Clinical Observations on Air-raid Casualties—II*
R. T. Grant,E. Reeve
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.2.4209.329
1941-09-06
British Medical Journal
Abstract:almost entirely "interesting" cases of rare diseases or with advanced physical signs. This has some justification, for the specialist naturally collects cases in his own specialty, and the loudest murmur is the one for the beginner to listen to. On the other hand, the senior student who has learnt to recognize physical signs can apply his knowledge in clinics, which is the nearest thing to general practice that hospitals provide. Out-patient clinics are fairly good for this purpose if they are not overcrowded, but municipal clinics that some London students go to are better, and the dispensary system in Scotland probably best of all. Another major problem in general practice is the maladjusted, possibly mildly neurotic, patient. A field in which a great deal of good can be done, it is almost entirely neglected by present-day medical education. Psychology consists of a few lectures in the major psychoses, illustrated by the most amusing inmates that the mental hospital can produce. This is a most important omission that can and should be rectified. Also in general practice in industrial centres diseases due to working conditions and industrial processes are constantly being met, yet training in recognizing them is confined to possibly two lectures in a public health course. In all these ways could medical education be more closely related to the needs of the doctor after qualifying. The manner in which teaching is carried out falls short of the ideal. Units tend to be much too large for the best results, as, particularly in the wards, the information doe3 not reach many of the listeners, and there is no opportunity at all of asking questions or taking part in discussion. Lectures are often compulsory, in which case the student is denied even the simple criticism of stopping away, and the lectures may become slovenly as a result. Reading from textbooks has been redundant since the invention of printing. During the last two years, when many schools have been evacuated, it has been found that the formation of seminar groups between teacher and students, with free discussion, has led to the most successful results. At the same time the ability to criticize lecturers has resulted in marked improvements. Thus the formation of staff student groups to discuss the organizational problems in a school is found to be effective from all points of view, revolutionary though it may seem. The other alternative suggestion is that the staff of a medical school should have had a pedagogical training, or at least be chosen for teaching ability rather than for research. Many feel, however, that this would kill any scientific life in the teaching through replacing scientists by orators, for if the research worker is good he will have such a clear idea of his subject that he cannot talk badly about it. The way forward shown by helpful mutual criticism between teachers and taught seems to be by far the most promising. The provision of smaller teaching units also enables students to get far more practical experience of the various techniques, such as lumbar puncture, intravenous infusions, and so on, that he will need to be able to do as a doctor. Opportunity for this varies greatly in various medical schools, and it cannot be doubted that the complete divorcement of the student from practical work is very bad. On the other hand, there is often required a tremendous amount of attendance at operations which in fact can demonstrate nothing to those more than a yard from the operative site. Perhaps most important of all is training in casualty work, for minor surgery plays a large part in a practising doctor's life. The aerial warfare of to-day makes it doubly important; in fact, the teaching of this subject has been greatly extended since the beginning of the war, but there is doubtless still room for improvement in some places. Conclusion A great many of the points mentioned can be easily changed by local adjustment; and usually the staff are very willing to accept suggestions for improvement. Broadly, however, the aims of medical teaching can only be altered, so that they fulfil the needs of the doctor and enable him to serve the community to the best of his ability, on a national scale. The British Medical Students' Association is going to present, by invitation, a memorandum to the Planning Commission set up by the B.M.A., and by this means it is hoped that the necessary changes will be effected.