The Origins of the Engels Debate

Kaan Kangal
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-34335-4_3
2020-01-01
Abstract:This chapter traces out the origins of the Engels debate. It goes back to the earlier critical readings of Hegel. It proposes that before Engels’ dialectics was singled out and attacked by what is sometimes termed ‘Western Marxism’, there was a Hegel(-Marx) debate that clustered largely around the problematic relation between logic and reality (nature/spirit) and a crucial component of it (contradiction). Anyone (including Marx) who claimed Hegel’s dialectics, critically or otherwise, faced the same charges brought against Hegel. Later on, Russian, German and Austrian socialists jointly shaped a debate and voiced various opinions from a wholesale rejection to a full approval of dialectics. As the chronicle of the debate testifies, there was neither an East-West division that can clearly demarcate one single Marxism, ‘Western’ or ‘Eastern’, as an integrated tradition, nor a straight line between Engels and Stalin, linking both figures by immediate causality.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?