Abstract:Accurate prediction of soot formation and evolution remains a formidable challenge due to the complex interaction between gas-phase composition and solid-phase particles. Recent studies have shown that the choice of gas-phase mechanisms is of primary importance in affecting predictability. In this work, a systematic analysis of ethylene (C 2 H 4 ) combustion mechanisms denoted as KAUST, Stanford, Aachen, Polimi, ABF, DLR/UT, Naples, Caltech, and SJTU, which have been widely used in the soot community, is performed to investigate their differences in fundamental chemistry, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon (PAH) chemistry, and soot prediction. It is found that the nine mechanisms exhibit large differences even in predicting canonical combustion properties (e.g., ignition delay time, laminar flame speed, and extinction strain rate), indicating significant variations in the fundamental chemistry. This is due to the fact that although most mechanisms share very similar dominant fuel-oxidation reactions, there are notable differences in the rate coefficients of sensitive reactions used in these mechanisms. Owing to the uncertainties in the fundamental chemistry, the predictions of C 2 H 2 from the nine mechanisms show significant differences, which contributes to the differences in soot precursor prediction, in conjunction with the difference in benzene (A1) formation pathways demonstrated by the element flux analysis of the C atom. Furthermore, it is found that PAHs containing two rings play a dominant role in soot formation for most mechanisms. Moreover, it is observed that while Caltech and SJTU significantly under estimate soot formation, they reasonably reproduce its sensitivity to strain rate. These results indicate that despite substantial advances in the development of C 2 H 4 oxidation and PAH formation chemistry, the various existing mechanisms lead to significant differences in predicting soot concentrations which can be traced back to considerable differences in both fundamental chemistry and PAH chemistry. This suggests that the fundamental chemistry should be calibrated or improved before further development of PAH chemistry and soot models.

Growth of Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbon and Soot Inception by in silico Simulation

The Growth of PAHs and Soot in the Post-Flame Region

The site effect on PAHs formation in HACA-based mass growth process

Elucidating the polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons involved in soot inception

Large Eddy Simulation of Soot Formation in a Turbulent Lifted Flame with a Discretized Population Balance and a Reduced Kinetic Mechanism

Study on Soot Nucleation and Growth from PAHs and Some Reactive Species at Flame Temperatures by ReaxFF Molecular Dynamics

Rapid soot inception via α-alkynyl substitution of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons

Formation and Evolvement of Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbon and Soot in Combustion Process of Diesel Engine

Stochastic Simulation of Soot Formation Evolution in Counterflow Diffusion Flames

A computational study of ethylene–air sooting flames: Effects of large polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons

Soot Formation of N-Decane Pyrolysis: A Mechanistic View from ReaxFF Molecular Dynamics Simulation

Formation of Incipient Soot Particles from Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons: A ReaxFF Molecular Dynamics Study

Modeling of Soot and Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons in Diesel Diffusion Combustion

Large Eddy Simulation of Soot Formation in a Laboratory Pulverized Coal Flame

Role of Carbon-Addition and Hydrogen-Migration Reactions in Soot Surface Growth.

Advanced characterization of soot precursors via excitation emission matrices fluorescence spectroscopy and molecular modeling

Simulation of the Formation and Growth of Soot Aerosol Particles in a Premixed Combustion Process Using a Soot Aerosol Dynamics Model

Development of a Phenomenological Soot Model Coupled with a Skeletal PAH Mechanism for Practical Engine Simulation

A systematic analysis of chemical mechanisms for ethylene oxidation and PAH formation

Study on the formation process of soot from 2,5-dimethylfuran pyrolysis by ReaxFF molecular dynamics

Role of Spin-Triplet Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons in Soot Surface Growth