Abstract:A probabilistic assessment is performed using different seismic fragility analysis approaches for structures under non-stationary stochastic ground motions. Four commonly used probabilistic seismic fragility analysis (PSFA) approaches are adopted, which are least squares regression (LSR), maximum likelihood estimation (MLE), kernel density estimation (KDE) and Monte Carlo simulation (MCS). The principles of the four PSFA approaches are first introduced, and the theories of non-stationary stochastic acceleration time series are introduced in light of the spectral representation of random functions. Then an analytical procedure of different PSFA approaches is constructed for structures under non-stationary stochastic motions. After that a case study is carried out to analyze the results of the four PSFA approaches. The demand distributions of univariate random variable under certain intensity measure levels are discussed, and multiple fragility curves under different limit states for all the approaches are compared. In general, the MCS approach is set as the benchmark to verify the effectiveness of other approaches, but it is computationally consuming. The non-parametric KDE approach is recommended to estimate the univariate distribution under specified IM levels, because it can reflect the real distribution characteristics with combined efficiency and accuracy. For the seismic fragility under different limit states, the LSR approach is suitable for efficient data processing and general trend assessment, at the expense of accuracy. The MLE approach indicates a better applicability under a smaller response threshold and slighter damage conditions, while the KDE approach shows a better applicability under a larger response threshold and severer damage conditions. The paper compares the accuracy and applicability of various PSFA approaches under multiple conditions, and provides a basis to link probabilistic hazard and risk analyses for performance assessment in the future research.

Fragility Estimates for High-Rise Buildings with Outrigger Systems under Seismic and Wind Loads

Kriging Metamodels for the Dynamic Response of High-Rise Buildings with Outrigger Systems and Fragility Estimates for Seismic and Wind Loads

Probabilistic Seismic Demand Models and Life-Cycle Fragility Estimates for High-Rise Buildings

Hybrid AI-Bayesian-based Demand Models and Fragility Estimates for Tall Buildings Against Multi-Hazard of Earthquakes and Winds

Damage Probability Analysis of a High-Rise Building Against Wind Excitation with Recorded Field Data and Direction Effect

Component damage‐based seismic fragility analysis of high‐rise building with transfer structure

Hybrid Bayesian-Copula-based damage probability estimation for steel-concrete composite tall buildings under concurrent seismic and wind loads

Multihazard Fragility Assessment of Steel‐concrete Composite Frame Structures with Buckling‐restrained Braces Subjected to Combined Earthquake and Wind

Probabilistic demand models and fragilities for reinforced concrete frame structures subject to mainshock-aftershock sequences

Copula-based Seismic Fragility Assessment of Base-Isolated Structures under Near-Fault Forward-Directivity Ground Motions

Damage Risk Assessment of a High-Rise Building Against Multihazard of Earthquake and Strong Wind with Recorded Data

Bayesian-based Seismic Resilience Assessment for High-Rise Buildings with the Uncertainty in Various Variables

Fragility Analysis Method for Vertically Irregular Reinforced Concrete Frame Structures

Multi‐hazard fragility assessment of monopile offshore wind turbines under earthquake, wind and wave loads

Seismic Fragility Estimation Through Real-Time Hybrid Simulation and Surrogate-Based Multi-Fidelity Monte Carlo Predictor

Seismic demand and capacity models, and fragility estimates for underground structures considering spatially varying soil properties

Seismic fragility analysis of slopes based on large-scale shaking table model tests

Multivariable fragility surfaces for earthquake-induced damage assessment of buildings integrating structural features

Probabilistic Seismic Demand and Capacity Models and Fragility Curves for Reticulated Structures under Far-Field Ground Motions

Assessment of various seismic fragility analysis approaches for structures excited by non-stationary stochastic ground motions

Optimal Outrigger Locations and Damping Parameters for Single-Outrigger Systems Considering Earthquake and Wind Excitations