Abstract:Ecological restoration programs are expected to control environmental deterioration and enhance ecosystem functions under a scenario of increasing human disturbance. The largest ecological restoration program ever implemented in China, the first round of the countrywide Grain for Green Program (GGP), finished in 2010. However, it is not known whether the ecological changes that resulted from the GGP met the restoration goal across the whole implementation region. In this study, we monitored and assessed the ecological changes in the whole GGP region in China over the lifetime of the first round of implementation (2000–2010), by establishing a comprehensive assessment indicator system composed of ecosystem pattern, ecosystem quality (EQ), and key ecosystem services (ESs). Remote sensing interpretation, ecological model simulations based on multi-source images, and trend analysis were used to generate land use and land cover (LULC) datasets and estimate ES and ESs indicators. Results showed that while forest increased by 0.77%, artificial land increased more intensely by 22.38%, and cropland and grassland decreased by 1.81% and 0.68%, respectively. The interconversion of cropland and forest played a primary role in ecosystem pattern change. The increase in ecosystem quality measures, including fractional vegetation cover (0.1459% yr−1), leaf area index (0.0121 yr−1), and net primary productivity (2.6958 gC m−2 yr−1), and the mitigation of ecosystem services deterioration in soil water loss (−0.0841 t ha yr−1) and soil wind loss (−1.0071 t ha yr−1) in the GGP region, indicated the positive ecological change in the GGP region to some extent, while southern GGP subregions improved more than the those in the north on the whole. The GGP implementation other than climate change impacted ecological change, with contributions of 14.23%, 9.94%, 8.23%, 30.45%, and 18.05% in the ecological outputs mentioned above, respectively. However, the water regulation did not improve (−2283 t km−2 yr−1), revealing trade-offs between ecosystem services and inappropriate afforestation in ecological restoration programs. Future GGP implementation should change the practice of large-scale afforestation, and focus more on the restoration of existing forest and cultivation of young plantings, formulating rational and specific plans and designs for afforestation areas through the establishment of near-natural vegetation communities, instead of single-species plantations, guided by regional climate and geographical characteristics.

Analysis of Net Primary Productivity of Retired Farmlands in the Grain-for-Green Project in China from 2011 to 2020

Significant trade-off for the impact of Grain-for-Green Programme on ecosystem services in North-western Yunnan, China

Returning Cropland to Grassland as a Potential Method for Increasing Carbon Storage in Dry-Hot Valley Areas

Net Primary Productivity Increased on the Loess Plateau Following Implementation of the Grain to Green Program

Chinese Grain for Green Program Led to Highly Increased Soil Organic Carbon Levels: a Meta-Analysis.

The Chinese Grain for Green Programme: assessing the carbon sequestered via land reform

A meta‐analysis reveals increases in soil organic carbon following the restoration and recovery of croplands in Southwest China

Evaluating net primary productivity dynamics and their response to land-use change in the loess plateau after the 'Grain for Green' program

Effects of the Main Ecological Restoration Projects on Grassland Carbon Sequestration in Ningxia on the Loess Plateau

Regional Contribution and Attribution of the Interannual Variation of Net Primary Production in the Yellow River Basin, China

Impacts of land conversion and management measures on net primary productivity in semi-arid grassland

Carbon Sequestration Potential in Stands under the Grain for Green Program in Southwest China

Carbon potential of China's Grain to Green Program and its contribution to the carbon target

Spatiotemporal Changes in Leaf Area and Carbon Sequestration of Terrestrial Vegetation in China over the Last Two Decades

Evolution and Mechanism Analysis of Terrestrial Ecosystems in China with Respect to Gross Primary Productivity

Quantifying the Contributions of Vegetation Dynamics and Climate Factors to the Enhancement of Vegetation Productivity in Northern China (2001–2020)

The Grain for Green Project Induced Land Cover Change in the Loess Plateau: A Case Study with Ansai County, Shanxi Province, China

Response of net primary production to land use and land cover change in mainland China since the late 1980s

Assessing the Impact of Restoration-Induced Land Conversion and Management Alternatives on Net Primary Productivity in Inner Mongolian Grassland, China

The Grain-for-Green Project Offsets Warming-Induced Soil Organic Carbon Loss and Increases Soil Carbon Stock in Chinese Loess Plateau.

Did Ecological Restoration Hit Its Mark? Monitoring and Assessing Ecological Changes in the Grain for Green Program Region Using Multi-source Satellite Images