RETHINKING AGRICULTURAL POLICIES FOR PRO-POOR GROWTH
Andrew Dorward,Shenggen Fan,Jonathan Kydd,Hans Lofgren,Jamie Morrison,Colin Poulton,Neetha Rao,Laurence Smith,Hardwick Tchale,Sukhadeo Thorat,Ian Urey,Peter Wobst
2004-01-01
Abstract:Global experience demonstrates the importance of agricultural growth for poverty reduction in poor rural areas, but also identifies the limitations of agriculture in delivering poverty reduction, and the need for complementary growth in the non-farm sector. Contrary to the thinking that dominates much of current development policy, subsidies need to play a crucial part in 'kick starting' food grain supply chains if increased smallholder productivity is to drive rural non-farm growth. Establishing the base conditions for such subsidies to work, designing and implementing them to be effective, and then phasing them out as soon as they have done their task, are major challenges facing policy makers concerned with reducing poverty in rural areas where most of the world's poorest people live. Policy conclusions • In many rural areas both the farm and non-farm sectors are critical for poverty reduction, with different but complementary contributions to pro- poor growth. As both sectors grow, the non-farm sector will build on the gains made by smallholder agriculture and increasingly influence real wages and food security. • Critical 'base' conditions for pro-poor agricultural growth include adequate levels of rural infrastructure, labour-demanding technical change that delivers significant productivity gains, and access to stable input, output and financial markets supporting such technologies. These should transmit to the poor the benefits from widespread technology adoption through tightening of labour markets and falling grain prices (but these must not precede growth or they will choke it). • Structural change of this kind requires policy analysis to differentiate between stages of development in poor rural areas and between different categories of rural people, and needs careful sequencing and targeting of policies. The early stages of growth require an active coordinating role by some central player(s). Finding new and more effective coordination mechanisms with different roles for the state, the private sector and civil society presents major technical, administrative and political challenges in policy design and implementation. • Subsidies focusing on transaction cost reduction may also often be necessary to make input purchases both profitable and affordable.The design and implementation of any interventions needed for output price stabilisation and credit delivery pose challenges, but if effective will often be more efficient than blunter input subsidies. • Promoting structural change from agriculture-based to non-farm growth requires large scale and long term investments. Increased pressure on resources, HIV/AIDS and competition through globalisation mean that it is becoming more difficult to achieve. • Nor can structural change be promoted successfully everywhere. In areas remote from markets with high population density and a declining resource base, the emphasis may have to be more on resource rehabilitation, supporting out-migration, and meeting local food needs than on fully-fledged transformation. Supporting pro-poor agricultural growth is a risky and long term project, but is one of the few alternatives to desperate outmigration and indefinite large scale welfare support.