Journals As Retention Mechanisms of Scientific Growth

Loet Leydesdorff

2008-01-01

Abstract:Professor Loet Leydesdorff has spent the last 20 years developing an idea first posed by Derek de Solla Price in 1961. He asks whether the aggregated citation relations among journals can be used to study clusters of journals as representations of the intellectual organization of the sciences.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

"Structuration" by Intellectual Organization: The Configuration of Knowledge in Relations among Structural Components in Networks of Science

Loet Leydesdorff

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1012.5735

2011-05-01

Abstract:Using aggregated journal-journal citation networks, the measurement of the knowledge base in empirical systems is factor-analyzed in two cases of interdisciplinary developments during the period 1995-2005: (i) the development of nanotechnology in the natural sciences and (ii) the development of communication studies as an interdiscipline between social psychology and political science. The results are compared with a case of stable development: the citation networks of core journals in chemistry. These citation networks are intellectually organized by networks of expectations in the knowledge base at the specialty (that is, above-journal) level. This "structuration" of structural components (over time) can be measured as configurational information. The latter is compared with the Shannon-type information generated in the interactions among structural components: the difference between these two measures provides us with a measure for the redundancy generated by the specification of a model in the knowledge base of the system. This knowledge base incurs (against the entropy law) to variable extents on the knowledge infrastructures provided by the observable networks of relations.

Digital Libraries,Adaptation and Self-Organizing Systems,Physics and Society
Bibliometrics/Citation networks

Loet Leydesdorff

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1502.06378

2015-02-23

Abstract:In addition to shaping social networks, for example, in terms of co-authorship relations, scientific communications induce and reproduce cognitive structures. Scientific literature is intellectually organized in terms of disciplines and specialties; these structures are reproduced and networked reflexively by making references to the authors, concepts and texts embedded in these literatures. The concept of a cognitive structure was introduced in social network analysis (SNA) in 1987 by David Krackhardt, but the focus in SNA has hitherto been on cognition as a psychological attribute of human agency. In bibliometrics, and in science and technology studies (STS) more generally, socio-cognitive structures refer to intellectual organization at the supra-individual level. This intellectual organization emerges and is reproduced by the collectives of authors who are organized not only in terms of inter-personal relations, but also more abstractly in terms of codes of communication that are field-specific. Citations can serve as indicators of this codification process.

Digital Libraries
Discontinuities in Citation Relations among Journals: Self-organized Criticality as a Model of Scientific Revolutions and Change

Loet Leydesdorff,Caroline S. Wagner,Lutz Bornmann

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1803.00554

2018-03-02

Abstract:Using three-year moving averages of the complete Journal Citation Reports 1994-2016 of the Science Citation Index and the Social Sciences Citation Index (combined), we analyze links between citing and cited journals in terms of (1) whether discontinuities among the networks of consecutive years have occurred; (2) are these discontinuities relatively isolated or networked? (3) Can these discontinuities be used as indicators of novelty, change, and innovation in the sciences? We examine each of the N2 links among the N journals across the years. We find power-laws for the top 10,000 instances of change, which we suggest interpreting in terms of "self-organized criticality": co-evolutions of avalanches in aggregated citation relations and meta-stable states in the knowledge base can be expected to drive the sciences towards the edges of chaos. The flux of journal-journal citations in new manuscripts may generate an avalanche in the meta-stable networks, but one can expect the effects to remain local (for example, within a specialty). The avalanches can be of any size; they reorient the relevant citation environments by inducing a rewrite of history in the affected partitions.

Digital Libraries
“ Structuration ” by Intellectual Organization : The Configuration of Knowledge in Relations among Scientific Texts

Loet Leydesdorff

2009-01-01

Abstract:Using aggregated journal-journal citation networks, the measurement of anticipation in empirical systems is examined in two cases of interdisciplinary developments during the period 1995-2005: (i) the development of nanotechnology in the natural sciences and (ii) the development of communication studies as an interdiscipline between social psychology and political science. The results are compared with a case of stable development: the citation networks of core journals in chemistry. The textual networks are intellectually organized by networks of expectations in the knowledge base at the specialty (that is, above-journal) level. This “structuration” of structural components in the observable networks can be measured as configurational information. The latter can be compared with the Shannon-type information generated in the interactions among structural components: the difference between these two measures provides us with a redundancy generated by the specification of a model in the knowledge base of the system. The knowledge base incurs to variable extents on the knowledge infrastructures provided by the networks of exchange relations.
A bibliometric perspective on the academic contributions of Loet Leydesdorff

Wenjing Xiong,Ping Zhou

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3145/epi.2023.dic.06

2023-12-29

El Profesional de la información

Abstract:The purpose of this paper is to commemorate the late scholar Loet Leydesdorff for his great academic contribution on the basis of data from Web of Science. In the span of more than 40 years, he had 526 publications, with the years 2004-2021 being the most productive (394 publications). His international collaborations spread widely across 36 countries, with Germany, the USA, the UK, China, Russia, and South Korea being the most significant. His most frequent collaboration partners included Lutz Bornmann (Germany), Staša Milojević (USA), Caroline Wagner (USA), Henry Etzkowitz (USA), Jonathan Adams (UK), Ronald Rousseau (Belgium), and Ping Zhou (China). With a broad and deep knowledge background, Leydesdorff’s research extended across multiple disciplines and fields, but he was most active in library and information science and computer science. He made profound contributions to the study of bibliometrics, innovation systems (the Triple Helix model), and communications. Leydesdorff had a remarkable and extensive citation impact, with citations in 221 WoS subject categories from 120 countries. His publications in 1996, 1998, 2000, 2005, 2006, and 2012 are highly cited, and those on university-industry-government relations (the Triple Helix model) are the most cited.

information science & library science,communication
Indicators of Structural Change in the Dynamics of Science: Entropy Statistics of the SCI Journal Citation Reports

Loet Leydesdorff

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.0911.3093

2009-11-17

Abstract:Can change in citation patterns among journals be used as an indicator of structural change in the organization of the sciences? Aggregated journal-journal citations for 1999 are compared with similar data in the Journal Citation Reports 1998 of the Science Citation Index. In addition to indicating local change, probabilistic entropy measures enable us to analyze changes in distributions at different levels of aggregation. The results of various statistics are discussed and compared by elaborating the journal-journal mappings. The relevance of this indicator for science and technology policies is further specified.

Digital Libraries,Physics and Society
The Development of Frames of References.

L. Leydesdorff

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/bf02017235

IF: 3.801

1986-01-01

Scientometrics

Abstract:Measurement of the effectiveness of science policies is analyzed as a multi-level problem. Journal-journal citations are discussed as a potential candidate for a domain beyond the control of policy-makers and authors or research groups and therefore may function as a relatively stable and easily accessible baseline for the ‘calibration’ of outputs and outcomes of science policy. A method is developed, usingSCPsJCRs which is then applied to the two cases of water pollution and humanisation of labor. This method can also be used as a simple indicator for the development of journal-journal citation patterns over time.
Tracing “interdisciplinarity” using time series of journal maps: The visualization and dynamic animation of journal-journal citation relations

Loet Leydesdorff

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/meet.2008.1450450209

2008-01-01

Abstract:Structural change—e.g., interdisciplinary development—is often an objective of government interventions in science and technology. However, the dynamic analysis of structural change in the organization of the sciences requires methodologically the integration of multivariate and time-series analysis. Recent developments in multidimensional scaling (MDS) enable us to distinguish the stress originating in each time-slice from the stress originating from the sequencing of time-slices, and thus to locally optimize the trade-offs between these two sources of variance in the animation. Furthermore, visualization programs like Pajek and Visone allow us to show not only the positions of the nodes, but also their relational attributes like betweenness centrality. Betweenness centrality in the vector space can be considered as an indicator of interdisciplinarity. Using this indicator, the dynamics of the citation impact environments of the journals Cognitive Science, Social Networks, and Nanotechnology are animated and assessed in terms of interdisciplinarity among the disciplines involved.
Dynamic and Evolutionary Updates of Classificatory Schemes in Scientific Journal Structures

L Leydesdorff

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/asi.10144

2002-01-01

Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology

Abstract:Can the inclusion of new journals in the Science Citation index be used for the indication of structural change in the database, and how can this change be compared with reorganizations of relations among previously included journals? Change in the number of journals (n) is distinguished from change in the number of journal categories (m). Although the number of journals can be considered as a given at each moment in time, the number of journal categories is based on a reconstruction that is time-stamped ex post. The reflexive reconstruction is in need of an update when new information becomes available in a next year. Implications of this shift towards an evolutionary perspective are specified.
The Journal of Communication and the Field of Communication Studies: Mapping Scientific Communication Online

Loet Leydesdorff

2008-01-01

Abstract:In this study, the authors have three objectives: 1. To make aggregated journal-journal citation networks based on the Journal Citation Reports 2004 of the Science Citation Index (5968 journals) and the Social Science Citation Index (1712 journals) accessible online from the perspective of any of these journals. The results are available at http://www.leydesdorff.net/jcr04 as input-files for the visualization program Pajek. The user is thus able to analyze the citation environment of a scientific journal, for example, in terms of core groups and peripheries. 2. To study the journal structure of communication studies as a discipline using the Journal of Communication as an example. Communication studies can be considered as a single field from the perspective of "being cited," but it is divided into two communities who reconstruct the field differently by making references. 3. To replace the notion of a global impact factor with that of a local impact factor relative to a journal's citation environment. The local impact of a journal in its citation environment can be defined as its share of the total citations in this environments. The vertical size of the nodes is varied proportionally to this citation impact; the horizontal axis of each node will be used to provide the same information after correction for within-journal (self-)citations.
Can Networks Of Journal-Journal Citations Be Used As Indicators Of Change In The Social Sciences?

Loet Leydesdorff

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1108/00220410310458028

2003-01-01

Journal of Documentation

Abstract:Aggregated journal-journal citations can be used for mapping the intellectual organization of the sciences in terms of specialties because the latter can be considered as interreading communities. Can the journal-journal citations also be used as early indicators of change by comparing the files for two subsequent years? Probabilistic entropy measures enable us to analyze changes in large datasets at different levels of aggregation and in considerable detail Compares journal Citation Reports of the Social Science Citation Index for 1999 with similar data for 1998 and analyzes the differences using these measures. Compares the various indicators with similar developments in the Science Citation Index. Specialty formation seems a more important mechaanis in the development of the social sciences than in the natural and life sciences, but the developments in the social sciences are volatile. The use of aggregate statistics based on the Science Citation Index is ill-advised in the case of the social sciences because of structural differences in the underlying dynamics.
The Development of the Journal Environment of Leonardo

Alkım Almila Akdağ Salah,Loet Leydesdorff

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1162/leon_a_00346

2012-01-01

Leonardo

Abstract:The authors present animations based on the aggregated journal-journal citations of Leonardo during the period 1974–2008. Leonardo is mainly cited by journals outside the arts domain for cultural reasons, for example, in neuropsychology and physics. Articles in Leonardo itself cite a large number of journals, but with a focus on the arts. Animations at this level of aggregation enable us to show the history of the journal from a network perspective.
The Time Dimension of Science: Connecting the Past to the Future

Yian Yin,Dashun Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.joi.2017.04.002

2017-04-19

Abstract:A central question in science of science concerns how time affects citations. Despite the long-standing interests and its broad impact, we lack systematic answers to this simple yet fundamental question. By reviewing and classifying prior studies for the past 50 years, we find a significant lack of consensus in the literature, primarily due to the coexistence of retrospective and prospective approaches to measuring citation age distributions. These two approaches have been pursued in parallel, lacking any known connections between the two. Here we developed a new theoretical framework that not only allows us to connect the two approaches through precise mathematical relationships, it also helps us reconcile the interplay between temporal decay of citations and the growth of science, helping us uncover new functional forms characterizing citation age distributions. We find retrospective distribution follows a lognormal distribution with exponential cutoff, while prospective distribution is governed by the interplay between a lognormal distribution and the growth in the number of references. Most interestingly, the two approaches can be connected once rescaled by the growth of publications and citations. We further validate our framework using both large-scale citation datasets and analytical models capturing citation dynamics. Together this paper presents a comprehensive analysis of the time dimension of science, representing a new empirical and theoretical basis for all future studies in this area.

Physics and Society,Digital Libraries,Social and Information Networks
Journals as constituents of scientific discourse: economic heterodoxy

Wilfred Dolfsma,Loet Leydesdorff

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.0911.2364

2009-11-12

Abstract:Purpose: to provide a view and analysis of the immediate field of journals which surround a number of key heterodox economics journals. Design/methodology/approach: Using citation data from the Science and Social Science Citation Index, the individual and collective networks of a number of journals in this field are analyzed. Findings: The size and shape of the citation networks of journals can differ substantially, even if in a broadly similar category. Heterodox economics cannot (yet) be considered as an integrated specialty: authors in several journals in heterodox economics cite more from mainstream economics than from other heterodox journals. There are also strong links with other disciplinary fields such as geography, development studies, women studies, etc.

Digital Libraries,Physics and Society
Visualization of the Citation Impact Environments of Scientific Journals: An online mapping exercise

Loet Leydesdorff

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.0911.2731

2009-11-13

Digital Libraries

Abstract:Aggregated journal-journal citation networks based on the Journal Citation Reports 2004 of the Science Citation Index (5968 journals) and the Social Science Citation Index (1712 journals) are made accessible from the perspective of any of these journals. The user is thus able to analyze the citation environment in terms of links and graphs. Furthermore, the local impact of a journal is defined as its share of the total citations in the specific journal's citation environments; the vertical size of the nodes is varied proportionally to this citation impact. The horizontal size of each node can be used to provide the same information after correction for within-journal (self)-citations. In the "citing" environment, the equivalents of this measure can be considered as a citation activity index which maps how the relevant journal environment is perceived by the collective of authors of a given journal. As a policy application, the mechanism of interdisciplinary developments among the sciences is elaborated for the case of nanotechnology journals.
Dynamic Animations of Journal Maps: Indicators of Structural Changes and Interdisciplinary Developments

Loet Leydesdorff,Thomas Schank

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.0911.1437

2009-11-07

Physics and Society

Abstract:The dynamic analysis of structural change in the organization of the sciences requires methodologically the integration of multivariate and time-series analysis. Structural change--e.g., interdisciplinary development--is often an objective of government interventions. Recent developments in multi-dimensional scaling (MDS) enable us to distinguish the stress originating in each time-slice from the stress originating from the sequencing of time-slices, and thus to locally optimize the trade-offs between these two sources of variance in the animation. Furthermore, visualization programs like Pajek and Visone allow us to show not only the positions of the nodes, but also their relational attributes like betweenness centrality. Betweenness centrality in the vector space can be considered as an indicator of interdisciplinarity. Using this indicator, the dynamics of the citation impact environments of the journals Cognitive Science, Social Networks, and Nanotechnology are animated and assessed in terms of interdisciplinarity among the disciplines involved.
Caveats for the Use of Citation Indicators in Research and Journal Evaluations

Loet Leydesdorff

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/asi.20743

2007-01-01

Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology

Abstract:Aging of publications, percentage of self-citations, and impact vary from journal to journal within fields of science. The assumption that citation and publication practices are homogenous within specialties and fields of science is invalid. Furthermore, the delineation of fields and among specialties is fuzzy. Institutional units of analysis and persons may move between fields or span different specialties. The match between the citation index and institutional profiles varies among institutional units and nations. The respective matches may heavily affect the representation of the units. Non-Institute of Scientific Information (ISI) journals are increasingly cornered into “transdisciplinary” Mode-2 functions with the exception of specialist journals publishing in languages other than English. An “externally cited impact factor” can be calculated for these journals. The citation impact of non-ISI journals will be demonstrated using Science and Public Policy as the example. © 2008 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
Tracking Areas Of Strategic Importance Using Scientometric Journal Mappings

Loet Leydesdorff,Susan Cozzens,Peter Van den Besselaar

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/0048-7333(94)90054-X

IF: 7.2

1994-01-01

Research Policy

Abstract:In science policy, it is often important to track emerging developments: new fields, fast-changing areas that are the focus of special funding efforts, or areas of growth or decline. This article presents methods to produce literature-based indicators for such areas using journal-to-journal citations. Using case studies of AIDS, superconductivity, and oncogenes, we posit that the inclusion of a new journal can be used as an indicator of structural change if the addition indicates the emergence of a new journal category. Using the cases of robotics and artificial intelligence, we illustrate the development of areas chosen for priority funding. Again using artificial intelligence, we demonstrate the importance of constructing even such simple measures of scientific performance as publication counts using dynamic rather than constant journal sets. Change in performance within a subfield can be systematically distinguished from change in the delineations among subfields over time.
The delineation of specialties in terms of journals using the dynamic journal set of the SCI

L. Leydesdorff,Susan E. Cozzens

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02016797

IF: 3.801

1993-01-01

Scientometrics

Abstract:In order to attribute journals to specialties in a dynamic journal set by using aggregated journal-journal citations derived from theScience Citation Index, it is necessary to complement the multi-variate analysis of this data with a time-serices perspective. This calls for a more analytical approach to the problem of choice among the many possible parameters for clustering. Changes in the disciplinary structure of science are tracked by using thedifferences among the multi-variate analyses for the various years. It is impossible to attribute change systematically to structure, noise, or deviance if these uncertainties are not clearly definedex ante. The study discusses the various choices which have to be made, in both conceptual and methodological terms. In addition to hierarchies among journals, one has to assume heterarchy among journal groups (and their centroids). For comprehensive mapping, a concept of “macro-journals” as representations of a density of points in the multi-dimensinoal space is defined. Empirical reslts indicate the feasibility of dynamic journal-journal mapping by using these methods.
Can "hot Spots" in the Sciences Be Mapped Using the Dynamics of Aggregated Journal-Journal Citation Relations?

Loet Leydesdorff,Wouter de Nooy

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/asi.23634

2015-01-01

Proceedings of the Association for Information Science and Technology

Abstract:Using 3 years of the Journal Citation Reports (2011, 2012, and 2013), indicators of transitions in 2012 (between 2011 and 2013) were studied using methodologies based on entropy statistics. Changes can be indicated at the level of journals using the margin totals of entropy production along the row or column vectors, but also at the level of links among journals by importing the transition matrices into network analysis and visualization programs (and using community-finding algorithms). Seventy-four journals were flagged in terms of discontinuous changes in their citations, but 3,114 journals were involved in “hot” links. Most of these links are embedded in a main component; 78 clusters (containing 172 journals) were flagged as potential “hot spots” emerging at the network level. An additional finding was that PLoS ONE introduced a new communication dynamic into the database. The limitations of the methodology were elaborated using an example. The results of the study indicate where developments in the citation dynamics can be considered as significantly unexpected. This can be used as heuristic information, but what a “hot spot” in terms of the entropy statistics of aggregated citation relations means substantively can be expected to vary from case to case.

Journals As Retention Mechanisms of Scientific Growth

"Structuration" by Intellectual Organization: The Configuration of Knowledge in Relations among Structural Components in Networks of Science

Bibliometrics/Citation networks

Discontinuities in Citation Relations among Journals: Self-organized Criticality as a Model of Scientific Revolutions and Change

“ Structuration ” by Intellectual Organization : The Configuration of Knowledge in Relations among Scientific Texts

A bibliometric perspective on the academic contributions of Loet Leydesdorff

Indicators of Structural Change in the Dynamics of Science: Entropy Statistics of the SCI Journal Citation Reports

The Development of Frames of References.

Tracing “interdisciplinarity” using time series of journal maps: The visualization and dynamic animation of journal-journal citation relations

Dynamic and Evolutionary Updates of Classificatory Schemes in Scientific Journal Structures

The Journal of Communication and the Field of Communication Studies: Mapping Scientific Communication Online

Can Networks Of Journal-Journal Citations Be Used As Indicators Of Change In The Social Sciences?

The Development of the Journal Environment of Leonardo

The Time Dimension of Science: Connecting the Past to the Future

Journals as constituents of scientific discourse: economic heterodoxy

Visualization of the Citation Impact Environments of Scientific Journals: An online mapping exercise

Dynamic Animations of Journal Maps: Indicators of Structural Changes and Interdisciplinary Developments

Caveats for the Use of Citation Indicators in Research and Journal Evaluations

Tracking Areas Of Strategic Importance Using Scientometric Journal Mappings

The delineation of specialties in terms of journals using the dynamic journal set of the SCI

Can "hot Spots" in the Sciences Be Mapped Using the Dynamics of Aggregated Journal-Journal Citation Relations?