Recent Experimental Explorations of Non-Classical Nucleation

Biao Jin,Zhaoming Liu,Ruikang Tang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d0ce00480d

IF: 3.756

2020-01-01

CrystEngComm

Abstract:This work provides a clearer picture for non-classical nucleation by revealing the presence of various intermediates using advanced characterization techniques.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

A New Perspective on Crystal Nucleation: A Classical View on Non-Classical Nucleation

Caiyun Jia,Zeyun Xiao,Jiang Zhao,P. Wang,Xiaoxia Fang,Haijun Zhang,Baohong Guan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.cgd.3c01078

IF: 4.01

2023-01-01

Crystal Growth & Design

Abstract:Nucleation is the key step of crystallization and is also the most difficult part to observe, as it evolves in very short temporal and spatial resolution. Conflicts between the features of classical nucleation theory and the observed nucleation behaviors inspire hypotheses of nonclassical nucleation mechanisms. In this Review, experimental evidence and molecular dynamics simulations involving the structure and formation mechanisms of a series of precursors and intermediate species, such as prenucleation clusters, liquid precursors, and amorphous precursors that in some cases coexist in a single system and successively transform into one another, are summarized to advance the understanding on the nucleation mechanisms of crystalline phases. What’s more, recent progress of building two-dimensional materials avoiding the nucleation barrier and accommodating nonclassical nucleation within the classical nucleation framework is outlined, which provides a new perspective on crystal nucleation: a classical view on nonclassical nucleation.
CFD Simulations and Experimental Verification on Nucleate Pool Boiling of Liquid Nitrogen

Zhang Xiaobin,Xiong Wei,Chen Jianye,Wang Yuchen,K. Tang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.phpro.2015.06.077

2015-01-01

Physics Procedia

Abstract:To explore the mechanism of nucleate pool boiling of cryogenic fluids, an experimental apparatus was built to conduct a visualization study and verify the CFD boiling model. Apart from the general measurements of the super-heat and heat flux, the influences of super-heat on bubble departure diameters were specially analyzed. Based on the observations, the whole nucleate boiling process from bubble formation to departure from the heated wall can be divided into three stages: low heat flux stage; transitional stage; fully developed nucleate boiling (FDNB) stage. CFD simulations with several existing correlations and the attained values from the experiments for the bubble diameter were finally conducted, and the results fitted well with the present experimental data.
Recent Developments in Computational Modelling of Nucleation in Phase Transformations

Lei Zhang,Weiqing Ren,Amit Samanta,Qiang Du

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/npjcompumats.2016.3

IF: 12.256

2016-01-01

npj Computational Materials

Abstract:Nucleation is one of the most common physical phenomena in physical, chemical, biological and materials sciences. Owing to the complex multiscale nature of various nucleation events and the difficulties in their direct experimental observation, development of effective computational methods and modeling approaches has become very important and is bringing new light to the study of this challenging subject. Our discussions in this manuscript provide a sampler of some newly developed numerical algorithms that are widely applicable to many nucleation and phase transformation problems. We first describe some recent progress on the design of efficient numerical methods for computing saddle points and minimum energy paths, and then illustrate their applications to the study of nucleation events associated with several different physical systems.
Atomic resolution liquid-cell transmission electron microscopy investigations of the dynamics of nanoparticles in ultrathin liquids.

Guomin Zhu,Yingying Jiang,Wei Huang,Hui Zhang,Fang Lin,Chuanhong Jin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/c3cc46667a

IF: 4.9

2013-01-01

Chemical Communications

Abstract:We proposed a highly reproducible method that enables atomic resolution transmission electron microscopy investigations of the dynamics of nanoparticles in liquids. An ultrathin liquid layer was established as a result of formation of bubbles that was initiated and tuned by beam radiation. The migration, aggregation and rotation of palladium nanoparticles were observed.
Resolving the early-stage nucleus structure and evolution in atomic systems

Yun Li,Hubin Luo,Fang Wang,Yinhang Yang,Cuimeng Song,J. Ping Liu,Izabela Szlufarska,Jian Zhang,Baogen Shen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.mattod.2024.06.002

IF: 24.2

2024-06-21

Materials Today

Abstract:Nucleation underpins a vast range of phase-transition phenomena in many disciplines. Critical to revealing nucleation thermodynamics and kinetics is the understanding of the nucleus structure at its early stage. Typically, it is assumed that nucleation is a sudden local structural transition from one phase to another. Here, we are able to access fundamental steps in the nucleation from amorphous phase by a combination of molecular simulations and experimental observation. We discover a surprising pathway of semicrystalline nucleation where one of the materials components crystallizes and another remains amorphous between the crystalline planes in the nuclei. The early-stage crystallization nucleus is robustly evidenced to undergo a gradual ordering and densification, originating from the presence of diffuse interfaces, and renders an ultralow interfacial energy that is orders of magnitude lower than those typically used in various formulations of nucleation. Our study provides critical information and insight for the early stages of nucleation that determine how crystallization is initiated and benefits controllable synthesis of materials.

materials science, multidisciplinary
Crystal Nucleation in an AlNiZr Metallic Liquid: Within and Beyond Classical Nucleation Theory

Fangzheng Chen,Kian Cole Dahlberg,Zohar Nussinov,K. F. Kelton

2023-11-21

Abstract:The Classical Nucleation Theory (CNT) has played a key role in crystal nucleation studies since the 19th century and has significantly advanced the understanding of nucleation. However, certain key assumptions of CNT, such as a compact and spherical nucleating cluster and the concept of individual diffusive jumps are questionable. The results of molecular dynamics (MD) studies of crystal nucleation in a Al20Ni60Zr20 metallic liquid demonstrate that the nucleating cluster is neither spherical nor compact. The seeding method was employed to determine the critical cluster size and nucleation parameters from CNT, which were then compared to those derived from the Mean First Passage Time (MFPT) method. While the CNT-based nucleation rate aligns well with experimental data from similar metallic liquids, the MFPT rate differs significantly. Further, contrary to the assumption of individual jumps for atoms to join the nucleating cluster, a cooperative mechanism of attachment or detachment is observed. This is accompanied by synchronized changes in the local potential energy. Similar cooperative motion also appeared in a non-classical nucleation process, particularly during the coalescence of nuclei.

Materials Science
Competing nucleation pathways in nanocrystal formation

Carlos R. Salazar,Akshay Krishna Ammothum Kandy,Jean Furstoss,Quentin Gromoff,Jacek Goniakowski,Julien Lam

2024-07-08

Abstract:Despite numerous efforts from numerical approaches to complement experimental measurements, several fundamental challenges have still hindered one's ability to truly provide an atomistic picture of the nucleation process in nanocrystals. Among them, our study resolves three obstacles: (1) Machine-learning force fields including long-range interactions able to capture the finesse of the underlying atomic interactions, (2) Data-driven characterization of the local ordering in a complex structural landscape associated with several crystal polymorphs and (3) Comparing results from a large range of temperatures using both brute-force and rare-event sampling. Altogether, our simulation strategy has allowed us to study zinc oxide crystallization from nano-droplet melt. Remarkably, our results show that different nucleation pathways compete depending on the investigated degree of supercooling.

Statistical Mechanics,Materials Science,Soft Condensed Matter,Chemical Physics,Computational Physics
Observing crystal nucleation in four dimensions using atomic electron tomography

Jihan Zhou,Yongsoo Yang,Yao Yang,Dennis S. Kim,Andrew Yuan,Xuezeng Tian,Colin Ophus,Fan Sun,Andreas K. Schmid,Michael Nathanson,Hendrik Heinz,Qi An,Hao Zeng,Peter Ercius,Jianwei Miao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-019-1317-x

IF: 64.8

2019-06-01

Nature

Abstract:Nucleation plays a critical role in many physical and biological phenomena that range from crystallization, melting and evaporation to the formation of clouds and the initiation of neurodegenerative diseases<a href="#ref-CR1">1</a>,<a href="#ref-CR2">2</a>,<a href="/articles/s41586-019-1317-x#ref-CR3">3</a>. However, nucleation is a challenging process to study experimentally, especially in its early stages, when several atoms or molecules start to form a new phase from a parent phase. A number of experimental and computational methods have been used to investigate nucleation processes<a href="#ref-CR4">4</a>,<a href="#ref-CR5">5</a>,<a href="#ref-CR6">6</a>,<a href="#ref-CR7">7</a>,<a href="#ref-CR8">8</a>,<a href="#ref-CR9">9</a>,<a href="#ref-CR10">10</a>,<a href="#ref-CR11">11</a>,<a href="#ref-CR12">12</a>,<a href="#ref-CR13">13</a>,<a href="#ref-CR14">14</a>,<a href="#ref-CR15">15</a>,<a href="#ref-CR16">16</a>,<a href="/articles/s41586-019-1317-x#ref-CR17">17</a>, but experimental determination of the three-dimensional atomic structure and the dynamics of early-stage nuclei has been unachievable. Here we use atomic electron tomography to study early-stage nucleation in four dimensions (that is, including time) at atomic resolution. Using FePt nanoparticles as a model system, we find that early-stage nuclei are irregularly shaped, each has a core of one to a few atoms with the maximum order parameter, and the order parameter gradient points from the core to the boundary of the nucleus. We capture the structure and dynamics of the same nuclei undergoing growth, fluctuation, dissolution, merging and/or division, which are regulated by the order parameter distribution and its gradient. These experimental observations are corroborated by molecular dynamics simulations of heterogeneous and homogeneous nucleation in liquid–solid phase transitions of Pt. Our experimental and molecular dynamics results indicate that a theory beyond classical nucleation theory<a href="/articles/s41586-019-1317-x#ref-CR1">1</a>,<a href="/articles/s41586-019-1317-x#ref-CR2">2</a>,<a href="/articles/s41586-019-1317-x#ref-CR18">18</a> is needed to describe early-stage nucleation at the atomic scale. We anticipate that the reported approach will open the door to the study of many fundamental problems in materials science, nanoscience, condensed matter physics and chemistry, such as phase transition, atomic diffusion, grain boundary dynamics, interface motion, defect dynamics and surface reconstruction with four-dimensional atomic resolution.

multidisciplinary sciences
Classical and Nonclassical Nucleation and Growth Mechanisms for Nanoparticle Formation.

Young-Shin Jun,Yaguang Zhu,Ying Wang,Deoukchen Ghim,Xuanhao Wu,Doyoon Kim,Haesung Jung

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-physchem-082720-100947

2022-01-01

Annual Review of Physical Chemistry

Abstract:All solid materials are created via nucleation. In this evolutionary process, nuclei form in solution or at interfaces, expand by monomeric growth and oriented attachment, and undergo phase transformation. Nucleation determines the location and size of nuclei, whereas growth controls the size, shape, and aggregation of newly formed nanoparticles. These physical properties of nanoparticles can affect their functionalities, reactivities, and porosities, as well as their fate and transport. Recent advances in nanoscale analytical technologies allow in situ real-time observations, enabling us to uncover the molecular nature of nuclei and the critical controlling factors for nucleation and growth. Although a single theory cannot yet fully explain such evolving processes, we have started to better understand how both classical andnonclassical theories can work together, and we have begun to recognize the importance of connecting these theories. This review discusses the recent convergence of knowledge about the nucleation and growth of nanoparticles.
Kinetic Pathways and Mechanisms of Two-Step Nucleation in Crystallization

Can Guo,Jincheng Wang,Junjie Li,Zhijun Wang,Sai Tang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.jpclett.6b02276

2016-12-15

Abstract:Crystallizations often pass through multiple intermediate structures before reaching the final state, such as amorphous precursors, polymorphs, or denser liquid droplets. However, the atomistic pathways from these metastable phases to final crystals still remain unclear. Here, we investigated the structure evolution process from liquid to final crystals of homogeneous nucleation by atomic-scale simulations and analyzed the intrinsic mechanisms that influence the nucleation pathways. Three different pathways of two-step nucleation were found by visualizing the precursors' evolutions, and some new micromechanisms of two-step nucleation are revealed. We suggest that the solid bond fluctuations can trigger the formation of intermediate precursors, while the precursors' packing density dominates the structural transformation pathways from intermediate phases to crystals. These findings not only shed light on the mechanisms of nucleation but also provide guidance for future refinements of two-step nucleation theory.
A new approach to solid-state nucleation in kinetically-constrained systems

Christopher Hutchinson,Yves Brechet

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.actamat.2024.120521

IF: 9.4

2024-11-06

Acta Materialia

Abstract:Nucleation is the first step of the phase transformations that we use to control the microstructures of engineering materials. The starting point for questions of nucleation is usually Classical Nucleation Theory (CNT) but for solid-state nucleation at low temperatures where atomic mobility is limited, such as in engineering alloys, CNT has not been very successful is quantitatively predicting nucleation. A strong assumption of CNT is that all thermally-induced stochastic fluctuations, no matter how far their compositions lie from the bulk alloy composition, are possible and that they become nuclei when a critical size determined from thermodynamics is reached.Here we present a new and complementary model for solid-state nucleation. We consider the other extreme where atomic mobility is limited and thermally-induced stochastic clusters cannot form in the time scale relevant for a nucleation event. Instead, we consider the geometric clusters that are a statistical feature of any solution as the origin of the nuclei and present a simple model for the number of nuclei and their rate of 'activation'. This new 'geometric cluster' model is shown to be able to successfully predict the competition in phase nucleation during the crystallization of a series of Al-Ni-Y metallic glass, predict the solvent trapping that is increasingly seen in solid-state nucleation and predict the peak number density of precipitates observed in Cu-Co and Fe-Cu alloys.

materials science, multidisciplinary,metallurgy & metallurgical engineering
Nanodroplets of Metal Carbonate Conform to Critical Nuclei of Classical Nucleation Theory

Shu Li Li,Jerry Chun Chung Chan,Lin Yi-Tan,His-Ching Tseng,Yuan-Jia Fan,Shing-Jong Huang,Eric Chung-Yuen Yuan,Chun-Yi David Lu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.26434/chemrxiv-2024-16j0s

2024-10-09

Abstract:Mineral nucleation is a fundamental process of paramount importance to various fields, including geology, biomineralization, and industrial manufacturing. Recently, studies on the biominerals of calcium carbonate and phosphate have revealed the presence of a dense liquid phase prior to the formation of an amorphous solid phase. However, there is vigorous debate on whether the nucleation of calcium carbonate clusters can be adequately described by the classical nucleation theory (CNT) or if one must turn to the non-classical nucleation theory. Here, we show that liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS) occurs in a non-aqueous solution where magnesium and calcium carbonates are dissolved in ethanol with excess triethylamine. The nanodroplets can be kinetically trapped by triethylamine. The size and number of the nanodroplets, in the vicinity of critical nuclei, can be adequately described within the framework of CNT. We found that bicarbonate-like species formed by triethylamine, CO2, and ethanol molecules are in constant exchange with sizable carbonate clusters. Our results demonstrate that the concepts of critical nuclei and the energy barrier of nucleation are indeed physically relevant. We argue that nanodroplets comprising highly solvated carbonate clusters are the key entities in the nucleation process, which falls within the realm of CNT.

Chemistry
Imaging the Homogeneous Nucleation During the Melting of Superheated Colloidal Crystals

Ziren Wang,Feng Wang,Yi Peng,Zhongyu Zheng,Yilong Han

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1224763

2012-01-01

Abstract:The nucleation process is crucial to many phase transitions, but its kinetics are difficult to predict and measure. We superheated and melted the interior of thermal-sensitive colloidal crystals and investigated by means of video microscopy the homogeneous melting at single-particle resolution. The observed nucleation precursor was local particle-exchange loops surrounded by particles with large displacement amplitudes rather than any defects. The critical size, incubation time, and shape and size evolutions of the nucleus were measured. They deviate from the classical nucleation theory under strong superheating, mainly because of the coalescence of nuclei. The superheat limit agrees with the measured Born and Lindemann instabilities.
In situ TEM investigation of nucleation and crystallization of hybrid bismuth nanodiamonds

Sihan Ma,Yipeng Li,Dewang Cui,Gang Yang,Lin Wang,Guang Ran

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3nr01338c

IF: 6.7

2023-04-27

Nanoscale

Abstract:Despite great progress in the non-classical homogeneous nucleation and crystallization theory, the heterogeneous processes of atomic nucleation and crystallization remain poorly understood. Abundant theories and experiments have demonstrated the detailed dynamics of homogeneous nucleation; however, intensive dynamic investigations on heterogeneous nucleation are still rare. In this work, in situ transmission electron microscopy (TEM) at the atomic scale was carried out with temporal resolution for heterogeneous nucleation and crystallization. The results show a reversible amorphous to crystal phase transformation that is manipulated by the size threshold effect. Moreover, the two growth pathways of Bi particles can be mainly assigned to the atomic adsorption expansion in the amorphous state and effective fusion in the crystal contact process. These interesting findings, based on a real dynamic imaging system, strongly enrich and improve our understanding of the dynamic mechanisms in the non-classical heterogeneous nucleation and crystallization theory, providing insights into designing innovative materials with controlled microstructures and desired physicochemical properties.

materials science, multidisciplinary,physics, applied,nanoscience & nanotechnology,chemistry
Alternative Theory of Nucleation in Super-Cooled Liquids

Laurent-Charles Valdès,Frédéric Affouard

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1803.03454

2018-03-09

Statistical Mechanics

Abstract:Having discovered a dimension mistake in two key formulas of the Classical Nucleation Theory (CNT) but wishing to remain in the style of this theory, we propose to approach nucleation on the basis of the Zeldovich unsteady rate formula, with the dimensionally correct expressions for the nucleation rate and time constant. Beforehand, the problematic status - physical size or simple parameter - of interfacial tension in CNT was audited. The results of numerical simulations on nucleation in various attraction but fixed repulsion conditions of the interaction potential have led us to motivate, then establish, a thermal evolution law for interfacial tension. Taking into account a scale dependance in the vicinity of absolute zero in temperature, this law is of stretched Arrhenius type. It works with the Zeldovich formula, notably for the determination of adjusting parameters. A remarkably accurate adjusting of this law to the numerical simulations has been obtained and led us to exhibit melting crystal volume as a measure of potential attractivity. It should allow accurate forecasts of instantaneous nucleation rate and average nucleation duration in physical or numerical super-cooled monoatomic liquids.
A microscopic approach to crystallization: challenging the classical/non-classical dichotomy

James F. Lutsko,Cédric Schoonen

2024-06-25

Abstract:Recently, it was shown that a theoretical description of nucleation based on fluctuating hydrodynamics and classical density functional theory can be used to determine non-classical nucleation pathways for crystallization (Lutsko, Sci. Adv. 5, eaav7399 (2019)). The advantage of the approach is that it is free of any assumptions regarding order parameters and that requires no input other than molecular interaction potentials. We now extend this fundamental framework so as to describe the dynamics of non-classical nucleation. We use it to study the nucleation of both droplets and crystalline solids from a low-concentration solution of colloidal particles using two different interaction potentials. We find that the nucleation pathways of both droplets and crystals are remarkably similar at the early stages of nucleation until they diverge due to a rapid ordering along the solid pathways in line with the paradigm of "non-classical" crystallization. We compute the unstable modes at the critical clusters and find that despite the non-classical nature of solid nucleation, the size of the nucleating clusters remains the principle order parameter in all cases supporting a "classical" description of the {\it dynamics} of crystallization. We show that nucleation rates can be extracted from our formalism in a systematic way. Our results suggest that in some cases, despite the non-classical nature of the nucleation pathways, classical nucleation theory can give reasonable results for solids but that there are circumstances where it may fail. This contributes a nuanced perspective to recent experimental and simulation work suggesting that important aspects of crystal nucleation can be described within a classical framework.

Chemical Physics,Soft Condensed Matter
Non-classical pathways of crystallization in colloidal systems

John Russo,Hajime Tanaka

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1557/mrs.2016.84

2016-11-22

Abstract:Colloidal systems offer the ideal conditions to study the nucleation process, both from an experimental viewpoint, due to their relative large size and long time-scales, and from a modeling point of view, due to the tunability of their interactions. Here we review some recent works that study the process of colloidal crystallization from a microscopic perspective. We focus in particular on non-classical pathways to nucleation where the appearance of the solid crystals involves fluctuations of two (or more) order parameters. We interpret the non-classical behavior as a decoupling of positional and orientational symmetry breaking. We then consider how the nucleation pathway determines which polymorph is selected upon nucleation from the melt. Moreover we show how the study of nucleation pathways not only sheds new light on the microscopic mechanism of nucleation, but also provides important information regarding its avoidance, thus suggesting a deep link between crystallization and vitrification.

Soft Condensed Matter,Materials Science,Statistical Mechanics
Non-clasical Nucleation in Supercooled Nickel

F. J. Cherne,M. I. Baskes,R. B. Schwarz,S. G. Srinivasan,W. Klein

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.cond-mat/0302491

2003-02-24

Materials Science

Abstract:The dynamics of homogeneous nucleation and growth of crystalline nickel from the super-cooled melt is examined during rapid quenching using molecular dynamics and a modified embedded atom method potential. The character of the critical nuclei of the crystallization transition is examined using common neighbor analysis and visualization. At nucleation the saddle point droplet consists of randomly stacked planar structures with an in plane triangular order. These results are consistent with previous theoretical results that predict that the nucleation process in some metals is non-classical due to the presence of long-range forces and a spinodal.
A Generalized Nucleation Theory for Ice Crystallization

Maodong Li,Yupeng Huang,Yijie Xia,Dechin Chen,Cheng Fan,Lijiang Yang,Yi Qin Gao,Yi Isaac Yang

2024-11-19

Abstract:Despite the simplicity of the water molecule, the kinetics of ice nucleation under natural conditions can be complex. We investigated spontaneously grown ice nuclei using all-atom molecular dynamics simulations and found significant differences between the kinetics of ice formation through spontaneously formed and ideal nuclei. Since classical nucleation theory can only provide a good description of ice nucleation in ideal conditions, we propose a generalized nucleation theory that can better characterize the kinetics of ice crystal nucleation in general conditions. This study provides an explanation on why previous experimental and computational studies have yielded widely varying critical nucleation sizes.

Soft Condensed Matter,Chemical Physics

Recent Experimental Explorations of Non-Classical Nucleation

A New Perspective on Crystal Nucleation: A Classical View on Non-Classical Nucleation

CFD Simulations and Experimental Verification on Nucleate Pool Boiling of Liquid Nitrogen

Recent Developments in Computational Modelling of Nucleation in Phase Transformations

Atomic resolution liquid-cell transmission electron microscopy investigations of the dynamics of nanoparticles in ultrathin liquids.

Resolving the early-stage nucleus structure and evolution in atomic systems

Crystal Nucleation in an AlNiZr Metallic Liquid: Within and Beyond Classical Nucleation Theory

Competing nucleation pathways in nanocrystal formation

Observing crystal nucleation in four dimensions using atomic electron tomography

Classical and Nonclassical Nucleation and Growth Mechanisms for Nanoparticle Formation.

Kinetic Pathways and Mechanisms of Two-Step Nucleation in Crystallization

A new approach to solid-state nucleation in kinetically-constrained systems

Nanodroplets of Metal Carbonate Conform to Critical Nuclei of Classical Nucleation Theory

Imaging the Homogeneous Nucleation During the Melting of Superheated Colloidal Crystals

In situ TEM investigation of nucleation and crystallization of hybrid bismuth nanodiamonds

Alternative Theory of Nucleation in Super-Cooled Liquids

A microscopic approach to crystallization: challenging the classical/non-classical dichotomy

Non-classical pathways of crystallization in colloidal systems

Non-clasical Nucleation in Supercooled Nickel

A Generalized Nucleation Theory for Ice Crystallization