Abstract:In China, three major rangeland management policies have caused dramatic social, economic, and ecological changes for pastoral regions in the past 30yr: the Rangeland Household Contract Policy (RHCP), Rangeland Ecological Construction Projects (RECPs), and the Nomad Settlement Policy (NSP). The impacts of these policies are greatly debated. In this paper, we conduct a systematic review of academic perspectives on the impacts of the three policies and the causes of ineffective and negative effects. The findings demonstrate that academics increasingly report negative impacts of RHCP on the ecosystem, animal husbandry, pastoralist livelihoods, and pastoral society. An increasing number of scholars, although not the majority, attribute the negative impacts to improper policy itself rather than incomplete implementation. Regarding the RECPs, most academics believe that policies have improved the rangeland ecosystem but with obvious negative impacts on pastoralist livelihoods and pastoral society; they attribute the problems to incomplete policy implementation. For the NSP, most academics report positive impacts on pastoralist livelihoods and animal husbandry, although recent researchers have identified negative impacts on pastoral society and the ecosystem. Although they are not in the mainstream, more and more academics attribute the negative impacts to improper policy. Finally, we apply the concept of coupled social–ecological systems (SES) to further analyze the outcomes of these three policies and propose a more flexible and inclusive land tenure policy that recognizes the diverse local institutional arrangements; an integrated RECP framework that considers coadaptation between social and ecological systems; and facilitating voluntary choice in nomad settlement and developing innovative approaches to provide social services for pastoralists who would like to remain in pastoral areas. As these three policy approaches are applied in rangeland management and pastoral development worldwide, this paper may provide useful implications for future policy development in pastoral regions on a global scale.

Chapter 7 Policy Analysis in Grassland Management of Xilingol Prefecture, Inner Mongolia

Policy Analysis In Grassland Management Of Xilingol Prefecture, Inner Mongolia

Small-Scale Co-Management for the Sustainable Use of Xilingol Biosphere Reserve, Inner Mongolia

Determinants of Grassland Use Right Transfer in Institutional Change: Evidence from Pastoral China

The Grassland Ecological Compensation Policy Drives the Differentiation of Herders’ Livelihoods in Inner Mongolian Desert Grassland

Property rights and grassland degradation: A study of the Xilingol Pasture, Inner Mongolia, China

Rangeland Degradation Control in China: A Policy Review

Impacts of the Grassland Ecological Compensation Policy on Household Livestock Production in China: an Empirical Study in Inner Mongolia

Perfecting the Grassland Resource Management System

Does 'Forage-Livestock Balance' Policy Impact Ecological Efficiency of Grasslands in China?

China’s Rangeland Management Policy Debates: What Have We Learned?

Grassland Ecological Compensation, Income Level and Policy Satisfaction: An Empirical Analysis Based on a Survey of Herders in Ecological Protection Redline Areas

Assessing Controversial Desertification Prevention Policies in Ecologically Fragile and Deeply Impoverished Areas: A Case Study of Marginal Parts of the Taklimakan Desert, China

The Impacts of the Eco-Environmental Policy on Grassland Degradation and Livestock Production in Inner Mongolia, China: an Empirical Analysis Based on the Simultaneous Equation Model

Integration of Conservation with Development in Xilingol Grassland Reserve

Assessing Ecological Compensation Policy Effectiveness: A Case Study in the Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region, China

Why "Balance of Forage and Livestock" System Failed to Reach Sustainable Grassland Utilization

Adaptation of Herders to Droughts and Privatization of Rangeland-Use Rights in the Arid Alxa Left Banner of Inner Mongolia.

Land Tenure Reform and Grassland Degradation in Inner Mongolia, China

Effects of Value Perception, Environmental Regulation and Their Interaction on the Improvement of Herdsmen’s Grassland Ecological Policy Satisfaction

Cooperative grassland management practices promoted by land tenure system transformation benefit social-ecological systems of pastoralism on the Qinghai-Tibetan plateau, China