Author Response: Lys63-linked Ubiquitin Chain Adopts Multiple Conformational States for Specific Target Recognition
Zhu Liu,Zhou Gong,Wen-Xue Jiang,Ju Yang,Wen-Kai Zhu,Da-Chuan Guo,Wei-Ping Zhang,Mai-Li Liu,Chun Tang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.7554/elife.05767.029
2015-01-01
Abstract:Article Figures and data Abstract eLife digest Introduction Results Discussion Materials and methods References Decision letter Author response Article and author information Metrics Abstract A polyubiquitin comprises multiple covalently linked ubiquitins and recognizes myriad targets. Free or bound to ligands, polyubiquitins are found in different arrangements of ubiquitin subunits. To understand the structural basis for polyubiquitin quaternary plasticity and to explore the target recognition mechanism, we characterize the conformational space of Lys63-linked diubiquitin (K63-Ub2). Refining against inter-subunit paramagnetic NMR data, we show that free K63-Ub2 exists as a dynamic ensemble comprising multiple closed and open quaternary states. The quaternary dynamics enables K63-Ub2 to be specifically recognized in a variety of signaling pathways. When binding to a target protein, one of the preexisting quaternary states is selected and stabilized. A point mutation that shifts the equilibrium between the different states modulates the binding affinities towards K63-Ub2 ligands. This conformational selection mechanism at the quaternary level may be used by polyubiquitins of different lengths and linkages for target recognition. https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.05767.001 eLife digest Proteins can be tagged with other molecules that indicate what the cell should do with that protein. For example, proteins tagged with a small protein called ubiquitin—which is linked to other ubiquitin molecules to form ‘polyubiquitin’—may be destroyed or relocated within a cell. Like all proteins, a ubiquitin is made up of chains of amino acids. Specific amino acids form the linkages between individual ubiquitins to form a polyubiquitin, and the nature of these linkages influences the effect that a polyubiquitin has on the tagged protein. One linkage involves a lysine amino acid at position 63 (known as Lys63). This linkage is found in the polyubiquitin that is involved in repairing damaged proteins and relocating target proteins to a part of the cell where they are utilized for immune response. To perform these different roles, the polyubiquitin must be able to distinguish between a variety of target proteins. The shape that a protein takes on determines how it works, and most proteins constantly and rapidly switch between different shapes. Previous work suggested that the Lys63-linked polyubiquitin could only take on an elongated ‘open’ structure by itself. It was not clear whether the protein could take on a compact ‘closed’ structure without first binding to a target protein. Liu et al. used a technique known as nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) to explore the high-resolution structures of the Lys63-linked ubiquitin chain when they are not bound to other proteins. The results showed that a large percentage of the protein was in a closed state, and that there were at least one open shape and two kinds of closed shapes. Liu et al. suggest that the shape of the unbound Lys63-linked ubiquitin chain determines what other proteins can be bound, and that the binding stabilizes the shape of the ubiquitin. This mechanism of binding is known as conformational selection. Further work is required to analyze whether other polyubiquitin chains recognize their partners in a similar manner. https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.05767.002 Introduction Ubiquitin is a 76-residue signaling protein found ubiquitously in cells. Multiple ubiquitins are covalently linked to form a polyubiquitin, which can then be attached to a substrate protein. The process is known as ubiquitination, a post-translational modification of the substrate protein. Three classes of enzymes catalyze ubiquitination: ubiquitin-activation enzyme (E1), ubiquitin-conjugation enzymes (E2), and ubiquitin-protein ligases (E3). E2 and E3 dictate ubiquitin linkage and substrate specificities. Additionally, deubiquitinases (DUBs) are responsible for specifically erasing ubiquitin signals from a substrate protein (Clague et al., 2012). Catalyzed by a linkage-specific E2, two or more ubiquitins are linked up via an isopeptide bond between the carboxylate at the C-terminus of one ubiquitin (referred to as the distal unit) and the ε-amine of a lysine residue (Lys6, Lys11, Lys27, Lys29, Lys33, Lys48, or Lys63) or the α-amine at the N-terminus of another ubiquitin (referred as the proximal unit). Lys48-linked polyubiquitin is the most abundant linkage in cells, and signals substrate proteins for proteasomal degradation (Kravtsova-Ivantsiv et al., 2013; Lu et al., 2015). Other types of linkages mostly perform non-degradative functions (Xu et al., 2009; Kulathu and Komander, 2012). Lys63-linked polyubiquitin is another common linkage, and has been found to be involved in DNA damage response (Hoege et al., 2002), multivesicular body mediated protein sorting (MacDonald et al., 2012), NF-κB signaling (Chen and Chen, 2013; Zinngrebe et al., 2014), and oxidative stress response (Silva et al., 2015). Lys63-linked polyubiquitin also exists as an unanchored form without being attached to a substrate protein, and the unanchored form may serve as a scaffold for recruiting proteins in the signaling pathways of innate immunity and protein aggregate removal (Zeng et al., 2010; Hao et al., 2013). How does Lys63-linked polyubiquitin perform different functions? To do so, Lys63-linked polyubiquitin has to specifically recognize multiple target proteins. Structural studies of Lys63-linked diubiquitin (K63-Ub2) have indicated that K63-Ub2 mostly adopts open extended conformations in the absence of a ligand and in complex with many target proteins (Datta et al., 2009; Komander et al., 2009; Sato et al., 2009a; Weeks et al., 2009; Sekiyama et al., 2012). It has been proposed that such an open extended structure differentiates K63-Ub2 from Lys48-linked polyubiquitin that predominantly exists in a closed structure (Varadan et al., 2004; Fushman and Walker, 2010; Hirano et al., 2011). Notwithstanding, K63-Ub2 has been found in closed conformations when complexed with the Npl4 zinc-finger domain (NZF) of TAK1-binding proteins (Kulathu et al., 2009; Sato et al., 2009b) for the activation of NF-κB signaling pathways. K63-Ub2 is also selectively recognized by the fourth zinc-finger (ZnF4) of A20, a ubiquitin-editing enzyme for the termination of NF-κB signaling (Wertz, 2014; Wertz and Dixit, 2014). The crystal structure of the complex between ZnF4 and ubiquitin monomer indicated that K63-Ub2 likely exists in a closed conformation when binding to ZnF4 (Bosanac et al., 2010). So are the closed-state structures already present for the free K63-Ub2, but have hitherto eluded structural characterization? Or is the closed-state structure induced by a specific ligand? To recognize a target protein and to perform specific functions, a protein has to fluctuate among a variety of conformational states (Henzler-Wildman and Kern, 2007). For a ubiquitin monomer, studies have shown that the protein exists as an ensemble of tertiary conformations which can accommodate different target proteins (Lange et al., 2008). As ubiquitin mainly functions as polyubiquitins, a more pertinent question is how does a polyubiquitin fluctuate at the quaternary level and achieve its target recognition specificity? Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) is well suited to characterize protein ensemble structures and to visualize protein dynamics. NMR depiction of dynamic fluctuation for multi-domain proteins such as pre-mRNA splicing factor U2AF and DNA-binding protein CAP, has uncovered conformational selection and equilibrium shift mechanisms for these systems (Mackereth et al., 2011; Tzeng and Kalodimos, 2012; Huang et al., 2014). Among the NMR techniques, paramagnetic relaxation enhancement (PRE) is exquisitely sensitive to transient and fleeting interactions between proteins (Sekhar and Kay, 2013; Xing et al., 2014). Owing to dipolar interactions between the paramagnetic center and protein nuclei, PRE is proportional to the inverse sixth power of the distance between the paramagnetic center and protein nuclei, and is ensemble-averaged over all the conformational states sampled (Clore and Iwahara, 2009). To explore the target recognition mechanism for K63-Ub2, we used PRE NMR in conjunction with other biophysical methods. We characterized the arrangements between the ubiquitin units, and we determined the ensemble structure for K63-Ub2 in the absence of a ligand. Our findings indicated a conformational selection mechanism at the quaternary level, whereby a target protein selects and stabilizes one of the preexisting conformational states of ligand-free K63-Ub2. Results Ligand-free K63-Ub2 exists in both open and closed states We first compared the chemical shift differences between the subunits in K63-Ub2 and ubiquitin monomer. Except for residues near the covalent ubiquitin linkage, the differences in chemical shifts are small (<0.04 ppm; Figure 1—figure supplement 1). Residues with relatively large chemical shift differences (>0.01 ppm) can be tentatively mapped, and form rather contiguous surfaces on each subunit (Figure 1—figure supplement 1, insets). However, it is unclear whether the perturbations are due to the covalent linkage, or due to non-covalent interactions between the two subunits. We also performed a half-filtered NMR experiment, which failed to reveal any inter-subunit nuclear Overhauser effects (NOEs) between the proximal and distal units of K63-Ub2. Our data are consistent with the previous NMR studies of K63-Ub2 (Tenno et al., 2004; Varadan et al., 2004); in the latter work, the authors failed to detect cross-saturations between the two subunits. Together, the diamagnetic NMR studies indicated that the closed-state structure of K63-Ub2, if existing, is loosely packed and possibly adopts multiple conformations. To visualize the quaternary arrangement between the subunits of K63-Ub2, we resorted to PRE NMR. We prepared K63-Ub2 protein with the proximal unit 15N-labeled and the distal unit unlabeled. A cysteine point mutation was introduced to Asn25 or Lys48 in the distal unit of K63-Ub2. An MTS paramagnetic probe was conjugated at N25C or K48C site. Each of the conjugation sites was designed so that the paramagnetic probe was away from the binding partners of K63-Ub2, which include Rap80 tUIM domain (Sekiyama et al., 2012), TAB2 NZF domain (Kulathu et al., 2009; Sato et al., 2009b), and A20 ZnF4 domain (Bosanac et al., 2010), and therefore the conjugation does not interfere with ligand binding (Figure 1—figure supplement 2). Indeed, the binding affinities between K63-Ub2 and tUIM or NZF remain unchanged for the paramagnetically tagged K63-Ub2 proteins (Figure 1—figure supplement 3). In addition, the paramagnetic NMR spectrum can be overlaid onto the diamagnetic spectrum, except for residues that are completely broadened out due to the PRE effect (Figure 1—figure supplement 4). Together, the modifications do not perturb the conformational space of K63-Ub2 or have an effect on K63-Ub2 function. We previously reported that ubiquitin monomer dimerizes non-covalently with an apparent KD value of 4.9 ± 0.3 mM (Liu et al., 2012). Therefore, the PRE effect could arise both intramolecularly and inter-molecularly. The inter-molecular PREs were measured on an equimolar mixture of K63-Ub2 (each at 500 µM), with paramagnetic tagging and isotope labeling on different subunits in separate proteins. With a paramagnetic probe conjugated at either N25C or K48C site and using the inter-molecular data for reference, our measurements revealed large intra-molecular inter-subunit PREs for many residues in the proximal unit (Figure 1A,B). At relatively low protein concentration (50 µM), the inter-molecular contribution to the overall PRE is negligible. We found that the relative decreases in peak intensities between the paramagnetic and diamagnetic spectra recorded at 50 µM are highly correlated with the relative decreases between the paramagnetic and inter-molecular spectra recorded at 500 µM (Figure 1—figure supplement 5). This corroborates the PRE measurement at the higher concentration. In addition, when a different paramagnetic probe, EDTA-Mn2+, was conjugated at N25C, the PRE profile is similar to that using the MTS probe (Figure 1—figure supplement 6). Thus, the intra-molecular inter-subunit PREs are independent of the paramagnetic probe used, and reveal intrinsic structural features of ligand-free K63-Ub2. Figure 1 with 8 supplements see all Download asset Open asset Intra-molecular inter-subunit paramagnetic relaxation enhancements (PREs) measured for ligand-free K63-Ub2. With the paramagnetic probe conjugated at (A) N25C or (B) K48C in the distal unit, the PRE 1H Γ2 rates were measured for amide protons of the 15N-labeled proximal unit. The red spheres indicate the observed PREs. The error bar indicates 1 SD in the PRE measurement. The blue lines are the back-calculated PRE values for residues 1–71. Residues that are completely broadened out are denoted with asterisks at the top. https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.05767.003 K63-Ub2 has been generally considered to only exist in the open state for both ligand-free and many ligand-bound forms. For the known open-state structures of K63-Ub2 (Sato et al., 2008; Datta et al., 2009; Komander et al., 2009; Sato et al., 2009a; Weeks et al., 2009; Yoshikawa et al., 2009; Sekiyama et al., 2012), the intra-molecular inter-subunit PREs calculated with an MTS probe attached at either N25C or K48C site are essentially zero for residues in the proximal unit (Figure 1—figure supplement 7). Alternatively, an open extended conformation of K63-Ub2 can be simply obtained by restraining the inter-subunit PRE target value to zero for residues in the proximal unit—the resulting conformational space encompasses all known K63-Ub2 structures in the open state (Figure 1—figure supplement 8). As such, the large inter-subunit PREs should only arise from the closed state of K63-Ub2, and ligand-free K63-Ub2 should exist in both open and closed states. The existence of the closed state for ligand-free K63-Ub2 is corroborated by small angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) analysis. The SAXS data collected for K63-Ub2 at higher concentrations display larger particle size than those at lower concentrations, indicative of high-order oligomers for the former (Figure 2—figure supplement 1). At lower concentrations, the Dmax value is smaller, and the data recorded at 1 mM and 500 µM are similar (Dmax = 67.2 and 65 Å, respectively). The Dmax values are smaller than the calculated values for all known open-state structures (84.0 ± 3.3 Å). Significantly, the experimental paired-distance distribution function P(r) at 1 mM is much narrower than those computed for the known open-state structures, with a large probability of distribution at ∼30 Å (Figure 2A). Further, the theoretical scattering profiles for the open-state structure models (Figure 1—figure supplement 8) all differ from the experiment curve (Figure 2—figure supplement 2A). Figure 2 with 2 supplements see all Download asset Open asset Small angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) analysis of ligand-free K63-Ub2. (A) Paired-distance distribution curves transformed from the experimental data (black line) or calculated for the known structures of K63-Ub2. Except for the Protein Data Bank (PDB) structures 3H7P, 3HM3, and 2JF5, the bound ligand was removed before calculation. (B) Comparison between experimental (gray dots) and simulated scattering data (transparent cyan line), affording a χ2 value of 1.24. The simulated curve was obtained by linearly combining the theoretical curves calculated for open-state (red line) and closed-state (blue line) solution structures at 30:70 ratio. https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.05767.012 Ensemble refinement of the closed-state structure of K63-Ub2 To characterize the closed-state structure of ligand-free K63-Ub2, we performed rigid-body simulated annealing refinement against the inter-subunit PREs. The linker between the two subunits (Lys63 side chain in the proximal unit and C-terminal flexible residues 72–76 of the distal unit) was given full torsional freedom. A grid search was performed by varying the number of conformers representing the closed state (from a single conformer to a five-conformer ensemble), and by varying the overall population of the closed state (from 10% to 90%). A single-conformer representation for the closed state does not satisfy the inter-subunit PREs, as assessed by the PRE Q-factor (Iwahara et al., 2004). This means that the closed state of ligand-free K63-Ub2 should exist in multiple conformations. The PRE Q-factor rapidly decreases as the number of conformers representing the closed state increases, and levels off with four or more conformers (Figure 3A). On the other hand, a closed-state population of at least 30% is required to achieve a good fit to the PRE data (Figure 3A). For reasons that will be discussed below, the population of the K63-Ub2 closed state is about 70%. At a 70% population for the closed state with a four-conformer representation, the back-calculated PREs agree well with the experimental ones, affording a PRE Q-factor of 0.22 and correlation coefficient of 0.94 (Figures 1, 3B). Importantly, the two paramagnetic conjugation sites, N25C and K48C, provide cross-validating PRE measurements—when refining the ensemble structure of the K63-Ub2 closed state against the N25C data alone, the PRE values predicted for the K48C site largely agree with the experimental values, affording a free Q-factor of 0.46 (Figure 3—figure supplement 1). On the other hand, the SAXS profiles computed for the PRE-based closed-state structures differ from the experiment curve, with the calculated intensities larger at scattering angles between 0.5 and 1 nm−1 (Figure 2—figure supplement 2B). Figure 3 with 1 supplement see all Download asset Open asset Ensemble refinement of the closed-state structure of K63-Ub2 against intra-molecular inter-subunit paramagnetic relaxation enhancements (PREs). (A) Heat map of PRE Q-factor upon varying the number of conformers and the population of the closed state. (B) The correlation between observed and calculated PREs, with a four-conformer representation at 70% closed-state population. The PRE ensemble Q-factor is 0.26 and 0.18 for the N25C site (open circles) and K48C site (closed circles), respectively, and 0.22 for both sites. The diagonal indicates a perfect correlation to guide the eyes. https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.05767.015 Analysis of the closed-state structure of K63-Ub2 To better visualize the ensemble structure of K63-Ub2 in the closed state, we projected the position of the proximal unit relative to the distal unit using spherical coordinates (Figure 4—figure supplement 1). Upon reducing the dimensionality, we found that the closed-state structures exist in two clusters, namely C1 and C2 (Figure 4A). For each four-conformer structure, one of the conformers falls into C2, while the other three are in C1. The proximal unit of ligand-free K63-Ub2 utilizes distinct interfaces to interact with the distal unit in C1 and C2 states (Figure 4B,C), affording buried solvent-accessible surface areas of 283.9 ± 139.7 Å2 and 200.5 ± 59.6 Å2, respectively. Significantly, the crystal structures of K63-Ub2 in complex with the ZnF4 domain of A20 (Bosanac et al., 2010) and with the NZF domain of TAB2 or TAB3 (Kulathu et al., 2009; Sato et al., 2009b) are found within or near the C1 and C2 clusters, respectively (Figure 4A). The root-mean-square difference (RMSD) between the conformers in C1 and the ZnF4-bound structure of K63-Ub2 is as small as 3.93 Å (Figure 4B), while the RMSD between C2 conformers and the NZF-bound structure is as small as 1.68 Å (Figure 4C). We predicted the inter-subunit PREs for two known complex structures in closed states (Figure 4—figure supplement 2A,B). Linearly combining the two sets of PREs at a 3:1 ratio and 70% total population, the resulting PREs agree well with the experimental values, although some details differ (Figure 4—figure supplement 2C). On the other hand, the paired-distance distribution profiles computed for A20 ZnF4 and TAB2/TAB3 NZF complexed K63-Ub2 (with bound ligand removed) display narrower distributions compared to those computed for the open-state structures or to the experimental data (Figure 2A). Figure 4 with 2 supplements see all Download asset Open asset Ensemble structure of K63-Ub2 in closed state. (A) Projection of the ensemble structures in two dimensions with spherical coordinates. K63-Ub2 crystal structures in closed states are also projected. (B, C) Comparison of the ligand-free K63-Ub2 structure with K63-Ub2 crystal structures in complex with A20 ZnF4 and NZF TAB2, respectively. With the distal unit superimposed, the other ubiquitin subunit in the crystal structure is shown as a gray cartoon, affording root-mean-square (RMS) differences of 3.93 Å and 1.68 Å for C1 and C2 closed states, respectively. https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.05767.017 Taken together, the ensemble structure refinement revealed that in addition to the open state, ligand-free K63-Ub2 also exists in at least two distinct closed states at a significant combined population. As C1 is represented with multiple conformers, it is possible to further partition the closed state into more conformational states. As the ligand-bound closed structures are similar to ligand-free structures of K63-Ub2 in either C1 or C2 state, a cognate ligand of K63-Ub2 can be preferentially recognized and accommodated into one of the preexisting conformations. As there are some differences between the ligand-free and ligand-bound K63-Ub2 in the closed state (Figure 4B,C), the binding may require some induced fit, especially towards the end of the binding process. On the other hand, the open-state conformation of K63-Ub2 may specifically recognize its corresponding ligand like Rap80 tUIM (Sekiyama et al., 2012) via a conformational selection mechanism. Perturbation of K63-Ub2 conformational space How does K63-Ub2 inter-convert among the preexisting conformations? To address this, we introduced a charge reversal mutation to residue Glu64 in the proximal unit, resulting an E64RP mutant of K63-Ub2. Glu64 is located at the interface between the two subunits in both C1 and C2 closed states, opposing the positively charged residues Arg72 and Arg74 in the distal unit (Figure 5—figure supplement 1). We reasoned that this mutation should affect the conformational space of K63-Ub2. Indeed, the E64RP mutation results in chemical shift perturbations (CSPs) in the K63-Ub2 distal unit (Figure 5—figure supplement 2). Although the perturbations are small, almost the same residues are perturbed upon E64RP mutation as upon the covalent linkage of ubiquitin monomers (Figure 5A and Figure 1—figure supplement 1D). However, the NMR peaks for the perturbed residues in the mutant do not simply move in the direction towards the chemical shift values of the ubiquitin monomer. This can be either due to altered non-covalent interactions around the mutation site, or to a change in the relative population of the conformational states. Therefore, it is difficult to quantitate the CSPs in terms of K63-Ub2 structural change. Figure 5 with 2 supplements see all Download asset Open asset Changes in NMR parameters for K63-Ub2 upon E64RP mutation. (A) Chemical shift differences of the distal unit upon mutation. Inset, residues with relatively large chemical shift differences (>0.01 ppm) are mapped to the surface of the distal unit (colored red). (B) Decreases in intra-molecular inter-subunit PREs upon mutation with an MTS paramagnetic probe conjugated at K48C site. Lines simply connect the data points. PRE values characteristic of C1 and C2 states are indicated with cyan and yellow strips, respectively. Error bars indicate the SD in PRE measurements. https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.05767.020 Thus we measured the intra-molecular inter-subunit PREs for the E64RP mutant of K63-Ub2, using the same paramagnetic conjugation scheme. The PRE profile of the mutant is similar to that of the wild type, indicating similar ensemble structures for the mutant (Figure 5B). However, the magnitude of the PRE decreases by about 50%. As the inter-subunits’ PRE arises only from the closed-state structures of K63-Ub2, smaller PREs indicate that the E64RP mutation destabilizes the closed state, reducing the closed-state population to half of that of the wild type. At the same time, the E64RP mutation should result in an increase in the population for the open state. Interactions between K63-Ub2 and its ligands In a conformational selection mechanism, a K63-Ub2 ligand (tUIM, NZF, or ZnF4) is preferentially recognized by one of the preexisting conformational states. Since the relative populations of the conformational states are perturbed upon the E64RP mutation, we expect that the binding affinities of K63-Ub2 towards the respective ligands differ. Importantly, the mutation is away from the binding interfaces between K63-Ub2 and its ligands (Figures 6A,B, 7), and therefore should not directly affect the interactions between K63-Ub2 and its ligands. Figure 6 Download asset Open asset The interactions between K63-Ub2 mutant with tUIM and with NZF. (A, B) Illustration of the E64RP mutation in the complex structures (Protein Data Bank [PDB] codes 2RR9 and 2WX0). The point mutation is distant from the K63-Ub2 interfaces with tUIM and NZF. (C, D) Isothermal calorimetry (ITC) measurements for the bindings with tUIM and NZF. The raw data (top panels) are converted to heat per injection, and the fitted curves using one-site binding model are shown as solid lines (bottom panels). The binding affinities KD, binding enthalpy changes ΔH, and entropy changes ΔS values are averaged over four independent experiments. https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.05767.023 Figure 7 with 2 supplements see all Download asset Open asset The interaction between K63-Ub2 and A20 ZnF4 at 313 K. (A, C) NMR titrations of ZnF4 into wild type and mutant K63-Ub2 with 15N-labeling at the distal unit. Residues 50–62 (labeled) experience slow timescale exchange and gradually disappear upon ZnF4 titration. (B, D) Fittings of chemical shift perturbations to binding isotherms. The chemical shift perturbations are calculated as (ΔδH2 + ΔδN2)^0.5 in Hz units. Inset, ZnF4-binding surface on K63-Ub2 distal unit (residues 50–62) is mapped (colored orange). https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.05767.024 Using isothermal calorimetry (ITC), we evaluated the binding affinities between wild type K63-Ub2 and tUIM, and between wild type K63-Ub2 and NZF. The respective KD values are 9.7 ± 0.3 µM and 12.2 ± 0.6 µM (Figure 1—figure supplement 3), which agree with the literature values (Kulathu et al., 2009; Sekiyama et al., 2012). We attempted to measure the binding affinity between A20 ZnF4 domain and K63-Ub2. However, the heat was too small to be fitted (Figure 7—figure supplement 1). Thus we resorted to NMR titration for the KD measurement. Upon titrating A20 ZnF4, a large set of residues in the distal unit of K63-Ub2 was perturbed (Figure 7A). Among the perturbed residues, residues 50–62 are located at the interface with ZnF4 (Bosanac et al., 2010), and their peaks disappear upon A20 ZnF4 titration, indicating a slow exchange between ZnF4-free and bound species (Figure 7—figure supplement 2). We were only able to fit the CSPs at an elevated temperature (313 K instead of 303 K), and determined the KD value at 384.1 ± 39.4 µM. A number of other residues in the K63-Ub2 distal unit also experience CSPs upon A20 ZnF4 titration. However, their peaks shift progressively at increasing ZnF4 concentrations, which indicates a fast exchange and should belong to a separate binding event. Upon the E64RP mutation, the binding between K63-Ub2 and the open-state ligand tUIM becomes tighter, with the KD value decreasing by more than fourfold to 2.2 ± 0.1 µM (Figure 6C). On the other hand, the binding towards closed-state ligands weakens—the KD value of K63-Ub2 binding towards NZF increases by ∼50% to 17.8 ± 1.1 µM (Figure 6D). Importantly, the enthalpy change ΔH values are almost identical for the bindings involving the wild type and mutant proteins (Figure 6 and Figure 1—figure supplement 3). For the interaction between K63-Ub2 mutant and A20 ZnF4, more peaks at the interface (residues 50–62 of the distal unit) can be traced, which can be attributed to a faster exchange than that of the wild type. Significantly, the KD value increases by almost threefold to 1199.9 ± 104.9 µM (Figure 7). Together, the binding affinity towards the open-state ligand increases at the expense of the binding affinities towards the closed-state ligands, and the changes in binding affinities are caused entropically due to the perturbation of K63-Ub2 conformational space. The difference in binding affinity can be accounted for by the difference in the conformational energy of K63-Ub2. Based on the PRE measurement, the closed-state population decreases by ∼50% upon E64RP mutation (Figure 5). At the same time, the population for the open state increases by the same amount. Thus, the gain in conformational energy will be manifested as the free energy difference for the increase in binding affinity between K63-Ub2 and its open-state partner
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
-
Lys63-linked ubiquitin chain adopts multiple conformational states for specific target recognition
zhu liu,zhou gong,wenxue jiang,ju yang,wenkai zhu,dachuan guo,weiping zhang,maili liu,chun tang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.05767
IF: 7.7
2015-01-01
eLife
Abstract:A polyubiquitin comprises multiple covalently linked ubiquitins and recognizes myriad targets. Free or bound to ligands, polyubiquitins are found in different arrangements of ubiquitin subunits. To understand the structural basis for polyubiquitin quaternary plasticity and to explore the target recognition mechanism, we characterize the conformational space of Lys63-linked diubiquitin (K63-Ub(2)). Refining against inter-subunit paramagnetic NMR data, we show that free K63-Ub(2) exists as a dynamic ensemble comprising multiple closed and open quaternary states. The quaternary dynamics enables K63-Ub(2) to be specifically recognized in a variety of signaling pathways. When binding to a target protein, one of the preexisting quaternary states is selected and stabilized. A point mutation that shifts the equilibrium between the different states modulates the binding affinities towards K63-Ub(2) ligands. This conformational selection mechanism at the quaternary level may be used by polyubiquitins of different lengths and linkages for target recognition. DOI: 10.7554/eLife.05767.001
-
Exploring the linkage dependence of polyubiquitin conformations using molecular modeling
David Fushman,Olivier Walker
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmb.2009.10.039
2010-01-29
Abstract:Posttranslational modification of proteins by covalent attachment of a small protein ubiquitin (Ub) or a polymeric chain of Ub molecules (called polyubiquitin) is involved in controlling a vast variety of processes in eukaryotic cells. The question of how different polyubiquitin signals are recognized is central to understanding the specificity of various types of polyubiquitination. In polyubiquitin, monomers are linked to each other via an isopeptide bond between the C-terminal glycine of one Ub and a lysine of the other. The functional outcome of polyubiquitination depends on the particular lysine involved in chain formation and appears to rely on linkage-dependent conformation of polyubiquitin. Thus, K48-linked chains, a universal signal for proteasomal degradation, under physiological conditions adopt a closed conformation where functionally important residues L8, I44, and V70 are sequestered at the interface between two adjacent Ub monomers. By contrast, K63-linked chains, which act as a nonproteolytic regulatory signal, adopt an extended conformation that lacks hydrophobic interubiquitin contact. Little is known about the functional roles of the so-called "noncanonical" chains (linked via K6, K11, K27, K29, or K33, or linked head-to-tail), and no structural information on these chains is available, except for information on the crystal structure of the head-to-tail-linked diubiquitin (Ub(2)). In this study, we use molecular modeling to examine whether any of the noncanonical chains can adopt a closed conformation similar to that in K48-linked polyubiquitin. Our results show that the eight possible Ub(2) chains can be divided into two groups: chains linked via K6, K11, K27, or K48 are predicted to form a closed conformation, whereas chains linked via K29, K33, or K63, or linked head-to-tail are unable to form such a contact due to steric occlusion. These predictions are validated by the known structures of K48-, K63-, and head-to-tail-linked chains. Our study also predicts structural models for Ub(2) chains linked via K6, K11, or K27. The implications of these findings for linkage-selective recognition of noncanonical polyubiquitin signals by various receptors are discussed.
-
Linkage via K27 Bestows Ubiquitin Chains with Unique Properties among Polyubiquitins
Carlos A Castañeda,Emma K Dixon,Olivier Walker,Apurva Chaturvedi,Mark A Nakasone,Joseph E Curtis,Megan R Reed,Susan Krueger,T Ashton Cropp,David Fushman
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.str.2016.01.007
IF: 5.871
2016-03-01
Structure
Abstract:Polyubiquitination, a critical protein post-translational modification, signals for a diverse set of cellular events via the different isopeptide linkages formed between the C terminus of one ubiquitin (Ub) and the ɛ-amine of K6, K11, K27, K29, K33, K48, or K63 of a second Ub. We assembled di-ubiquitins (Ub2) comprising every lysine linkage and examined them biochemically and structurally. Of these, K27-Ub2 is unique as it is not cleaved by most deubiquitinases. As this remains the only structurally uncharacterized lysine linkage, we comprehensively examined the structures and dynamics of K27-Ub2 using nuclear magnetic resonance, small-angle neutron scattering, and in silico ensemble modeling. Our structural data provide insights into the functional properties of K27-Ub2, in particular that K27-Ub2 may be specifically recognized by K48-selective receptor UBA2 domain from proteasomal shuttle protein hHR23a. Binding studies and mutagenesis confirmed this prediction, further highlighting structural/recognition versatility of polyubiquitins and the potential power of determining function from elucidation of conformational ensembles.
-
Ensemble Structure Description of Lys63-linked Diubiquitin
Zhu Liu,Chun Tang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.dib.2016.02.003
IF: 1.2
2016-01-01
Data in Brief
Abstract:The data described herein are related to the article entitled “Lys63-linked ubiquitin chain adopts multiple conformational states for specific target recognition” [1], and to the coordinates for the ensemble structure of Lys63-linked diubiquitin (PDB code 2N2K). A Lys63-linked diubiquitin exists in three conformational states with different orientations for the two subunits, each responsible for binding to a target protein and encoding a specific cell signal. An atomic entry in the ensemble structure file consists multiple lines, representing alternative locations of the atom and recapitulating the dynamics of the protein. Experimental details about obtaining strictly intramolecular paramagnetic restraints and determining the relative occupancies of the conformational states are presented. The experimental design and procedures in this Data article can be useful for characterizing the structure and dynamics of other multi-domain proteins.
-
Ubiquitin S65 Phosphorylation Engenders A Ph-Sensitive Conformational Switch
Xu Dong,Zhou Gong,Yun-Bi Lu,Kan Liu,Ling-Yun Qin,Meng-Lin Ran,Chang-Li Zhang,Zhu Liu,Wei-Ping Zhang,Chun Tang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1705718114
2017-01-01
Abstract:Ubiquitin (Ub) is an important signaling protein. Recent studies have shown that Ub can be enzymatically phosphorylated at S65, and that the resulting pUb exhibits two conformational states-a relaxed state and a retracted state. However, crystallization efforts have yielded only the structure for the relaxed state, which was found similar to that of unmodified Ub. Here we present the solution structures of pUb in both states obtained through refinement against state-specific NMR restraints. We show that the retracted state differs from the relaxed state by the retraction of the last beta-strand and by the extension of the second alpha-helix. Further, we show that at 7.2, the pK(a) value for the phosphoryl group in the relaxed state is higher by 1.4 units than that in the retracted state. Consequently, pUb exists in equilibrium between protonated and deprotonated forms and between retracted and relaxed states, with protonated/relaxed species enriched at slightly acidic pH and deprotonated/retracted species enriched at slightly basic pH. The heterogeneity of pUb explains the inability of phosphomimetic mutants to fully mimic pUb. The pH-sensitive conformational switch is likely preserved for polyubiquitin, as single-molecule FRET data indicate that pH change leads to quaternary rearrangement of a phosphorylated K63-linked diubiquitin. Because cellular pH varies among compartments and changes upon pathophysiological insults, our finding suggests that pH and Ub phosphorylation confer additional target specificities and enable an additional layer of modulation for Ub signals.
-
PolyUbiquitin chain linkage topology selects the functions from the underlying binding landscape
Yong Wang,Chun Tang,Erkang Wang,Jin Wang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pcbi.1003691
2014-07-03
Abstract:Ubiquitin (Ub) can generate versatile molecular signals and lead to different celluar fates. The functional poly-valence of Ub is believed to be resulted from its ability to form distinct polymerized chains with eight linkage types. To provide a full picture of ubiquitin code, we explore the binding landscape of two free Ub monomers and also the functional landscapes of of all eight linkage types by theoretical modeling. Remarkably, we found that most of the compact structures of covalently connected dimeric Ub chains (diUbs) pre-exist on the binding landscape. These compact functional states were subsequently validated by corresponding linkage models. This leads to the proposal that the folding architecture of Ub monomer has encoded all functional states into its binding landscape, which is further selected by different topologies of polymeric Ub chains. Moreover, our results revealed that covalent linkage leads to symmetry breaking of interfacial interactions. We further propose that topological constraint not only limits the conformational space for effective switching between functional states, but also selects the local interactions for realizing the corresponding biological function. Therefore, the topological constraint provides a way for breaking the binding symmetry and reaching the functional specificity. The simulation results also provide several predictions that qualitatively and quantitatively consistent with experiments. Importantly, the K48 linkage model successfully predicted intermediate states. The resulting multi-state energy landscape was further employed to reconcile the seemingly contradictory experimental data on the conformational equilibrium of K48-diUb. Our results further suggest that hydrophobic interactions are dominant in the functional landscapes of K6-, K11-, K33- and K48 diUbs, while electrostatic interactions play a more important role in the functional landscapes of K27, K29, K63 and linear linkages.
-
Assembly and specific recognition of k29- and k33-linked polyubiquitin
Martin A Michel,Paul R Elliott,Kirby N Swatek,Michal Simicek,Jonathan N Pruneda,Jane L Wagstaff,Stefan M V Freund,David Komander
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.molcel.2015.01.042
2015-04-02
Abstract:Protein ubiquitination regulates many cellular processes via attachment of structurally and functionally distinct ubiquitin (Ub) chains. Several atypical chain types have remained poorly characterized because the enzymes mediating their assembly and receptors with specific binding properties have been elusive. We found that the human HECT E3 ligases UBE3C and AREL1 assemble K48/K29- and K11/K33-linked Ub chains, respectively, and can be used in combination with DUBs to generate K29- and K33-linked chains for biochemical and structural analyses. Solution studies indicate that both chains adopt open and dynamic conformations. We further show that the N-terminal Npl4-like zinc finger (NZF1) domain of the K29/K33-specific deubiquitinase TRABID specifically binds K29/K33-linked diUb, and a crystal structure of this complex explains TRABID specificity and suggests a model for chain binding by TRABID. Our work uncovers linkage-specific components in the Ub system for atypical K29- and K33-linked Ub chains, providing tools to further understand these unstudied posttranslational modifications.
-
Beyond K48 and K63: non-canonical protein ubiquitination
Michal Tracz,Wojciech Bialek
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s11658-020-00245-6
2021-01-05
Abstract:Abstract Protein ubiquitination has become one of the most extensively studied post-translational modifications. Originally discovered as a critical element in highly regulated proteolysis, ubiquitination is now regarded as essential for many other cellular processes. This results from the unique features of ubiquitin (Ub) and its ability to form various homo- and heterotypic linkage types involving one of the seven different lysine residues or the free amino group located at its N-terminus. While K48- and K63-linked chains are broadly covered in the literature, the other types of chains assembled through K6, K11, K27, K29, and K33 residues deserve equal attention in the light of the latest discoveries. Here, we provide a concise summary of recent advances in the field of these poorly understood Ub linkages and their possible roles in vivo.
cell biology,biochemistry & molecular biology
-
How phosphorylation by PINK1 remodels the ubiquitin system, a perspective from structure and dynamics.
Chun Tang,Wei-Ping Zhang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.biochem.9b00715
IF: 3.321
2020-01-01
Biochemistry
Abstract:Ubiquitin is an important signaling protein in cells. It functions by covalent attachment to substrate proteins and by noncovalent interactions with target proteins. Ubiquitins are also concatenated, and the resulting polyubiquitins recognize target proteins multivalently with enhanced specificity. The function of ubiquitin is enabled by the conformational dynamics of ubiquitin and polyubiquitins, which spans over 12 orders of magnitude in a time scale. Recently, it was found that ubiquitin can be phosphorylated by PINK1 at residues S65 and T66. Only sparsely populated for the unmodified ubiquitin, a C-terminally retracted conformation is stabilized for phosphorylated ubiquitin and is further enriched at an increasing pH. The modulation of tertiary structure further impacts the quaternary arrangements of ubiquitin subunits in polyubiquitins. Additionally, ubiquitin phosphorylation inhibits the activities of many enzymes responsible for attaching and removing polyubiquitins, thus remodeling the composition and length of polyubiquitins. The phosphorylation-remolded polyubiquitins can then recognize different target proteins. As PINK1 and ubiquitin phosphorylation levels are up-regulated under certain pathophysiological conditions, the remodeled ubiquitin system may be involved in the divergence of cell fate.
-
Molecular determinants of polyubiquitin linkage selection by an HECT ubiquitin ligase
Min Wang,Dongmei Cheng,Junmin Peng,Cecile M Pickart
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/sj.emboj.7601061
2006-04-06
The EMBO Journal
Abstract:Ubiquitin (Ub)-protein ligases (E3s) frequently modify their substrates with multiple Ub molecules in the form of a polyubiquitin (poly-Ub) chain. Although structurally distinct poly-Ub chains (linked through different Ub lysine (Lys) residues) can confer different fates on target proteins, little is known about how E3s select the Lys residue to be used in chain synthesis. Here, we used a combination of mutagenesis, biochemistry, and mass spectrometry to map determinants of linkage choice in chain assembly catalyzed by KIAA10, an HECT (Homologous to E6AP C-Terminus) domain E3 that synthesizes K29- and K48-linked chains. Focusing on the Ub molecule that contributes the Lys residue for chain formation, we found that specific surface residues adjacent to K48 and K29 are critical for the usage of the respective Lys residues in chain synthesis. This direct mechanism of linkage choice bears similarities to the mechanism of substrate site selection in sumoylation catalyzed by Ubc9, but is distinct from the mechanism of chain linkage selection used by the Mms2/Ubc13 (Ub E2 variant (UEV)/E2) complex.
-
Recognition of Poly-Ubiquitins by the Proteasome Through Protein Refolding Guided by Electrostatic and Hydrophobic Interactions
Yi Zhang,Lela Vuković,Till Rudack,Wei Han,Klaus Schulten
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.jpcb.6b01327
2016-01-01
Abstract:Specificity of protein degradation by cellular proteasomes comes from tetra-ubiquitin recognition. We carry out molecular dynamics simulations to characterize how the ubiquitin receptor Rpn10 recognizes in the 26S proteasome K48-linked tetra-ubiquitin. In the binding pose, ubiquitin and Rpn10 interact primarily through hydrophobic patches. However, K48-linked tetra-ubiquitin mostly assumes a closed form in solution prior to binding, in which its hydrophobic patches are not exposed to solvent. Likewise, the hydrophobic ubiquitin interacting motifs (UIMs) of Rpn10 are mostly protected prior to binding. As a result, ubiquitin recognition in the proteasome requires refolding of both K48-linked tetra-ubiquitin and Rpn10. Simulations suggest that conserved complementary electrostatic patterns of Rpn10 and ubiquitins guide protein association (stage 1 in the recognition process), which induces refolding (stage 2), and then facilitates formation of hydrophobic contacts (stage 3). The simulations also explain why Rpn10 has a higher affinity for K48-linked tetra-ubiquitin than for mono-ubiquitin and K48-linked di- and tri-ubiquitins. Simulation results expand on the current view that the flexible arm of Rpn10 acts as an extended fragment of α-helices and flexible coils in the recognition process.
-
Atomic Tailoring of Ubiquitin Side Chains Influences E2‐Mediated Ubiquitin Chain Formation
Haewon Song,Toshiki Mikami,Sohei Majima,Jeffrey W. Bode
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/hlca.202400003
2024-04-26
Helvetica Chimica Acta
Abstract:Ubiquitin (Ub) is a small, highly conserved protein essential for eukaryotic biology, and is unique in its formation of polyubiquitin chains by conjugation to one of its seven lysine side chains. Here we report that atomic tailoring of Ub side chains – i.e. the insertion, deletion, or replacement of specific atoms – has significant and unexpected consequences on the enzymatic conjugation of Ub oligomers by isopeptide bond formation mediated by E2 conjugating enzymes. These studies employed chemical synthesis and ligation methods to prepare numerous specifically tailored Ub monomers on multi‐milligram scales. While some modifications including N‐terminal acylation and methionine replacement did not affect protein folding or Ub chain formation with Ube2K, other modifications had a pronounced effect of oligomerization with Ubc13/Mms2. We observed that Ala46Hse mutation obliterates the ability of this Ub monomer to accept another Ub at Lys63 in Ubc13‐mediated conjugations. Exhaustive replacement of all seven lysines with shorter surrogates Orn, Dab, or Dap essentially blocks Ub chain formation, and in the case of Dap, precludes proper folding of the Ub protein.
chemistry, multidisciplinary
-
Decoding polyubiquitin regulation of K 7. 1 functional expression with engineered linkage-selective deubiquitinases
Sri Karthika Shanmugam,Scott A. Kanner,Xinle Zou,Enoch Amarh,Papiya Choudhury,Rajesh Soni,Robert S. Kass,Henry M. Colecraft
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.09.17.613539
2024-09-17
Abstract:Protein posttranslational modification with distinct polyubiquitin linkage chains is a critical component of the ‘ubiquitin code’ that universally regulates protein expression and function to control biology. Functional consequences of diverse polyubiquitin linkages on proteins are mostly unknown, with progress hindered by a lack of methods to specifically tune polyubiquitin linkages on individual proteins in live cells. Here, we bridge this gap by exploiting deubiquitinases (DUBs) with preferences for hydrolyzing different polyubiquitin linkages: OTUD1 - K63; OTUD4 - K48; Cezanne - K11; TRABID - K29/K33; and USP21 - non-specific. We developed a suite of engineered deubiquitinases (enDUBs) comprised of DUB catalytic domains fused to a GFP- targeted nanobody and used them to investigate polyubiquitin linkage regulation of an ion channel, YFP-KCNQ1. Mass spectrometry of YFP-KCNQ1 expressed in HEK293 cells indicated channel polyubiquitination with K48 (72%) and K63 (24%) linkages being dominant. NEDD4-2 and ITCH both decreased KCNQ1 functional expression but with distinctive polyubiquitination signatures. All enDUBs reduced KCNQ1 ubiquitination but yielded unique effects on channel expression, surface density, ionic currents, and subcellular localization. The pattern of outcomes indicates K11, K29/K33, and K63 chains mediate net KCNQ1-YFP intracellular retention, but achieved in different ways: K11 promotes ER retention/degradation, enhances endocytosis, and reduces recycling; K29/K33 promotes ER retention/degradation; K63 enhances endocytosis and reduces recycling. The pattern of enDUB effects on KCNQ1-YFP differed in cardiomyocytes, emphasizing ubiquitin code mutability. Surprisingly, enDUB-O4 decreased KCNQ1-YFP surface density suggesting a role for K48 in forward trafficking. Lastly, linkage-selective enDUBs displayed varying capabilities to rescue distinct trafficking-deficient long QT syndrome type 1 mutations. The results reveal distinct polyubiquitin chains control different aspects of KCNQ1 functional expression, demonstrate ubiquitin code plasticity, and introduce linkage-selective enDUBs as a potent tool to help demystify the polyubiquitin code.
Molecular Biology
-
Ubiquitination Enzymes
Toshiyuki Habu,Jiyeong Kim
DOI: https://doi.org/10.5772/intechopen.100408
2021-10-18
Abstract:Posttranslational protein modifications by mono- or polyubiquitination are involved in diverse cellular signaling pathways and tightly regulated to ensure proper function of cellular processes. Three types of enzymes, namely ubiquitin-activating enzymes (E1), ubiquitin-conjugating enzymes (E2), and ubiquitin-protein ligases (E3), contribute to ubiquitination. Combinations of E2 and E3 enzymes determine ∼ the fate of their substrates via ubiquitination. The seven lysine residues of ubiquitin, Lys6, Lys11, Lys27, Lys29, Lys33, Lys48, and Lys63, can serve as attachment sites for other ubiquitin molecules. Lys48 (K48)-linked polyubiquitination facilitates recognition of the conjugated protein by proteasome molecules and subsequent proteolytic degradation of the target protein. By contrast, Lys63 (K63)-linked polyubiquitination appears to be involved in polyubiquitin signaling in critical cellular processes, such as DNA repair, regulation of the I-kappaB kinase/NF-kappaB cascade, or T cell receptor signaling, but not protein degradation. In this review, we describe the properties of ubiquitin modification enzymes and the structural interplay among these proteins.
-
Kinetic Constraints in the Specific Interaction Between Phosphorylated Ubiquitin and Proteasomal Shuttle Factors
Ling-Yun Qin,Zhou Gong,Kan Liu,Xu Dong,Chun Tang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/biom11071008
IF: 6.064
2021-01-01
Biomolecules
Abstract:Ubiquitin (Ub) specifically interacts with the Ub-associating domain (UBA) in a proteasomal shuttle factor, while the latter is involved in either proteasomal targeting or self-assembly coacervation. PINK1 phosphorylates Ub at S65 and makes Ub alternate between C-terminally relaxed (pUbRL) and retracted conformations (pUbRT). Using NMR spectroscopy, we show that pUbRL but not pUbRT preferentially interacts with the UBA from two proteasomal shuttle factors Ubqln2 and Rad23A. Yet discriminatorily, Ubqln2-UBA binds to pUb more tightly than Rad23A does and selectively enriches pUbRL upon complex formation. Further, we determine the solution structure of the complex between Ubqln2-UBA and pUbRL and uncover the thermodynamic basis for the stronger interaction. NMR kinetics analysis at different timescales further suggests an indued-fit binding mechanism for pUb-UBA interaction. Notably, at a relatively low saturation level, the dissociation rate of the UBA-pUbRL complex is comparable with the exchange rate between pUbRL and pUbRT. Thus, a kinetic constraint would dictate the interaction between Ub and UBA, thus fine-tuning the functional state of the proteasomal shuttle factors.
-
Solution structure of the HOIL-1L NZF domain reveals a conformational switch regulating linear ubiquitin affinity
Erik Walinda,Kenji Sugase,Naoki Ishii,Masahiro Shirakawa,Kazuhiro Iwai,Daichi Morimoto
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbc.2023.105165
Abstract:Attachment of polyubiquitin (poly-Ub) chains to proteins is a major posttranslational modification in eukaryotes. Linear ubiquitin chain assembly complex, consisting of HOIP (HOIL-1-interacting protein), HOIL-1L (heme-oxidized IRP2 Ub ligase 1), and SHARPIN (Shank-associated RH domain-interacting protein), specifically synthesizes "head-to-tail" poly-Ub chains, which are linked via the N-terminal methionine α-amino and C-terminal carboxylate of adjacent Ub units and are thus commonly called "linear" poly-Ub chains. Linear ubiquitin chain assembly complex-assembled linear poly-Ub chains play key roles in immune signaling and suppression of cell death and have been associated with immune diseases and cancer; HOIL-1L is one of the proteins known to selectively bind linear poly-Ub via its Npl4 zinc finger (NZF) domain. Although the structure of the bound form of the HOIL-1L NZF domain with linear di-Ub is known, several aspects of the recognition specificity remain unexplained. Here, we show using NMR and orthogonal biophysical methods, how the NZF domain evolves from a free to the specific linear di-Ub-bound state while rejecting other potential Ub species after weak initial binding. The solution structure of the free NZF domain revealed changes in conformational stability upon linear Ub binding, and interactions between the NZF core and tail revealed conserved electrostatic contacts, which were sensitive to charge modulation at a reported phosphorylation site: threonine-207. Phosphomimetic mutations reduced linear Ub affinity by weakening the integrity of the linear di-Ub-bound conformation. The described molecular determinants of linear di-Ub binding provide insight into the dynamic aspects of the Ub code and the NZF domain's role in full-length HOIL-1L.
-
Chemical Protein Synthesis Enabled Mechanistic Studies on Molecular Recognition of K27-linked Ubiquitin Chains.
Man Pan,Qingyun Zheng,Shan Ding,Lujia Zhang,Qian Qu,Tian Wang,Danning Hong,Yujing Ren,Lujun Liang,Chunlai Chen,Ziqing Mei,Lei Liu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/anie.201810814
2019-01-01
Abstract:New synthetic strategies that exploited the strengths of both chemoselective ligation and recombinant protein expression were developed to prepare K27 di-ubiquitins (diUb), which enabled mechanistic studies on the molecular recognition of K27-linked Ubs by single-molecule Forster resonance energy transfer (smFRET) and X-ray crystallography. The results revealed that free K27 diUb adopted a compact conformation, whereas upon binding to UCHL3, K27 diUb was remodeled to an open conformation. The K27 isopeptide bond remained rigidly buried inside the diUb moiety during binding, an interesting unique structural feature that may explain the distinctive biological function of K27 Ub chains.
-
Characterizing the monomer-dimer equilibrium of UbcH8/Ube2L6: A combined SAXS and NMR study
Kerem Kahraman,Scott A. Robson,Oktay Göcenler,Cansu M. Yenici,Cansu D. Tozkoparan,Jennifer M. Klein,Volker Dötsch,Emine Sonay Elgin,Arthur L. Haas,Joshua J. Ziarek,Çağdaş Dağ
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2023.04.13.536743
2024-04-14
Abstract:Interferon-stimulated gene-15 (ISG15) is an interferon-induced protein with two ubiquitin-like (Ubl) domains linked by a short peptide chain, and the conjugated protein of the ISGylation system. Similar to ubiquitin and other Ubls, ISG15 is ligated to its target proteins through a series of E1, E2, and E3 enzymes known as Uba7, Ube2L6/UbcH8, and HERC5, respectively. Ube2L6/UbcH8 plays a literal central role in ISGylation, underscoring it as an important drug target for boosting innate antiviral immunity. Depending on the type of conjugated protein and the ultimate target protein, E2 enzymes have been shown to function as monomers, dimers, or both. UbcH8 has been crystalized in both monomeric and dimeric forms, but the functional state is unclear. Here, we used a combined approach of small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy to characterize UbcH8’s oligomeric state in solution. SAXS revealed a dimeric UbcH8 structure that could be dissociated when fused N-terminally to glutathione S-transferase. NMR spectroscopy validated the presence of a concentration-dependent monomer-dimer equilibrium and suggested a backside dimerization interface. Chemical shift perturbation and peak intensity analysis further suggest dimer-induced conformational dynamics at E1 and E3 interfaces - providing hypotheses for the protein’s functional mechanisms. Our study highlights the power of combining NMR and SAXS techniques in providing structural information about proteins in solution.
Biochemistry
-
Structural Basis For The Recognition Of K48-Linked Ub Chain By Proteasomal Receptor Rpn13
Zhu Liu,Xu Dong,Hua-Wei Yi,Ju Yang,Zhou Gong,Yi Wang,Kan Liu,Wei-Ping Zhang,Chun Tang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41421-019-0089-7
IF: 38.079
2019-01-01
Cell Discovery
Abstract:The interaction between K48-linked ubiquitin (Ub) chain and Rpn13 is important for proteasomal degradation of ubiquitinated substrate proteins. Only the complex structure between the N-terminal domain of Rpn13 (Rpn13(NTD)) and Ub monomer has been characterized, while it remains unclear how Rpn13 specifically recognizes K48-linked Ub chain. Using single-molecule FRET, here we show that K48-linked diubiquitin (K48-diUb) fluctuates among distinct conformational states, and a preexisting compact state is selectively enriched by Rpn13(NTD). The same binding mode is observed for full-length Rpn13 and longer K48-linked Ub chain. Using solution NMR spectroscopy, we have determined the complex structure between Rpn13(NTD) and K48-diUb. In this structure, Rpn13(NTD) simultaneously interacts with proximal and distal Ub subunits of K48-diUb that remain associated in the complex, thus corroborating smFRET findings. The proximal Ub interacts with Rpn13(NTD) similarly as the Ub monomer in the known Rpn13(NTD):Ub structure, while the distal Ub binds to a largely electrostatic surface of Rpn13(NTD). Thus, a charge-reversal mutation in Rpn13 NTD weakens the interaction between Rpn13 and K48-linked Ub chain, causing accumulation of ubiquitinated proteins. Moreover, physical blockage of the access of the distal Ub to Rpn13(NTD) with a proximity-attached Ub monomer can disrupt the interaction between Rpn13 and K48-diUb. Taken together, the bivalent interaction of K48-linked Ub chain with Rpn13 provides the structural basis for Rpn13 linkage selectivity, which opens a new window for modulating proteasomal function.
-
Decoding polyubiquitin regulation of KV7. 1 functional expression with engineered linkage-selective deubiquitinases
Sri Karthika Shanmugam,Scott A Kanner,Xinle Zou,Enoch Amarh,Papiya Choudhury,Rajesh Soni,Robert S Kass,Henry M Colecraft
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.09.17.613539
2024-09-17
bioRxiv
Abstract:Protein posttranslational modification with distinct polyubiquitin linkage chains is a critical component of the 'ubiquitin code' that universally regulates protein expression and function to control biology. Functional consequences of diverse polyubiquitin linkages on proteins are mostly unknown, with progress hindered by a lack of methods to specifically tune polyubiquitin linkages on individual proteins in live cells. Here, we bridge this gap by exploiting deubiquitinases (DUBs) with preferences for hydrolyzing different polyubiquitin linkages: OTUD1 - K63; OTUD4 - K48; Cezanne - K11; TRABID - K29/K33; and USP21 - non-specific. We developed a suite of engineered deubiquitinases (enDUBs) comprised of DUB catalytic domains fused to a GFP-targeted nanobody and used them to investigate polyubiquitin linkage regulation of an ion channel, YFP-KCNQ1. Mass spectrometry of YFP-KCNQ1 expressed in HEK293 cells indicated channel polyubiquitination with K48 (72%) and K63 (24%) linkages being dominant. NEDD4-2 and ITCH both decreased KCNQ1 functional expression but with distinctive polyubiquitination signatures. All enDUBs reduced KCNQ1 ubiquitination but yielded unique effects on channel expression, surface density, ionic currents, and subcellular localization. The pattern of outcomes indicates K11, K29/K33, and K63 chains mediate net KCNQ1-YFP intracellular retention, but achieved in different ways: K11 promotes ER retention/degradation, enhances endocytosis, and reduces recycling; K29/K33 promotes ER retention/degradation; K63 enhances endocytosis and reduces recycling. The pattern of enDUB effects on KCNQ1-YFP differed in cardiomyocytes, emphasizing ubiquitin code mutability. Surprisingly, enDUB-O4 decreased KCNQ1-YFP surface density suggesting a role for K48 in forward trafficking. Lastly, linkage-selective enDUBs displayed varying capabilities to rescue distinct trafficking-deficient long QT syndrome type 1 mutations. The results reveal distinct polyubiquitin chains control different aspects of KCNQ1 functional expression, demonstrate ubiquitin code plasticity, and introduce linkage-selective enDUBs as a potent tool to help demystify the polyubiquitin code.