Calculation of oxygen consumption and carbon dioxide production during anesthesia.
G. Gronert
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1213/00000539-199411000-00038
1994-11-01
Abstract:Therefore, the correlation analysis reported by Nakajima et al. is inappropriate. It does not demonstrate the clinical usefulness of their data, whereas the bias and precision analysis that they performed (only in the two principal calibrated groups) does (2). Unfortunately, they have not provided any other subgroup bias analysis but have based their discussion on absolute values and comparisons of the correlation coefficients. Nevertheless, this approach should have been helpful in looking for an explanation for the results pointed out by their sole bias analysis (mean difference between catheter reading and CO-oximeter value), which showed a constant tendency of the catheter oximeter to overestimate Sjo, about 2%-3% under the in vitro calibration (considering the CO-oximeter measurement as a reference). In particular, despite a baseline overestimation, blood temperature seemed to exert an additional influence on the bias, since its nadir was observed at the hypothermic stage of the surgical procedure. Temperature Influence on Measurements. These findings require a second comment about the influence of temperature in the interpretation of Sjo, values. The spectroscopic techniques (transmission or reflectance) provide a direct and accurate measurement of the hemoglobin oxygen saturation. Nevertheless, the oxygen saturation depends on the conditions in which the measurement is performed (3). Effectively, hemoglobin oxygen saturation continuously results from an equilibrium between hemoglobin and 0, tension. Hemoglobin affinity for oxygen depends on several variables, including temperature, CO, partial tension, pH, and erythrocyte 2,3-diphosphoglycerate concentration (4). Although the last three probably remain quite constant if the delay between blood withdrawal and transmission spectroscopic measurement is short, temperature rapidly equilibrates with ambient temperature. For this reason, most laboratory oximeters can control temperature to allow a direct saturation measurement in restored physiologic conditions (usually at 37°C). Severinghaus (5) showed that, when this correction is not performed, hypothennia increases hemoglobin oxygen saturation as if there were a variation in Po,, as expressed in the following formula: