to macroevolution

Evolution of autocatalytic sets in a competitive percolation model

Modeling and Analysis of Competitive Behavior in Social Systems

A Complex Network Evolution Model Based on Microscopic Characteristic of Nodes

Instability in Evolutionary Games