Trust in the Doctor–Patient Relationship in Chinese Public Hospitals: Evidence for Hope
Yangyang Han,Reidar K Lie,Zhenlin Li,Rui Guo
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/PPA.S352636
2022-03-05
Patient Preference and Adherence
Abstract:Yangyang Han, 1 Reidar K Lie, 2 Zhenlin Li, 3 Rui Guo 3 1 Department of Outpatient, Beijing Hospital of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Capital Medical University, Beijing, People's Republic of China; 2 Department of Philosophy, University of Bergen, Bergen, Norway; 3 School of Public Health, Capital Medical University, Beijing, People's Republic of China Correspondence: Rui Guo, School of Public Health, Capital Medical University, No. 10 Xitoutiao, Youanmenwai, Fengtai District, Beijing, 100069, People's Republic of China, Tel +86-10-83911573, Email Purpose: Trust is an essential component in a successful health care relationship. Doctor–patient trust involves the subjects of both sides, including the direction of patients' trust in physicians (patients' perception) and physicians' trust in patients (physicians' perception). This study aims to assess the status quo and explore suggestions for improving trust between doctors and patients. Patients and Methods: In May 2018, we collected data from six representative hospitals in Beijing, China, including 610 questionnaires (310 physicians and 300 patients). Participants were Chinese-speaking, age 14 and older, who expressed their opinions clearly. Kruskal–Wallis H -test and Wilcoxon rank sum test were used to analyze the difference in the trust scores of the responses. Results: Based on the doctor and patient characteristics, the data show that inpatients are trusted more than outpatients, and patients who often visit the clinic are more doubtful of doctors. The family trust is the highest, and social trust is the lowest. In general, the degree of trust between doctors and patients is good, but the score of physicians (Mean=3.87; SD=0.79) is lower than that of patients (Mean=4.05; SD=0.76). Physicians' evaluation of the degree of trust tends to be more negative than patients'. Conclusion: In spite of recent negative press reports, there remains a high degree of trust between patients and doctors in Beijing. Despite this, one should not be complacent. We need to explore the root cause of the trust between doctors and patients from a deeper perspective to promote better medical services to meet the health needs of patients. Keywords: China, doctor–patient relationship, trust, public hospitals Since 1978 China has experienced a period with several major health care system reforms. 1,2 This has had a profound effect on the doctor-patient relationship in China. 3 Public hospitals are the backbone of the Medical institutions in China, but they face the pressure of insufficient funds and demands of self-reliance. 4 Although medical treatment has improved to ensure a more comprehensive medical service level, the health demand and supply gap still exists. 5 High drug prices, difficult consultations, and irrational drug usage are obstacles for people seeking consultations from a doctor in recent years. 6 People's demand for medical services has increased significantly. The imbalance between supply and demand because of existing high drug costs reports, and excessive medical treatments has brought pressure on the medical system. 7 It wastes limited medical resources and causes tensions between doctors and patients and affects the people's trust in the whole medical system. 8 For nearly ten years, the incidence of medical disputes in China has been rising in a straight line. 9 The intensification of doctor-patient conflicts has seriously affected the normal order of diagnosis and treatment in hospitals. 10 This has led to introducing a new word among medical professionals, called "medical harassers" (Yi nao). 7 It is the conflicts between patients and doctors and the people in charge of organizing the trouble in order to obtain huge profits. In the doctor-patient conflicts, the patients obviously show indignation and hatred; Patients often suspect the actions of doctors and their motives and intentions. This vague uncertainty greatly weakens doctor-patient trust and leads to confrontation between doctors and patients. 9 Mass media sometimes has not played a positive role in harmonizing the relationship. 11 And the distorted coverage of such doctors in the Chinese media has exacerbated tensions between doctors and patients. 12 The report overemphasized the tension between doctors and patients and overplayed the faults between doctors and patients, which increased the hostility of patients towards their doctors. 13 Doctors often take a neutral attitude, frequently change treatment plans, refer patients, and consult with many experts. However, some media report such phenomen -Abstract Truncated-
medicine, general & internal