Does "National Civilized City" policy mitigate air pollution in China? A spatial Durbin difference-in-differences analysis

Lei Jiang,Zinan Zhang,Bo Zhang,Shixiong He

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s12889-024-18671-y

IF: 4.5

2024-05-05

BMC Public Health

Abstract:"National Civilized City" (NCC) is regarded as China's highest honorary title and most valuable city brand. To win and maintain the "golden city" title, municipal governments must pay close attention to various key appraisal indicators, mainly environmental ones. In this study we verify whether cities with the title are more likely to mitigate SO 2 pollution. We adopt the spatial Durbin difference-in-differences (DID) model and use panel data of 283 Chinese cities from 2003 to 2018 to analyze the local (direct) and spillover effects (indirect) of the NCC policy on SO 2 pollution. We find that SO 2 pollution in Chinese cities is not randomly distributed in geography, suggesting the existence of spatial spillovers and possible biased estimates. Our study treats the NCC policy as a quasi-experiment and incorporates spatial spillovers of NCC policy into a classical DID model to verify this assumption. Our findings show: (1) The spatial distribution of SO 2 pollution represents strong spatial spillovers, with the most highly polluted regions mainly situated in the North China Plain. (2) The Moran's I test results confirms significant spatial autocorrelation. (3) Results of the spatial Durbin DID models reveal that the civilized cities have indeed significantly mitigated SO 2 pollution, indicating that cities with the honorary title are acutely aware of the environment in their bid to maintain the golden city brand. As importantly, we notice that the spatial DID term is also significant and negative, implying that neighboring civilized cities have also mitigated their own SO 2 pollution. Due to demonstration and competition effects, neighboring cities that won the title ostensibly motivates local officials to adopt stringent policies and measures for lowering SO 2 pollution and protecting the environment in competition for the golden title. The spatial autoregressive coefficient was significant and positive, indicating that SO 2 pollution of local cities has been deeply affected by neighbors. A series of robustness check tests also confirms our conclusions. Policy recommendations based on the findings for protecting the environment and promoting sustainable development are proposed.

public, environmental & occupational health

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### The Problem the Paper Attempts to Solve

This paper aims to explore whether China's "National Civilized City" (NCC) policy can significantly reduce sulfur dioxide (SO₂) pollution in cities and whether this impact can spread to neighboring cities.

#### Main Research Content:
1. **Background and Motivation**:
- China's rapid economic growth relies on natural resources, especially fossil fuels, leading to severe environmental pollution problems, particularly sulfur dioxide pollution.
- The government has taken a series of measures to mitigate pollution, including the establishment of the "National Civilized City" evaluation activity, encouraging local governments to participate in environmental protection.

2. **Research Methods**:
- Using the Spatial Durbin Difference-in-Differences (DID) model, the paper analyzes panel data from 283 cities in China from 2003 to 2018.
- The study examines the direct effects and spillover effects (indirect effects) of the NCC policy on urban sulfur dioxide pollution.

3. **Main Findings**:
- The distribution of sulfur dioxide pollution in Chinese cities shows significant spatial clustering, with the North China Plain region being the most severely polluted.
- Cities that have obtained the NCC title have indeed significantly reduced sulfur dioxide pollution.
- Neighboring civilized cities are also influenced by the demonstration effect, adopting strict environmental protection measures, thereby reducing their own sulfur dioxide pollution.

4. **Policy Recommendations**:
- Based on the research results, a series of policy recommendations are proposed to protect the environment and promote sustainable development.

Through this research, the paper aims to verify the effectiveness of the NCC policy in reducing sulfur dioxide pollution and its spatial spillover effects, providing scientific evidence for the formulation of effective environmental protection policies.