Sustainable Agriculture: from Sweet Sorghum Planting and Ensiling to Ruminant Feeding
Qi Xie,Zhihong Xu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.molp.2019.04.001
IF: 27.5
2019-01-01
Molecular Plant
Abstract:A large proportion of food is composed of crops and meat besides vegetables and fruits. The production of crops and meat needs a large area of land and other resources, such as water, chemical fertilizer, and pesticides. The growing world population increases the demand for food security. Moreover, developing countries with highly dense populations have dramatically changed food composition from mostly crops to more meat and milk, which has forced the adjustment and optimization of agricultural production structure to supply the demand caused by these dramatic changes. For example, after 40 years of economic reform in China, the living standard has considerably increased and is reflected by the stark changes in food demand. From 1990 to 2012 human consumption of crops in China declined by 38%, while consumption of meat and milk increased by 226% (Louie et al., 2015Louie J.C.Y. Flood V.M. Atkinson F.S. Barclay A.W. Brand-Miller J.C. Methodology for assigning appropriate glycaemic index values to an Australian food composition database.J. Food Compost. Anal. 2015; 38: 1-6Crossref Scopus (15) Google Scholar). Considering that the Chinese population totals 1.4 billion, one-quarter of the world's population, this rapidly increasing demand for animal-derived foods and products increases the need for more grains used as feed. Over the last several years, total grain output in China reached 0.6 billion tons per year, more than half of these being used as animal feed. Mass production of livestock has caused many negative environmental consequences. In particular, feeding chickens and pigs not only produces large amounts of fecal waste but also causes large quantities of antibiotic contamination of water and soil in China (Zhang et al., 2015Zhang Q.Q. Ying G.G. Pan C.G. Liu Y.S. Zhao J.L. Comprehensive evaluation of antibiotics emission and fate in the river basins of China: source analysis, multimedia modeling, and linkage to bacterial resistance.Environ. Sci. Technol. 2015; 49: 6772-6782Crossref PubMed Scopus (2499) Google Scholar). Moreover, increased production of grains results in large amounts of crop straw left in the field. Unfortunately, burning the straw in the field, the widely adopted method used for post-harvest treatment of straw, has caused severe air pollution. Straw returning back into soils also potentially increases the rate of occurrence of plant diseases and insect pests in the subsequent season of crop growth. Currently, developed countries are using two types of livestock feeding that appear to be better alternatives for supplying quality meats while reducing negative effects on the environment, namely grass feed and silage. For every 100 units of meat produced from crop-fed livestock consumed around the world, 74 units were from grass-feeding livestock. This ratio was lower in China, where only 17.8 units of its meat products were from grass-feeding animals. In contrast, the ratios of units of meat from grass-feeding to crop-feeding sources in the Unites States was 128:100 and in Australia was 730:100 in 2016, according to the report by the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) of the United Nations (http://www.fao.org/infoods/infoods/tables-and-databases/en). In developed countries, such as Germany, approximately 96% of maize crops were harvested before full maturation for silage to feed cattle for the production of quality meat and milk rather than for the production of grains (Corn Agronomy, http://corn.agronomy.wisc.edu/Default.aspx). Grass-feeding and silage techniques are both more environmentally friendly because all plant biomass is fully consumed by livestock and there is no need to burn straw waste. In addition, the ruminant manure is used as fertilizer in the field to maintain a more green and sustainable agricultural practice. Fostering sustainable practices in agriculture is important to protect our Earth's natural resources while providing food security to the growing populations in developing countries such as China. Food composition changes led the increased demand of food from animal resources, which led China to import a large amount of meat and milk (data from China National Bureau of Statistics, http://data.stats.gov.cn/). Thus, the Chinese government has implemented special policies to adjust and optimize the structure of agricultural production, from the traditional two-component cropping system (grain crops/economic crops) to three-component cropping system (TCCS: grain crops/economic crops/forage grass), for promoting grain conversion and speeding the development of grass-feeding livestock. Additionally, China has developed the largest aquaculture industry in the world to provide high-quality protein foods (FAO data). This is an inevitable trend of the development of modern agriculture in China. To adapt to this adjustment, more scientific research is needed to develop the necessary technology and practice. Currently, maize is one of the most photosynthetic-efficient crops that has been globally planted as grain crop and silage. However, sweet sorghum, another C4 crop, is emerging as an alternative, given that it shows some advantages over maize. Sorghum possesses high tolerance to various abiotic stresses and high water-use efficiency, and thus is more often grown in semi-arid areas, and is expanding into those regions where fresh water is declining. Sorghum is widely planted around the world and its planting field in total constitutes the fifth largest land area among all C4 crops. Except for its use as food in most African countries, sorghum is also widely used as animal feed, especially for pigs and chickens. Sweet sorghum, a variant of sorghum, accumulates high amounts of sugar in the stem and has been adapted as a bioenergy crop (Mullet et al., 2014Mullet J. Morishige D. McCormick R. Truong S. Hilley J. McKinley B. Anderson R. Olson S.N. Rooney W. Energy sorghum—a genetic model for the design of C4 grass bioenergy crops.J. Exp. Bot. 2014; 65: 3479-3489Crossref PubMed Scopus (135) Google Scholar), known as “energy sorghum.” Moreover, due to the high protein content and quality of fibers in the aerial parts, sweet sorghum is widely used as forage, especially as silage for ruminants. The highest protein content in sweet sorghum is reportedly up to 22% in the leaves (Ferraris and Charles-Edwards, 1986Ferraris R. Charles-Edwards D.A. A comparative analysis of the growth of sweet and forage sorghum crops. II. Accumulation of soluble carbohydrates and nitrogen.Aust. J. Agric. Res. 1986; 37: 513-522Crossref Scopus (29) Google Scholar). A meta-analysis of feeding experiments found that cows fed with sweet sorghum silage produced, on average, more milk (1.64 kg/day/cow) with better quality compared with those fed with maize silage (Sánchez-Duarte et al., 2019Sánchez-Duarte J.I. Kalscheur K.F. Garcia A.D. Contreras-Govea F.E. Short communication: meta-analysis of dairy cows fed conventional sorghum or corn silages compared with brown midrib sorghum silage.J. Dairy Sci. 2019; 102: 419-425Abstract Full Text Full Text PDF PubMed Scopus (13) Google Scholar). In addition, sweet sorghum is also a good source as forage for many other reasons. Its high photosynthetic efficiency as a C4 plant coupled with its high nitrogen-use efficiency enables it to produces two to three times more biomass per harvest than the more commonly used silage crop, maize. Moreover, sweet sorghum can vegetatively reproduce new stalks, and thus can be harvested up to four times in each life cycle, in areas with high cumulative temperatures, resulting in even greater biomass production per growing season. In addition, almost all large-production sorghums are from hybrid seeds, which usually produce greater biomass. For example, the sorghum hybrid Tentaka is considered as a crop with strong hybrid vigor; its final biomass was 10- to 14-fold greater than that of its parental lines when grown in an experimental field (Tazoe et al., 2016Tazoe Y. Sazuka T. Yamaguchi M. Saito C. Ikeuchi M. Kanno K. Kojima S. Hirano K. Kitano H. Kasuga S. et al.Growth properties and biomass production in the hybrid C4 crop sorghum bicolor.Plant Cell Physiol. 2016; 57: 944-952Crossref PubMed Scopus (12) Google Scholar). Sorghum can also tolerate a number of different abiotic stresses, especially salt and drought stresses. Roughly 15% of the world's land naturally contains high concentrations of salt (<0.7% NaCl) that inhibit the growth of most types of crops. Furthermore, nearly 50% of arable land is predicted to become salinized by 2050 (Jamil et al., 2011Jamil A. Riaz S. Ashraf M. Foolad M.R. Gene expression profiling of plants under salt stress.Crit. Rev. Plant Sci. 2011; 30: 435-458Crossref Scopus (415) Google Scholar). There are hybrid breeds of sweet sorghum that can grow well under saline conditions with less than a 25% reduction of biomass compared with that of hybrids grown in a non-saline field (Tang et al., 2018Tang S. Wang Z. Chen C. Xie P. Xie Q. The prospect of sweet sorghum as the source for high biomass crop.J. Agric. Sci. Bot. 2018; 2: 5-11Google Scholar). Therefore, planting sweet sorghum in these large areas of marginal land is a viable option to help ensure food security. In an energy sorghum crop, the high nitrogen-use efficiency was found to be higher than that of another monocot, Miscanthus, which produces high yields of biomass as an energy plant. High biomass yield, efficient nitrogen recycling, and preferential accumulation of stem biomass with low nitrogen content contributes to energy sorghum's elevated nitrogen-use efficiency (Rosenblueth et al., 2018Rosenblueth M. Ormeño-Orrillo E. López-López A. Rogel M.A. Reyes-Hernández B.J. Martínez-Romero J.C. Reddy P.M. Martínez-Romero E. Nitrogen fixation in cereals.Front. Microbiol. 2018; 9: 1794Crossref PubMed Scopus (119) Google Scholar). Thus, sweet sorghum has great potential to be an eco-friendly crop that requires less nitrogen fertilizer application than other commonly planted crops. Livestock that provides meat and milk products is an important high-energy resource for human beings. Different kinds of livestock require different forms of forage depending on the type of animals. Ruminants are mammals with hooves and notably a specialized stomach called a rumen, which aids digestion of all plant biomass and acquisition of nutrients from the fibrous tissues of plants rather than the more easily digestible parts such as the seeds. Within the rumen are anaerobic microbes, such as protozoa and some fungi, which are responsible for breaking down the complex cellulosic materials into sugars for fermentation. Plant biomass digestion is facilitated by anaerobic microbes within the rumen that ferment the complex fibers primarily consisting of celluloses. The large proportion of crop biomass called straw is usually classified as waste in agriculture. Crop straw mainly contains cellulose that is suitably used as ruminant feed, and subsequently the animal dung is a good resource of farm manure. Thus, selecting high-biomass-producing C4 crops such as sorghum in combination with intensive ruminant farming may be better practices for meat production to support modern eco-agriculture worldwide. Application of silage as feed greatly increases the energy transfer from plant biomass to quality food, because silage bacteria degrades fibers to release the cellulose for more efficient digestion by ruminants by up to 65% in comparison with only 5%–15% from dry grass feeding (Nichols et al., 1998Nichols S.W. Froetschel M.A. Amos H.E. Ely L.O. Effects of fiber from tropical corn and forage sorghum silages on intake, digestion, and performance of lactating dairy cows.J. Dairy Sci. 1998; 81: 2383-2393Abstract Full Text PDF PubMed Scopus (28) Google Scholar). In silage fermentation, the entire green plant (not just the grain) of fodder is sealed off in a high-moisture container. The microbes then work to break down cellulose and carbohydrates to produce the necessary volatile fatty acids (VFAs) for energetic metabolic processes such as the tricarboxylic acid cycle (Henderson et al., 2015Henderson G. Cox F. Ganesh S. Jonker A. Young W. Janssen P.H. Rumen microbial community composition varies with diet and host, but a core microbiome is found across a wide geographical range.Sci. Rep. 2015; 5: 14567Crossref PubMed Scopus (760) Google Scholar). By lowering the pH, the sealed containers create a hostile environment for competing bacteria that might cause spoilage of silage. The VFAs thus act as natural preservatives, in the same way that lactic acid can preserve milk in the form of yogurt and cheese, or vinegar (dilute acetic acid) preserves vegetables in pickled form. The supplement of lacto-bacteria to silage production is also an advantageous technique to maximize the production of lactic acid, folic acid, and vitamin B12 (Hugenholtz and Smid, 2002Hugenholtz J. Smid E.J. Nutraceutical production with food-grade microorganisms.Curr. Opin. Biotechnol. 2002; 13: 497-507Crossref PubMed Scopus (128) Google Scholar). Different from maize and other crops, most sorghum accumulates high amounts of tannins in the seeds. Numerous studies report that, depending on their concentration and nature, hydrolyzable tannins and condensed tannins can have adverse or beneficial effects on ruminants. Tannins can be beneficial; they have been shown to promote milk production, lambing percentage, and growth of wool, as well as reducing the risk of rumen bloat (Patra and Saxena, 2011Patra A.K. Saxena J. Exploitation of dietary tannins to improve rumen metabolism and ruminant nutrition.J. Sci. Food Agric. 2011; 91: 24-37Crossref PubMed Scopus (464) Google Scholar). In addition, in an in vitro rumen fermentation experiment, the supplement of 15 mg of condensed tannins in 500 mg of total oven-dried guinea grass reduced methane (CH4) production by 47% (Tan et al., 2011Tan H.Y. Sieo C.C. Abdullah N. Liang J.B. Huang X.D. Ho Y.W. Effects of condensed tannins from Leucaena on methane production, rumen fermentation and populations of methanogens and protozoa in vitro.Anim. Feed Sci. Technol. 2011; 169: 185-193Crossref Scopus (159) Google Scholar). This discovery demonstrates another important advantage of using sweet sorghum silage over other crops, namely its potential for lower methane production. Ruminants are known to produce a large proportion of CH4 that acts as a greenhouse gas, warming the planet's surface temperatures. By promoting strategies such as the use of sweet sorghum as silage to feed livestock, the concept of applying more efficient and green eco-techniques is becoming more accepted in agricultural practice across many provinces in China. In the countries such as China, high-quality meat production will grow along with the improvement in living standards. Therefore, we must continue to develop and improve technology and practice to meet the needs of protecting our environment while feeding the growing appetite for meat. Through analyses of food demand, land conditions for agriculture, and sustainable agriculture for growing populations, we believe that current agricultural policy and techniques need to be reviewed, especially for developing countries. The strategy of planting highly photosynthetic-efficient crops, such as sorghum and maize, and using them not only for grain but also for the biomass production to convert to high-quality foods such as meat and milk, is needed for the growing populations of developing countries. Which livestock to be selected is also a critical point for increasing energy transfer from plant to livestock and for promoting environment-friendly farming practice. Ruminants are the first choice as they can process all materials in their feed, avoiding the disposal of such materials as straw that would be burned if the crop cultivated for grain production is used as pig and chicken feed. Furthermore, developing high-quality silage through manipulation of microbial strains and silage production techniques to improve nutrition of the feed, and energy transfer from feed to animal, should improve technologies and agricultural practices. Although maize is the more common silage crop, sweet sorghum is now emerging as an alternative silage crop throughout the world, due to its wider range of environmental tolerances and higher production of biomass and protein content. We propose a high-efficient and eco-friendly strategy combining sweet sorghum and ruminants for green and sustainable agriculture, as shown in Figure 1. Despite many advantages, there is still room for sweet sorghum improvement. Tannins have a role in insect resistance and herbivore deterrence; however, high contents of tannins in sweet sorghum seeds can affect the feeding behavior of ruminants. Harvest of sweet sorghum without seeds will affect the starch contents in the silage, and thus sweet sorghum with low tannin in seeds will be a future targeting aspect for breeding. Since the tannin biogenesis pathway has been extensively studied in sorghum, it would not be difficult to breed sweet sorghum varieties with the desired tannin content in the forage. In addition, development of herbicide-tolerant sorghum is also necessary for large-scale production. Herbicide-tolerant genes, such as those in amino acid and photosynthesis pathways whose mutations result in herbicide tolerance, detected in closely related monocots, may be used to genetically engineer herbicide-tolerant sorghum. Because the proteins mainly accumulate in the leaf tissues of sweet sorghum, breeding varieties with bigger leaf area and more leaves is another potential way to improve sorghum as forage. Regulating those genes associated with light response and photoperiod could strengthen this point. To further improve sweet sorghum as forage, later harvest of sweet sorghum with seeds will increase the starch content, but later harvest will affect the fiber quality. To improve ruminant digestibility, a number of bmr mutants have been used in breeding forage sweet sorghum to reduce lignin contents, and the discovery of the role of tricin in lignin-cellulose structure (Eudes et al., 2017Eudes A. Dutta T. Deng K. Jacquet N. Sinha A. Benites V.T. Baidoo E.E.K. Richel A. Sattler S.E. Northen T.R. et al.SbCOMT (Bmr12) is involved in the biosynthesis of tricin-lignin in sorghum.PLoS One. 2017; 12: e0178160Crossref PubMed Scopus (43) Google Scholar) will further enable our ability to manipulate digestion of cellulose in sweet sorghum silage. To increase the dry weight content in sweet sorghum we could manage the alleles of NAC family gene Dry (Zhang et al., 2018Zhang L.M. Leng C.Y. Luo H. Wu X.Y. Liu Z.Q. Zhang Y.M. Zhang H. Xia Y. Shang L. Liu C.M. et al.Sweet sorghum originated through selection of dry, a plant-specific NAC transcription factor gene.Plant Cell. 2018; 30: 2286-2307Crossref PubMed Scopus (38) Google Scholar) in the breeding to generate a semi-dry stem variation. Aerial parts of the well-known Chinese herbs, such as Gouji, Astragalus mongholicus, and Liquiritia glycyrrhiza, which are eaten by ruminants such as sheep and cattle while grazing grasslands, could be collected and used in proper proportions as supplements in sweet sorghum silage to improve meat and milk quality as well as animal health. Sorghum planting can negatively affect subsequent crops planted in the same fields, especially dicot crops. Recent physiological and molecular studies revealed that an allelopathic metabolite, sorgoleone, released from roots into the soil, was the “crime culprit”. Because the biosynthesis pathway of sorgoleone is well known, we may be able to genetically manipulate sorghum to secrete less sorgoleone into the soil. In short, available genomic, transcriptomic, and other “-omics” datasets as well as new breeding technologies such as molecular marker-assisted breeding and genome-editing technology can help us engineer the ideal sweet sorghum silage in the future. Besides breeding, the field management practice, harvest timing and methods to meet the minimum dry weight content, and forage processing technologies should also be improved in the future. This work was financially supported by grants from the National Key R&D Program of China (2018YFD1000704), the Key Deployment Projects of the Chinese Academy of Sciences (KFZD-SW-112-01), and Agricultural Breeding Program in NingXia Province (2014NYYZ0401).