Transfusion Rate for 300 Consecutive Living Donor Liver Transplantations
Lei JY,Yan LN
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1097/tp.0b013e318274ab4a
2012-01-01
Transplantation
Abstract:With great interest, we read the paper “Transfusion Rate for 500 Consecutive Liver Transplantations: Experience of One Liver Transplantation Center” by L. Massicotte et al., published in Transplantation. (1) We would like to make the following comments. Of the total of 500 recipients, 20.4% of the patients received blood products including but not limited to red blood cells, plasma, and platelets. A mean of 1.3 with a standard deviation (SD) of 0.5 unit red blood cells transfusions were performed transfused in all the cases of orthotopic liver transplantation (OLT). A multivariate logistic regression indicated that the starting Hb value and the phlebotomy showed a significant regression with the OLT without transfusion. In contrast, the severity of the disease did not show a significant relationship. The report was focused on the transfusion rate of the OLT. Hence, we would like to discuss some of our own unpublished data on the subject. We have reviewed 300 consecutive cases of living donor liver transplants, performed at our center between March 2002 and June 2012. The volume of living donor liver transplantation in our center was the largest in mainland China, being equivalent to almost one quarter of the total number of cases. The average intraoperative blood loss was 732.5±521.4 ml in 300 patients. Because of the incidence of blood loss, an intraoperative blood transfusion was indicated in 220 (73.3%) of the cases. In 123 (41%) of these cases, autologous blood was used. Allogeneic and autologous blood transfusions were used in 32 (10.7%) of the cases. For the 97 patients (32.3%) who were transfused with allogeneic blood, the mean allogeneic transfused RBC and plasma was 2.8 units (SD, ±1.4 units) and 345.4 ml (SD, ±311.4 ml), respectively. Fifteen patients needed a platelet transfusion with a mean of 1.3 units (SD, ±0.4 units). Thirty-six of the patients accepted a cryoprecipitate transfusion with a mean of 4.5 units (SD, ±1.3 units). For the 155 patients (51.7%) who received autologous blood transfusions, the mean volume of autologous whole blood transfusion was 345.3 ml (SD, ±231.8 ml). After the surgery, a postoperative blood transfusion was indicated in 70 cases (23.3%), with a mean of 1.7 units (SD, ±1.6 units) of RBC and a mean of 215.6 ml (SD, ±120.6 ml) of plasma. Moreover, a multivariate logistic regression analysis was used to determine the main predictors for the indication of intraoperative blood transfusions. Several variables were studied, including the recipient’s age, body mass index, type of disease, preoperative platelet count and blood clotting, history of previous abdominal surgery, Hb value, severity of recipient’s disease, operative time, and other 12 preoperative variables. From the results of this analysis, it was concluded that a preoperative lower Hb value; the severity of the disease in the recipient, as assessed by the MELD score; and a previous history of abdominal surgery showed a significant relationship with the indication of an intraoperative transfusion in cases of living donor liver transplantation. Massicotte et al. reported an increased volume of blood loss (mean±SD, 1,051±940 ml vs 732.5±521.4 ml) but less allogeneic blood transfusions (20.4% vs 36%). The main factor related to these differences seems to be the lower hemoglobin levels and platelet counts in the cases of cirrhosis and splenomegaly, which are significantly more prevalent in China. From the 300 patients, which were included in the study group at our center, there were 259 cases (86.3%) of liver cirrhosis. The mean MELD score in these patients was 13.9 (SD=9.2). Thus, when the preoperative liver function is more affected, the cirrhosis and splenomegaly can lead to a low platelet count with subsequent blood coagulation disorders. Furthermore, the patients with preoperative history of an abdominal surgery can also be at risk for increased blood loss, requiring more blood transfusions. The most common abdominal surgery was a splenectomy and portalazygous disconnection followed by a hepatectomy. A history of an abdominal surgery can lead to an increased blood loss because of the intra-abdominal adhesions; hence, more blood transfusions would be indicated. As compared with the paper by Massicotte et al., the number of allogeneic and autologous transfusions has been discussed. The indication of postoperative blood transfusions was also analyzed. The most common factors related to the postoperative blood transfusions were the postoperative intra-abdominal bleeding, the preoperative lower value of Hb, and a larger volume of intraoperative blood loss. In summary, a preoperative lower value of Hb; the severity of the disease in the recipients, as assessed by the MELD score; and the history of abdominal surgery showed a significant relationship with the indication of transfusions in cases of living donor liver transplantation. Lei JY Yan LN Liver Transplantation Center West China Hospital of Sichuan University Chengdu, China