Disassembly Time Estimation for Used Smartphones Based on Maynard Operation Sequence Technology
Xiaojing Chu,Lin Li,Fu Zhao,John W. Sutherland,Fengfu Yin
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cie.2024.110291
IF: 7.18
2024-01-01
Computers & Industrial Engineering
Abstract:The disassembly phase plays a crucial role in improving sustainability and circular performance, in particular when carried out through manual disassembly. At present, the Maynard operation sequence technique (MOST) for determining disassembly time can avoid subjectivity and is aligned with actual disassembly actions. However, the MOST suffers from inaccurate action analysis and the omission of some disassembly actions, resulting in lower accuracy for the disassembly time estimation of used smartphones with existing index values. To address this issue, the paper proposes an improved method based on the MOST to improve the accuracy of used smartphone disassembly time estimation. Based on the improved general movement index table, the improved tool usage index table, and the established disassembly time calculation model, the disassembly time for a given sequence of actions and target parts is estimated by the proposed method. One of the innovative aspects of the proposed method is the definition of seven disassembly action units, which can provide better insights into which disassembly action is the most time-consuming, and how the product design could be improved. The proposed method is validated through a case study involving manual disassembly for four types of used smartphones, namely Redmi 1, Huawei Enjoy 5, Meizu MX4 Pro, and iPhone 6. The experimental results show that the overall accuracy of the proposed method is approximately 98% in disassembly time estimation, which is improved by 5.7% compared to MOST. Moreover, the distribution analysis for each unit revealed that disconnection is the most time-consuming action followed by surface treatment, and action distance-gain control and action distance-placement. If the Redmi 1 employs the same back cover connection as the Huawei Enjoy 5, the disconnecting time can be shortened by 18.6% of the total disassembly time. This work verifies the applicability of the proposed method and guides for used smartphone design improvements.