Effects of Different Tasks and Frequencies on the Emotional Valence Effect of Chinese Characters
Fan Ning,Song Yaowu,Peng Danling
2012-01-01
Abstract:The affective(positive or negative) information of emotion words can accelerate the words processing compared with the neutral words.Some research revealed that the emotional valence effect occurred under either conscious or subliminal conditions.However,whether the emotional valence effect is an automatic procedure or an interactive outcome between the task paradigm and the stimulus property is still unclear.The present study used semantic and phonological tasks to explore the influence of frequency on the emotional valence effect when people read Chinese characters.After normalization,two experiments applied the same stimuli sets of Chinese characters,which had been strictly matched in terms of their frequency,stroke number,radical number,concrete level,and emotional arousal level in all six conditions.Experiment 1 used the semantic category decision task,2(high frequency vs.low frequency) × 3(negative/neutral/positive) within-subjects design.The participants were 30 college students with one subject excluded because his total error rate was too high(> 10%).They were asked to decide whether the target Chinese character was a living being(e.g.tiger,horse,grass) or not by pressing a keyboard button.Different from the semantic processing,Experiment 2 applied the rhyming decision task.Another 30 college students participated in this task.They made responses according to the target characters' pronunciation.If the syllable contained /ong/(e.g./song4/,/qiong2/,/nong2/),they were to press the "yes" button,otherwise press "no".The two experiments shared the same design,stimuli and program.A computer automatically recorded the subject's reaction time and error rate with E-prime 1.1.The multivariate analysis of variance results showed that when the participants were asked to perform the semantic task,the negative valence accelerated the characters' semantic access in both high and low frequency conditions(ps <.05).There was no significant interaction between frequency and emotional valence(p>.05).At the same time,the positive valence speeded up the low-frequency characters only(p <.05),but not the high-frequency ones(p >.05).The influence of positive valence was weaker than that of negative valence.However,there was a significant interaction between emotional valence and frequency in the phonological task(p <.001).The simple main effect showed that emotional valence mainly impacted on the low-frequency characters' phonological access(p <.001),and didn't affect the high-frequency ones(p >.05).In the low-frequency condition,the RTs of negative(p <.01) and positive(p <.001) characters were shorter than those of the neutral ones.The integration of two experiments supports the biased competition model.In summary,the results suggest that the emotional information modulates the semantic and phonological access during reading characters.Moreover,the modulation effect is influenced by the task-oriented and the familiarity of material.Emotional valence can accelerate the low-frequency characters' phonological and semantic access,but not the high-frequency characters' phonological access.However,in a semantic task,even the high-frequency characters' processing can be affected by negative valence.