Fair Value and the Role of Accruals: A Comparison between New and Old Accounting Standards in China
Xue Shuang,Xu Haoping,Shi Haina
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1008-3448.2009.05.017
2009-01-01
Abstract:All listed companies in China are required to adopt the new accounting standards from 2007 on. The new accounting standards, compared with the old accounting standards, are characterized by the adoption of fair value. Most of the existing literature focuses on studying the effect of fair value on value relevance of accounting numbers. In this paper, we compare the old and new accounting standards to investigate whether the adoption of fair value enhance the role of accruals. Following Dechow and Dichev (2002) and Ball and Shivakumar (2006), we focus on two distinguish roles of accruals: (1) the noise-reduction role; and (2) the timely gain recognition role. Specifically, we examine whether fair value approach adopted by new accounting standards improves accruals’ role in mitigating transitory variation in cash flows and in timely recognizing economic gains. Accruals are measured based on Modified Jones Model. To facilitate a clean comparison between new and old accounting standards, we choose year 2006 as our sample period, in which year income statements under both standards are reported. With a sample of 1,211 non-financial listed firms in 2006, we document the following findings. We find that the explanatory power of cash flows on accruals is significantly lower under the fair value approach. Moreover, the results show that the positive (negative) association between lagged (current period) cash flow and accruals is attenuated under the fair value approach. But the results for future cash flow tell a different story: by adopting the fair value approach, the positive association between future cash flow and accruals is strengthened, and the ability of accruals to predict future cash flow is significantly improved. The above findings suggest that the noisereduction role of accruals is attenuated under the fair value approach. With respect to the second role, we find that the use of fair value accelerate the recognition of economic gains.