Exploring the chaotic relationships of Annelida produced by mitogenomic data: skew inversions and their effect on evolutionary studies

Hong-Peng Lei,Ivan Jakovlić,Hong Zou,Dong Zhang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-1828162/v1
2022-01-01
Abstract:Abstract BackgroundSeveral studies have shown that the phylogeny of Annelida is pronouncedly data- and methodology-influenced. Inversions of the origin of replication (ORI) in mitochondrial genomes may interfere with phylogenetic reconstruction, as well as other evolutionary studies in Arthropoda. ORI events and their impacts on evolutionary analyses remain very poorly understood in other metazoan lineages. This also includes the Annelida, in which a handful of studies merely reported inverted base composition skews in isolated lineages.ResultsWe observed that some of the inverted-skew species exhibited long branches and ‘rogue’ behaviour in phylogenetic analyses. This made us hypothesise that ORI events may be a major factor interfering with phylogenetic reconstruction in Annelida. We first inferred the evolutionary history of ORI events in Annelida on a dataset comprising almost all available annelid mitogenomes (174). We identified twelve new ORI species and six ORI events in total. Most ORI events occurred at lower taxonomic levels (species, genus, family), but one was mapped to a common ancestor of sister-families Sabellidae & Serpulidae, and one to the entire suborder Hirudiniformes. In comparison to non-ORI lineages, ORI lineages exhibited a higher: mutational saturation, number of nonsynonymous substitutions, dN/dS ratios, hydropathicity of the translated gene products, and compositional heterogeneity; but a lower codon bias index. They also exhibited relaxed purifying selection pressures. We found several putative examples of ORI events causing artefactual clustering of lineages with homoplastic base composition biases in phylogenetic analyses. We attempted several different strategies aimed at stabilizing the topology, such as the removal of ORI species and third codon sites, but none of these managed to fully stabilize the topology.ConclusionsWe inferred the evolutionary history of skews in annelids and explored the underlying mechanisms by which ORI events may cause artefactual clustering. We conclude that ORI events may be one of the causes for the chaotic relationships of Annelida. In the context of currently available strategies for phylogenetic reconstruction, mitogenomes are not suitable for studying the phylum-level and class-level phylogeny of Annelida. Given the strong evidence that ORIs may interfere with evolutionary studies in annelids, researchers should pay close attention to indications of skew inversions.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?